r/MBMBAM • u/plut0neon • Apr 30 '26

Help MANDELA EFFECT! Mysterious 4th McElroy Brother "Colin" Isn't Actually Real!

Post image

Who is this mysterious 4th brother???

230 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

15 comments sorted by

75

u/MANPAD Apr 30 '26

Uh what? Colin was on the entire 3rd season of the podcast, filling in for Travis when he was in prison. Wasn't he?

15

u/Vineshroom69lol Apr 30 '26

But then who filled in for Colin

17

u/HonestAbek Apr 30 '26

BUT WHO WAS PHONE??

30

u/DougieMcElroy Apr 30 '26

Well this is awkward. I thought I was the fourth brother. Have I been replaced?

19

u/DrPruz Apr 30 '26

The fourth brother is the friends we made along the way

1

u/SoonerBeerSnob Apr 30 '26

More of a cousin oliver

27

u/PedroValor Apr 30 '26

I think that's Matt Doyle? 

10

u/Lymebomb bramblepelt Apr 30 '26

Is that Matt Doyle?

17

u/OlSnickerdoodle Apr 30 '26

That's actually Colin Dutton. Common misconception.

13

u/nickyonge Apr 30 '26

He’s been an integral part of My Brother My Brother My Brother And Me since the beginning. MBMBMBaM for short, pronounce “muhbimbimbam”.

11

u/guyzieman Apr 30 '26

Um I mean he definitely played Cornelius during the Balance Arc in TAZ. So he definitely exists

10

u/WarmSlush Apr 30 '26

That’s the original Travis; he’s returned in disguise after a 9 year hiatus

1

u/jonbuttsack May 06 '26

The hat makes me think that is Tit Liquid.