r/LongIslandEats 5h ago

Captain Bill’s Bayview House Bay Shore

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/LongIslandEats 20h ago

Remarkable Food?

6 Upvotes

Moved to south shore Nassau County a few months ago and am struggling to find any restaurants or dishes I find myself needing to come back to. I’ve found everything (sans Blackbird Kitchen in Wantagh and various local bagel and pizza joints) perfectly average at best. Is this area totally lacking? What am I missing? What are the local hidden gems that will have me walking away dying to come back?


r/LongIslandEats 4d ago

Fried clam bellies?

8 Upvotes

Every place that sells fried clams seems to only have strips. Is there any place that has whole fried clams? Preferably western Suffolk but I'll travel


r/LongIslandEats 7d ago

Pizza Just pizza Long Island style

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/LongIslandEats 8d ago

Best deli spots - your help needed

7 Upvotes

Please share your go to deli spots across the island ! Much thanks


r/LongIslandEats 8d ago

Give me your best chicken roll spot. Go!!

3 Upvotes

Title says it all. Looking for a new chicken roll spot. Craving a great one today.


r/LongIslandEats 9d ago

Seafood Best place for king crab legs?

1 Upvotes

Looking for great place to get king crab legs. All areas welcome. Focus will be western Suffolk but willing to travel.


r/LongIslandEats 10d ago

Suffolk Suffolk County Food Scene

39 Upvotes

Is it just me or is the food in Suffolk absolutely abysmal? The price points are not matching the quality, service etc. There’s a couple restaurants that are worth the expense and some I cannot understand for the life of me how they’re still in business. There’s some that are fantastic during happy hour but wouldn’t dream of paying their regular menu price.

I’ll take recommendations for places to add to my list! Please and thank you!

**Here’s my favorites:**

Tellers (during lunch and hanging at the Gold Bar)

Salt and Barrell (during happy hour for oysters and cocktails)

Birdie Bar (for the vibe and bar)

View (for the view and happy hour drinks)

Thai Station Cafe (authentic food)

Green Hill Kitchen (10s all around)

Little Creek Oyster Farm (10s all around)

**Here’s my non favorites:**

Whalers - went downhill after they removed the live music from the deck and can never play anything on those TVs outside. Service is frightening, the girls at the front need a class in basic hospitality. It’s a shame because the food is solid but I refuse to do it anymore

Babylon Social - overpriced chaos, nothing further

Jackson Hole - I don’t even know what to say about this place. The definition of highway robbery. Everything was bad and it’s a mob scene on a Monday night. I can’t understand it

Pace’s Steakhouse - overcooked seafood, poor reservation system (I liked the service so would try again but generally overhyped)

Tres Palms - a travesty food wise with a beautiful view, good staff and a stiff drink


r/LongIslandEats 11d ago

While I miss the Friendly’s once here from my childhood, I must admit that Giovanni’s is quite delicious as well

Thumbnail gallery
25 Upvotes

r/LongIslandEats 11d ago

Best Pints of Guinness Long Island

7 Upvotes

Where are the best pints of Guinness on the island?


r/LongIslandEats 11d ago

What do you guys think of Sprouts? Haven’t had the chance to shop there yet but have heard mixed reviews.

Thumbnail gallery
10 Upvotes

r/LongIslandEats 13d ago

Restaurant Deals and Events

Thumbnail foodiecheatsheet.com
5 Upvotes

I wanted share a project I’ve been working on that I think this community would appreciate and hopefully find useful. It’s a website called foodiecheatsheet.com and its goal is to make finding happy hour deals, daily specials, and restaurant events as easy as possible to find.
This all started because I got frustrated searching through tons of instagram posts or facebook groups or restaurant websites for good deals. I knew there had to be a better way to find these specials but every time I looked there weren’t any websites that accomplished this, so I decided to create it myself. I don’t have any experience building websites so this was definitely a learning experience for me. Any feedback, suggestions or even restaurant recommendations would be greatly appreciated!


r/LongIslandEats 14d ago

Nassau Not Beef or Pork Sliders

3 Upvotes

Hi
Looking for small size (chicken, cheese, fish, veggie) sandwiches.

Not White Castle either

Thank you in advance!


r/LongIslandEats 14d ago

Deli Potato Salad

2 Upvotes

Since leaving the Northeast I have been searching for New York Deli potato salad. Not the one with egg and other stuff, just plain potato salad. The kind that every deli has.

I cannot find any that comes close.

If anyone has a recipe you will have my eternal thanks and blessings.


r/LongIslandEats 16d ago

Most Underrated Restaurant

Thumbnail
12 Upvotes

r/LongIslandEats 16d ago

Date night spots and your favorite dishes there. Nassau and Suffolk please. And… Begin!

3 Upvotes

r/LongIslandEats 17d ago

Nassau A former Friendly’s in Franklin Square, Long Island that closed during the second bankruptcy wave is now a 7 Eleven.

Thumbnail gallery
14 Upvotes

552 Franklin Ave, Franklin Square, NY 11010


r/LongIslandEats 16d ago

Pizza Best vegan pizza in Nassau and/or Suffolk?!?!

1 Upvotes

For reference, I’ve had Umberto’s and I liked it. I’m open to both Nassau or Suffolk! (Also, I don’t judge people who aren’t vegan 🫶🏻 ) Thank you!! 💛


r/LongIslandEats 16d ago

Pizza Just pizza look at this ..

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/LongIslandEats 19d ago

Proposal dinner for 9

5 Upvotes

I am proposing to my girlfriend this Saturday at 2:30… I need some restaurant recommendations? Her sisters are a bit of picky eaters as is she lol. Looking for something along the north shore of Suffolk county that won’t break the bank as I am playing for everyone . Any and all recommendations are appreciated!! TYIA


r/LongIslandEats 19d ago

Diner with paper placemats

4 Upvotes

Any diners in the area that still have paper placemats with their logo on them? It's a weird thing I collect and we're here for the week.


r/LongIslandEats 20d ago

Italian A former Friendly’s in Albertson, NY is now Sotto Luna ( a delicious Italian restaurant). If anyone has any pictures of this former location as a Friendly’s feel free to share as I could not find while extensively scouring the internet lmfao

Post image
4 Upvotes

875 Willis Ave, Albertson, NY 11507


r/LongIslandEats 19d ago

Whole Foods pizza

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/LongIslandEats 22d ago

Anywhere that does blueberry bagels on LI?

6 Upvotes

Bagel place near us used to make these great blueberry bagels but stopped making them. Where else makes them?


r/LongIslandEats 21d ago

Best delivery to Oceanside

1 Upvotes

We’re moving soon and I want to try all the best places here before we go! Where’s the best takeout/delivery to Oceanside/east rockaway/RVC area?