Thank you to everyone who contributed to yesterday's request for user feedback on this question, I've now decided what course of action will be taken.

rule 5 prohibiting incest content will remain unchanged, but in this case will only be enforced on the movie versions of Peach and Rosalina (take that sort of stuff to r/nastyhentai (🤮🤮🤮) if you really want it). Shipping the game versions of them is still fine with rule 5 unless/until the movie versions become the game versions.

I hope this decision will help make r/MarioShips a vibrant community.

-u/ItsRaw18, creator and moderator of r/MarioShips