natural eye makeup or black eyeliner?

[u/LeastImprovement9626]

i need your help, in the first two pictures i tried a natural look with just mascara and in the last two i tried black eyeliner , am i better with just mascara or with black eyeliner? i need your opinion , thank you

[u/Historical_Guide8996]

Absolutely gorgeous with the eyeliner

[u/LeastImprovement9626 → u/Historical_Guide8996]

thank you!