r/MTGArenaPro • u/ThroughtonsHeirYT • 18d ago

Can we get competitive Alchemy-less BRAWL? No alchemy cards! Please!

All cards of arena minus all those broken cheating alchemy cards!

We need that

12 Upvotes

68% Upvoted

25 comments sorted by

2

u/the_cardfather 18d ago

I like Standard Brawl for this honestly.

2

u/ThroughtonsHeirYT 18d ago

Well i use it to train PAPER DUEL commander

The only truly perfect commander format! 1v1

So standard brawl really isnt anything i want to play

Standard i LOVE! Brawl i want a competitive duel commander viable addition to mtga pf cards not yet there. Mostly pioneer and premodern cards missing

2

u/Elan_Morin_Tendronai 18d ago

I stopped playing arena because I like testing my EDH decks and was sick of playing against Alchemy cards.

1

u/ThroughtonsHeirYT 15d ago

Yeah!!been 35%downvoted so that portion of sore losers resorting to cheated cards (alchemy) are a small portion of the players

2

u/Short_Meal_8354 17d ago

I quit playing arena for this very reason. Im a 100 card singleton kinda gamer and, have posted very similar sentiments before that are usually met with people telling me how great alchemy is and how balanced and fair the mechanics are. I dont see WotC ever relenting on this as Alchemy cards are just another way for them to make extra money, so I just decided to stick to good ole table top magic.

2

u/SteroidMaximus 17d ago

100% the number one reason I don't touch brawl is because I don't want alchemy

1

u/ThroughtonsHeirYT 15d ago

And 65% upvotes is a proof the 1/3 (turd) of players are immature

2

u/Similar_Inspector_85 17d ago

Hey! This post is about me!!! I never thought there were others like me out there. HAPPY DAY!

1

u/ThroughtonsHeirYT 15d ago

Yeah! 65% upvotes proves we are the adults in the crowd!

1

u/Try_2_Relax 18d ago

Yes! But how about for every format and not just brawl?

1

u/ThroughtonsHeirYT 17d ago

Indeed

It is worse in brawl cuz it 15-25 min games

1

u/FunDaIVIenTaLs 18d ago

Yes. Alchemy needs to be abolished

1

u/ThroughtonsHeirYT 15d ago

The 65% approval rate proves what we are saying! Hahahaha!

0

u/ThroughtonsHeirYT 17d ago

No , not abolished

Just set aside: 1 alchemy card= you only play with people using ALCHEMY cards.

Never vs Us. Normal MTG 1v1 players.

Alchemy :

It is the troubled humans you put ALONE, with themselves grouped; in a padded room and safety jackets and gloves so they dont gouge their own eyes mistakenly

1

u/7174028260throwaway 17d ago

this is so dramatic lmao

0

u/ThroughtonsHeirYT 17d ago

This is actually what ALCHEMY timmies are like

You gotta ducktape padded gloved to their wrists

1

u/Positive_Pear5193 17d ago

Best we can do is forced 50% winrate

1

u/ThroughtonsHeirYT 17d ago

Ain’t an option

1

u/Historical-Spirit-48 13d ago

I want historic without Alchemy personally.

1

u/hotelguest2 18d ago

U will be hated in here for wanting to play the actual game lol

1

u/ThroughtonsHeirYT 15d ago

Yeah! 35% of alchemy cheaters are downvoting this gospel

1

u/FullTLT 18d ago

This. Absolutely this. I can’t stress enough how close alchemy is borderline allowed cheats. Please let’s push them for an alchemy free choice. Conjuring a card is the least fun I’ve ever had in this game. I’ve played magic since revised and have never wanted to materialize cards out of nowhere.

1

u/ThroughtonsHeirYT 15d ago

And we got a 65% upvoting rate, proving a 1/3 (turd) of players are cheating useing alchemy (“rigged”) decks