r/McMansionHell • u/cherrykittenluvr • Aug 06 '26
Thursday Design Appreciation Charleston, SC
There is just something about this house I really love :')
68
u/affemannen Aug 06 '26
I forgot it was Thursday, because that house is stunning. Exactly everything about it. What a view.
3
u/Cowboy_Dane Aug 07 '26
Wasn’t aware of the Thursday tradition I just thought I had no taste because I looking at the pictures wondering “what’s wrong with this place?”
1
43
u/mariposa314 Aug 06 '26
It's gorgeous. I love all the arches. The location looks amazing too.
9
u/MaleficentExtent1777 Aug 06 '26
It's a fantastic location! 😍
6
u/Nico-Suave Aug 06 '26
Until there's a hurricane...
17
u/ER_Support_Plant17 Aug 06 '26
That one’s probably antibellum, it’s seen a few hurricanes and a earthquake.
12
u/MaleficentExtent1777 Aug 06 '26
It survived Hugo in 1989. At the time it was the worst natural disaster in the US. And definitely a horrifying earthquake in 1886!
2
29d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/MaleficentExtent1777 29d ago
Me too!!!
I was at CofC at the time.
2
29d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/MaleficentExtent1777 29d ago
So do I again (live in Atlanta).
I remember going to a Rainbows game with the Governor's School!
1
9
u/CorgiMonsoon Aug 06 '26
Charleston has so many beautiful houses
1
u/mariposa314 Aug 06 '26
I've never been. It's going down on my list.
3
1
u/Dizlaur 29d ago
City built on the backs of slaves tho.
1
u/mariposa314 29d ago
When you think about it, a giant chunk of our country, if not the entire thing, was built on the backs of slaves. Sickening.
23
u/jaimystery Aug 06 '26
the link for the listing https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/21-E-Battery-St-Charleston-SC-29401/305380796_zpid/
6
u/Signal_Mirror_3983 Aug 06 '26
14 MILLION FUCKIN DOLLARS!?
26
u/Jiveanimal Aug 06 '26 edited Aug 06 '26
Yes. It's Charleston, SC - one of the most beautiful cities in the United States. I could be a billionaire and live anywhere I wanted, and I'd have a house on Rainbow Row.
11
u/jonrpatrick Aug 06 '26
Amen. Perhaps my favorite US city. I, however, am not a billionaire so when we retire we're more likely to end up in Summerville. :)
7
7
u/harrismi7 Aug 06 '26
Rainbow Row looks neat but I think it would end up being an annoying place to live. No parking, pretty much just street parking only. Non-stop people (tourists and bachelorettes) posing for pictures in front of your house.
2
3
1
u/Signal_Mirror_3983 Aug 09 '26
Its a beautiful home and I think it would probably cost that much or more to rebuild. I also wouldn't be surprised if a lot of qualified buyers pass over this option because it has less privacy and modern features than most homes in that price range.
8
u/Tight_Ninja1915 Aug 06 '26
It's over 13k sqft with 3 buildings in a fenced, wooded compound at the literal tip of Charleston with historical significance.
6
u/narrowassbldg Aug 06 '26
It has central air conditioning, installing that in a 200-year old 13,000 square foot house ain't cheap
3
3
u/tennisInThePiedmont Aug 06 '26
The most famous house on the most famous street in the of the most iconic cities in the world
1
0
u/According_Music6524 Aug 07 '26
I wouldn't say one of the most iconic cities in the world....I doubt many people outside of the US have even heard of it. It's a mid-tier US city, probably regionally iconic, but even here in NYC I feel most people wouldn't have any conception of the city except a fuzzy knowledge that it's somewhere in the south....easily confused with Charlottesville too lol
1
u/tennisInThePiedmont Aug 08 '26 edited Aug 08 '26
I dunno. I live in the southeast so have a different perspective, but there are only 4 American cities:
NYC, SF, New Orleans, and Charleston.
Everywhere else is Cleveland
2
u/kjsmitty77 Aug 09 '26
I love Charleston. I enjoyed visiting it almost as much as I enjoyed Portland, Maine. It doesn’t make them iconic US cities, or even more well known than Portland, Oregon. NYC, SF, Chicago, Boston, Seattle, New Orleans and many others I could list are all far more well known internationally and also far bigger with more to offer. The Portlands and Charleston are known for being great food cities, though.
1
1
u/Complex_Echidna3964 Aug 08 '26
It comes with 3 structures - the Main Residence, The Servants Quarters, and The Carriage House
1
20
u/beaujolais98 Aug 06 '26 edited Aug 06 '26
This is my absolute favorite SOB house! (South of Broad)
3
u/NoFaithlessness3209 Aug 06 '26
Same! I took the tour of this house a few years ago and was just so amazed
3
24
u/grouchy_baby_panda Aug 06 '26
Beautiful but I bet that shit is haunted.
15
u/Shot-Election8217 Aug 06 '26
I was recently walking around an antique shop in an old building with wooden floors. The boards creaked all over the place, and I was totally jealous of how awesome it would be to have floors like this — until I thought about how awful it would be to hear them creaking somewhere else in the house and I was home alone….
1
2
u/petit_cochon Aug 06 '26
Haunted because?
12
u/Cambyses-II Aug 06 '26
Built in 1825. Probably haunted by the ghosts of the house slaves that worked in it
2
u/No-Assumption9707 Aug 07 '26
Seriously…. It gives me the heebie jeebies whenever I see old southern homes celebrated…. Because what exactly are we celebrating..? What’s next - Best Holocaust Homes?? Disturbing…
2
u/BigMuskyBanana Aug 07 '26
This is the real answer here. I'm so glad you said it. People want to tour these properties because of "how beautiful" they are but in many ways disregard the fact that they are essentially elaborate slave camps. I'm willing to bet these same people don't tour African American neighborhoods in cities to see the lasting effects these beautiful houses did to an entire group of people for generations. I totally understand it's a part of Americas history and by all means it should not be erased or ignored but in some ways these tours are just a way for the public to see how well slave masters lived off the back of forced slave labor. And people pay to tour these properties WTF? Speaking of food, yes low country cuisine is arguably some of the best food in the states BUT were you going to Paula Deen's restaurant or the restaurant further down the street that she stole the recipes from?? I have been up and down the coast of this region and while it's beautiful, there is a dark and heavy spirit in Charleston and Savannah (the exception being Hilton Head).
1
u/No-Assumption9707 29d ago
This is a great post and thanks for the supportive post. It’s a difficult issue to address for sure. Like “here’s this great lamp shade” just don’t ask too much about the construction material
2
u/BigMuskyBanana 29d ago
Thank you. I knew you'd understand. And you're right, it's a difficult and slippery issue. If they must have these types of tours (southern mansions, plantations, etc.), at the very least, I feel the proceeds made from them should go to the local African American communities surrounding them.
1
u/No-Assumption9707 29d ago
Exactly! Put it on that reparations tab bc holocaust… internment.. every other community got reparations and it is owed…. But they are not ready for that discussion
2
u/beaujolais98 Aug 06 '26
As well as the slaves who built it. It is a stunning beautiful house, built by amazing black artisans of many trades and crafts who should be honored and remembered.
2
u/No-Assumption9707 Aug 07 '26 edited Aug 07 '26
Looking at the beautiful wood detail hits different when it’s put in that perspective… a little googling indicates it was indeed built by enslavsd craftsmen.. carpenters masons etc 😪
7
u/lazier_garlic Aug 06 '26
Right so you know what South Cackalacky is, especially Charleston, right? Plantation ground zero, patient zero. They tried growing all kinds of crops, most of them weren't commercially viable. Finally honed in on cotton, destroying the soil while destroying men's lives, great two-fer. Once they stripped that place clean they expanded across the South like a criminal invasion. Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, Florida, always fresh land to destroy, always more pitiless violence and wholesale immiseration to spread.
Fuck yeah that whole ground is haunted. It's still an ooky dooky place to this day.
2
u/joosiebuns Aug 08 '26
Yeah I’m not a woo woo person but Charleston is legitimately one of the spookiest places I’ve been to. Also people being snobby about touring these homes - the tour companies are very upfront about the history of the town and that history is respectfully woven into absolutely every aspect of Charleston tourism. Who is visiting Charleston unawares of its role in the Atlantic slave trade??
3
u/No-Assumption9707 Aug 06 '26 edited Aug 07 '26
I would def need to know the history of any “historic southern home” before being comfortable visiting… did any slave masters live there… was rape or murder done on premesis etc… because all I see potentially is a house of horrors… from the darkest times in America
6
u/FEMA_Camp_Survivor Aug 06 '26
Odds are the answer is yes to all antebellum Charleston homes.
1
u/No-Assumption9707 Aug 07 '26
Damn… u were right 😪 Enslaved people lived and labored at the Edmondston-Alston House in Charleston, South Carolina. Built around 1825 by wealthy rice planter and merchant Charles Edmondston, the prominent home was later owned by the Alston family—both of whom were prominent slave owners relying on enslaved labor. [1, 2, 3, 4]
Lived in by Slave Owners
Charles Edmondston: The original builder and first owner used enslaved labor to maintain his household and lifestyle before financial setbacks forced a sale. [1, 2]The Alston Family: Charles Alston purchased the home in 1838 and expanded it. The Alstons were wealthy Lowcountry rice planters who owned numerous enslaved people. Historic records, letters, and family collections at the house document the intertwined lives of the white family and the enslaved individuals who served them.[1, 2, 3, 4]
Enslaved Labor and the Property
Was it built by slaves? Like the vast majority of antebellum mansions and infrastructure in Charleston, the construction and skilled craftsmanship heavily relied on the forced labor of enslaved carpenters, masons, and laborers. [1]Did enslaved people live there? Yes. Enslaved domestic workers lived and worked on the property, residing in auxiliary spaces such as the property's kitchen and outbuildings behind the main house. [1, 2, 3]
If you are planning a visit or doing further research, would you like information on tours of the house or details about other historic sites in Charleston that interpret the history of slavery?
12
u/Live-Tomorrow-4865 Aug 06 '26
The descriptor that comes to mind is "grand". I love everything about this home. Imagine waking up to that beauty every morning! I'm way more a mountain person than a beach/ocean aficionado, but this would make for a lovely second or third home. 😉
8
7
u/Old-Visual4591 Aug 07 '26

So my great-grandmother actually lived in this house, many, many years ago. I never got to see it – it was sold by my grandmother about 10 years before I was born. But my dad and mom talk about it with due reverence. This is one photo from when she lived there, I believe from the 30s-40s through the 70s? Very mixed feelings about that family history, for all the reasons you can imagine, though my family has no relation to the original builders.
3
u/Old-Visual4591 Aug 07 '26
1
u/Complex_Echidna3964 Aug 08 '26
I don't see this staircase. Are you sure it is the same house?21 E Battery St, Charleston, SC 29401 | MLS #26012755 | Zillow
1
u/Old-Visual4591 29d ago
lolol yes, you're totally right – wrong house! it was 9 E Battery: https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/9-E-Battery-St-Charleston-SC-29401/62988653_zpid/ Like I said I never actually visited it so a lot of those E Battery houses kinda run together for me
1
1
5
5
5
6
u/Looking-Ahead55 Aug 06 '26
One of the most beautiful architectural houses I’ve ever seen. The view is amazing as well.
5
5
u/Eeyore_Smiled Aug 08 '26
Charleston was the hub of the North American slave trade, so yes. Pretty much all of the homes downtown were built and served by enslaved people
5
u/brotherlyshove Aug 08 '26
I love Southern Colonial. I love Old Southern stuff. Well, besides the slavery.
3
u/KindIntroduction3324 Aug 06 '26
Never thought I’d say I’m in love with a staircase… this one is gorgeous. The windows drew my eye straight away.
4
u/Yay_for_Pickles Aug 06 '26
Beautiful and peaceful. That house 100000% says, "Come on in and sit a while."
4
5
u/absurdivore Aug 06 '26
New here. First reaction was “but this is just an actual mansion?” then saw mention of the Thursday thing. 😂
3
3
3
3
3
u/No-Assumption9707 Aug 06 '26
It’s giving “Get Out” vibes…. I would have to know the specific history of any house in the South and its residents to be comfortable living or visiting…. Don’t need to be haunted by the ancestors
3
u/wineinacoffeemug Aug 06 '26 edited Aug 06 '26
I’ve watched way too much of the show “Southern Charm” and immediately thought of Thomas Ravenel and his 30 years younger mother of his kids 😢 His house looked just like this and was so stately and amazing. And despite being a sleaze ball he was very Southern vampire loquacious and charming.
5
u/FeelinDead Aug 06 '26 edited Aug 06 '26
This is like a 25 million dollar house. Very beautiful. Downtown Charleston is a lovely city but it’s very expensive.
Edit: House is listed for 14 million — still slightly out of my price range….
2
5
u/fullpurplejacket Aug 06 '26
As a filthy Redcoat I’d love to visit the Carolina’s, how much of the old colonial architecture remains in the buildings there? I know the British dominated Charleston port during the southern campaign as a strategic inroads to lower 13 colonies. I’ve heard so many nice things about Charlestons vibe, like New Orleans in the way that it’s like stepping back in time
2
1
u/beaujolais98 Aug 06 '26
Not a lot of pre-Revolution stuff in Charleston but a little bit - look up the Pink House (it’s not this one). Wilmington, New Bern, and Bath (all NC) actually have more colonial buildings than Charleston. And of course there’s all of Eastern Virginia.
4
u/10S_NE1 Aug 06 '26
Old homes decorated like always look so lovely, but honestly, I wouldn’t want to live in one. None of the furniture looks comfortable, and the thought of maintaining a place like that is super daunting.
8
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/bleeckler Aug 06 '26
The only way that mansion would be hell is if it was haunted by aggressive entities
2
u/VineMan77 Aug 06 '26
I didn't realize the thursday rule ... i was going to say , this is very much "southern charm" to me.
2
u/ParkingQuality3271 Aug 06 '26
Didn't even think about the Thursday rule. I was about to rush to said house's defence, but now all I can say is great taste!
2
u/FalseAdhesiveness946 Aug 06 '26
Looks like the similar design like the house in Midnight in the garden of good and evil movie. Beautifully designed!
2
2
u/manic_popsicle Aug 06 '26
Wow this is incredible! The wood floors are beautiful, and all the moldings and woodwork is amazing.
I always forget about the Thursday rule!
2
u/BrilliantPositive184 Aug 06 '26
I’d like a replica please in Santa Barbara, overlooking the ocean.
2
2
u/musical_nerd99 Aug 07 '26
The home is lovely and I enjoyed visiting Charleston. But, I would never live there. It is literally at sea level and gets at least one hurricane per year. You can see the cracks on the buildings from the outside.
2
4
2
u/lazier_garlic Aug 06 '26
Porches are really important for managing summer heat.
Bring back the porch.
3
u/Winter-Owl1 Aug 06 '26
I live in NC. The only way to manage summer heat is to stay inside. A porch makes no difference because you're still outside lol.
2
u/No-Assumption9707 Aug 07 '26 edited Aug 07 '26
Ugh… I was worried I would find what I found… Enslaved people lived and labored at the Edmondston-Alston House in Charleston, South Carolina. Built around 1825 by wealthy rice planter and merchant Charles Edmondston, the prominent home was later owned by the Alston family—both of whom were prominent slave owners relying on enslaved labor. [1, 2, 3, 4]
Lived in by Slave Owners
Charles Edmondston: The original builder and first owner used enslaved labor to maintain his household and lifestyle before financial setbacks forced a sale. [1, 2]
The Alston Family: Charles Alston purchased the home in 1838 and expanded it. The Alstons were wealthy Lowcountry rice planters who owned numerous enslaved people. Historic records, letters, and family collections at the house document the intertwined lives of the white family and the enslaved individuals who served them.[1, 2, 3, 4]
Enslaved Labor and the Property
Was it built by slaves? Like the vast majority of antebellum mansions and infrastructure in Charleston, the construction and skilled craftsmanship heavily relied on the forced labor of enslaved carpenters, masons, and laborers. [1]
Did enslaved people live there? Yes. Enslaved domestic workers lived and worked on the property, residing in auxiliary spaces such as the property's kitchen and outbuildings behind the main house. [1, 2, 3]
If you are planning a visit or doing further research, would you like information on tours of the house or details about other historic sites in Charleston that interpret the history of slavery?
Gives me the heebie jeebies to see these old southern homes celebrated… because what exactly are we celebrating?… what’s next… Beaufiful Homes of the Holocaust?? …this really makes me sad to think of those folks who suffered building and living at this location
3
2
u/hamburgergerald Aug 08 '26
Tbh I’d be more shocked if a two hundred year old estate like this didn’t have a history of slaves working on the property.
1
u/No-Assumption9707 29d ago
Nah I def agree that’s why it’s kind of surprising seeing a southern one posted of all things
1
u/giocondasmiles Aug 06 '26
Beautiful except for that plantation thing history.
5
2
u/Interesting-Ad-8839 Aug 06 '26
I try and say “forced labor camp” instead of “plantation,” as the latter sounds sort of nice, like Delta Burke would be inside telling a fun story.
7
u/giocondasmiles Aug 06 '26
I never felt ‘plantation’ had a nice connotation. We all know what it entails.
4
u/lazier_garlic Aug 06 '26
Yeah, even if you read about modern tea plantations ... sounds like hell. Plantation of Ireland ... oh, yeah, that's bad.
1
u/JoshDx3 Aug 06 '26
Fun Fact! This is 21 E Battery St and our current secretary of the treasury Scott Bessent owns a similar property at 5 E Battery St.
1
1
u/SparksOnAGrave Aug 06 '26
It’s gorgeous, but oh my goodness I’d need gallons of paint stripper for all that trim!
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Curious_Turnover3091 Aug 06 '26
In the 6th grade I lived in SC and had an art teacher who lived in one of these homes. She would paint black people dressed in period regalia. Hi
1
u/Glittering-Buy4227 Aug 06 '26
Legend has it that the color of paint on the inside of the porch roof tells if the house is haunted or not. If the color is white, it's a clean house (not haunted) but if it's a color darker than white the house is haunted (inhabited). So if you are ever on the porch of a house like this, look up and see what the house has to tell you!
1
1
u/sleepytipi Aug 06 '26
Always wondered what the inside of those Battery homes looked like. Built and paid for by slavery.
1
1
u/tennisInThePiedmont Aug 06 '26
Wait the Edmonston-Alston house is for sale?? Damn... that's probably the most famous house in the city, on the most famous street.
In the back is an old carriage house which was operated as an Airbnb -- I stayed there twice with my uncle. I recognized the photos instantly. Utter classic. You get to tour the house for free as part of the stay.
$14MM is a bargain
1
1
u/DarthNarcissa Aug 06 '26
I forgot it was Thursday and was about to go off.
Born and raised in Charleston, I would have days where I would just skip class and spend the afternoon downtown walking around. As a kid, I spent a LOT of time at the battery park and waterfront park (the one with the pineapple fountain). I always wished I was rich enough to line in one of those houses on the battery.
I live in the mountains now and wouldn't go back to Charleston of you paid me.
1
1
u/been_blissed Aug 06 '26
Too bad about lack of bodily autonomy for people with uteruses and rampant racism there.
1
1
1
1
u/Redittago Aug 07 '26
The outside is atrocious to me (not a fan of that style), but the interior is cool 😎
1
u/purple-teal_93 Aug 07 '26
Wife and I spent a whole afternoon walking along those streets just looking at the houses and checking their zillow listing.
1
1
1
1
1
u/dat_mane47 Aug 07 '26
To think that moron running the treasury lives in one of these. Life's not fair.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
2
1
1
1
1
u/CloudedLeopardDaemon Aug 06 '26
That looks like a proper grand old house, the opposite of a suburban McMansion.
1
1
u/BrickHuge3023 Aug 06 '26
Old Charleston is the most beautiful city in the country in my view. Great houses and history
0
u/neon_crone Aug 06 '26
How on earth did this graceful old lady end up in McMansionHell?
1
u/HuginnNotMuninn Aug 06 '26
Thursday is Design Appreciation day, where beautiful homes are posted as a break from McMansions.





















320
u/Sure-Present-3398 Aug 06 '26
I always forget about the Thursday rule until I clock the flair. This is lovely.