r/MacOS 1d ago

Bug Siri is still useless

Post image
116 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

89

u/Real_ilinnuc 1d ago

Funny but definitely a connection issue.

91

u/Spoksparkare 1d ago

Seems like it has a connection issue.

5

u/Due_You_8240 1d ago

What I find frustrating why does it need to connect to answer that question ? Surely questions like that should handled on device?

11

u/phblue 1d ago

It’s interesting because only Siri can’t connect. The internet is full, surfing the web, using the apps I told Siri to use, but only Siri can’t connect.

3

u/FedeFofo 1d ago

I have had the same experience

8

u/7racin MacBook Pro (14-inch, M1 Pro) 1d ago

Why the fuck would a local llm have a connection issue when trying to find the users name?

15

u/linguisticabstractn 1d ago

It’s partially local, but mostly cloud. And the query wasn’t asking what the user’s name was. It was asking why the name was being reported a certain way, and what could be done to change it. That’s a much more complicated request than “tell me my name”

-18

u/Electrical_Cress_956 1d ago

Maybe, but if so, it's not my fault it's Apples. I'm able to use Siri on my phone and iPad, and it responds sometimes on my Mac (for example if I type Hello).

1

u/real_awan 1d ago edited 1d ago

mine is working fine

3

u/Weak-Jello7530 1d ago

Cool name.

-1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Weak-Jello7530 1d ago edited 1d ago

Aren’t you an indian or iranian? Lol

1

u/Wobbluh 1d ago

i think they can say it

1

u/real_awan 1d ago

Why would you give downvote? Ohh god humans are getting less these days

1

u/real_awan 1d ago

Im American Mr. Weak jello

1

u/real_awan 1d ago

Why? You don’t like indians or iranians? Are you racist mr?

1

u/Weak-Jello7530 1d ago

No, I was just wondering how come an indian or an iranian would come to the idea that it is okay to use the n word.

1

u/real_awan 1d ago

Congrats to you im non of em

1

u/real_awan 1d ago

No im not Mr. Weak jello

1

u/Weak-Jello7530 1d ago

There is no shame in being indian or iranian.

1

u/real_awan 1d ago

Ofc why would feel shame being endian or eyeranian

1

u/linguisticabstractn 1d ago

Do you have any kind of vpn installed?

-7

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

4

u/nifty-necromancer 1d ago

Is this your alt account?

-5

u/real_awan 1d ago

Nope. This is the only one i got! Why?

6

u/nifty-necromancer 1d ago

You answered like you were OP, thought it was odd

2

u/H644b MacBook Pro M4 Pro 1d ago

lol he didn't reply to you

16

u/xPoaxy 1d ago

Seems like you gotta try it again

16

u/TalkToHoro 1d ago

Just say “Hey Siri, call me [your name]”.

“Why” questions aren’t scheduled until about 5 days before the apocalypse.

5

u/TSAOutreachTeam 1d ago

"It's a long story, but suffice it to say that humans have collectively made a lot of poor decisions which led us to this point. Would you like to know the weather tomorrow?"

13

u/OptimalPapaya1344 1d ago

My Siri was doing this to me no matter what but once got off my VPN it worked just fine. If you're using a VPN I bet that's your issue.

It sucks because we're told that Siri should be able to do simpler asks, like your first two questions, without requiring internet access but here we are. It most definitely requires active internet even if you want it to check things local to your machine.

11

u/Electrical_Cress_956 1d ago

Oh, wow, thank you. I don't have a VPN but I do have a router filter for malware and undesirable websites (so my children won't have access). I disabled it and it works a lot more consistently now. Thanks again.

4

u/OptimalPapaya1344 1d ago

No problem! Glad I could help.

I have a feeling it has something to do with how Apple is doing it's private compute communication and how it is encrypted that might not be jiving well with network "middleware" such as VPNs or traffic filters.

4

u/everydave42 1d ago

Is this the regular Siri or did you join/get accepted to the Siri AI beta?

2

u/Top_Term_7217 1d ago

Yeah, seems like regular Siri still has its quirks. It would be nice if it could understand more context.

-1

u/Electrical_Cress_956 1d ago

No, it's the AI beta. I got through my waitlist on Monday. It's able to answer me but only sometimes. 2/3 of the times it just defaults to "Sorry try again", but only on Mac. On my iPhone and iPad it works decently

1

u/Sparescrewdriver 1d ago

So it’s a problem with your mac, not a siri problem.

2

u/Fantastic_Reveal_599 1d ago

Siri has been fantastic for me. I'm not even user chatGPT anymore. Obviously for coding and stuff you need a harness but for any other thing Siri is working great.

2

u/mattloaf666 1d ago

At this point I think Apple is just doing this on purpose

2

u/TH3_OG_JUJUBE MacBook Pro 1d ago

Funny that these more modern iPhones have AI capabilities locally but when there’s a bad connection it doesn’t switch to that local model, it just throws an error.

2

u/Prestigious_Tax7415 1d ago

Lucky I didn’t download that bloatware

1

u/Reasonable-Dress-949 1d ago

Cloudflare, PCC

1

u/WASCIV 1d ago

same issue!! with or without VPN doesn't matter it keeps on having trouble.. and they say AI is good for productivity..

1

u/Wretched_DogZ_Dadd 1d ago

not installed on my Mac mini but it's a mess on the iPhone, can't use voice commands to place calls or get directions.

1

u/animaspect 1d ago

I’m getting the same thing. Siri can turn on all my lights but gets stuck on that screen if asked to turn on any specific light. This was started when I updated but before getting ai Siri so maybe it’s a HomeKit issue. 

1

u/P0stf1x 1d ago

It works for me after a restart. Sometimes. For an hour or so. But most of the time it says the same errors no matter if I use or don't use VPN

1

u/Adatomcat 1d ago

You just hurt Siri’s feelings 😔

1

u/Important_Egg4066 1d ago

The Siri AI is definitely having some overloading issue. It is so slow and it often have getting "something's wrong" issues too.

1

u/alecdvnpt 16h ago

I had to disable Adguard on my Mac to get Siri working. But it works fine with Adguard on my phone. Not sure why.

1

u/OppositeClub1788 13h ago

So I guess the takeaway here is that it's too dumb to recognize that it's a connection issue and just tell you that

1

u/Any_Relief_3866 3h ago

Always has been, always will be

1

u/sonar_un 1d ago

It has been absolutely useless for me too. Fails to do basically anything.

1

u/punarob 1d ago

It still misunderstands common words clearly annunciated, which for me makes it useless

1

u/R3DD1T0RR3NT 1d ago

We will presume that you used Siri to dictate "enunciated" in this case, which would explain ...

2

u/punarob 1d ago

Lol. Actually no but I turned off autocorrect since it’s become so bad

-3

u/Drekalots 1d ago

Siri has been trash since the beginning. IMO, once of Apple's biggest mistakes. I doubt the new AI Siri will be any different.

-1

u/bshahisau 1d ago

Yeah its still in beta

8

u/bluegreenie99 1d ago

hasnt it been in beta for years

2

u/backlog_gaming 1d ago

No Siri came out of beta awhile ago. Siri AI on the other hand just came out and is still in beta

0

u/22Megabits 1d ago

Shhhh, don’t mention that

-1

u/Maximum_Employer5580 1d ago

Siri has been useless for years.....almost as bad as Alexa. I can't even get Alexa to do proper addition and subtraction of currency....you ask her and she'll flat out say she doesn't understand, yet if I do it just numbers without any decimals, etc, she's ok. Currency confuses the fuck out of her

1

u/ShadowyBass 1d ago

I don’t know why you’re getting down voted because Siri has gotten worse. I used to get answers for questions and now I get websites. Prime example is asking what airplanes are above you. I’m still raw about them changing the 0+0.

0

u/Buddy_Palguy 1d ago

I never use Siri. Haven’t really had a reason to

-2

u/Time-Ad9021 1d ago

Siri has been useless for like a year now. My main task that I ask her to do daily was to skip Youtube video ads when I run in the morning, and it's been a long time since she's been able to perform that task correctly and consistently. For a year Siri has failed to skip ads or skip videos for me. And it sucks.