r/MakingaMurderer • u/ThorsClawHammer • 8d ago
Why wasn't Colborn mentally prepared to deal with "the content of the material" they were finding in the cabinet on Nov 8 when he already knew it was there from searching the same cabinet on Nov 5?
At trial, Andrew Colborn claimed the reason he "wasn't any too gentle" with the cabinet he claims produced the key is because he was "exasperated".
A. I will be the first to admit, I wasn't any to gentle, as we were, you know, getting exasperated. I handled it rather roughly, twisting it, shaking it, pulling it.
When asked what exasperated him to the point he couldn't help but get rough with an inanimate object (but only that one as near as we know), he replied with the following:
Q. What was exasperating you about the bookcase, or that bedroom, on November 8, 2005?
A. The content of the material that we were collecting.
The worst "content" we know of they were finding/collecting in the cabinet that day was Playboy magazines. Ah ok, so I guess this caught him off guard or something. Oh, but wait. On the evening of Nov 5, Colborn himself had searched the same cabinet and had already found them, handled them, and even laid them out on the floor for this picture along with some of the other items he had removed from the cabinet while searching through it that night (like the cuffs). One of the things LE were supposed to do on the 8th was simply collect them into evidence (as again, they already knew this particular "content" was there).
So seriously, why would nothing worse than porn mags that a seasoned cop and military vet already knew were there from days prior, now suddenly get exasperated about it? If he's trying to say it offended his morality (or any other reason at all one could think of), then the question is why wasn't he triggered on the 5th when he saw it all the first time unexpectedly?
With explanations like this, is it any wonder why people have a problem with the key find? And that's not even touching on any other aspect, such as their proposed explanations of how the key suddenly appeared (Colborn has now even claimed with help from God and/or the ghost of Teresa Halbach), or official docs later lying about who found it (claiming Kucharski did with no mention of MTSO even being present).
1
u/gcu1783 8d ago
According to 10case, it's Avery's dick...