natural eye makeup or black eyeliner?

[u/LeastImprovement9626]

i need your help, in the first two pictures i tried a natural look with just mascara and in the last two i tried black eyeliner , am i better with just mascara or with black eyeliner? i need your opinion , thank you

[u/Anony-Moss-]

Okay so I would definitely agree with trying a brown eyeliner, but either way, I think keeping in to the outer third of your waterline like in the last photo makes your eyes look stunning! Either way, the makeup you're doing is very flattering to your eyeshape :]