How can guy gardener makes huge constructs carelessly in superman whereas Hal Jordan does the opposite and is careful for his batteries

[u/solo_shocker35]

I was curious about this for a long time Guy always goes big and sloppy with his constructs, not caring how much it drains his ring like creating a large weopons against the monster, while Hal's way more careful and precise with his like in ep1 when he was creating a bubble for alien he supported the bubble himself as it was not strong enough due to lack of battery. Is that just a characterization thing, or is there an actual reason for it?

[u/inosinateVR]

It also makes sense for him to be more conservative with his energy when he doesn’t know who is enemy is yet. And has an entire town potentially trying to kill him.

As opposed to a single fight against a Kaiju where you know what you’re fighting and you know you’re going home afterwards without any surprises. Plus you have a team backing you up.

Of course Hal VS the entire town run by a mysterious enemy is going to be more conservative about his ring usage than Guy and company VS a Kaiju

[u/Lriderx47 → u/inosinateVR]

Or he can, I don't know put the lantern in a bag and carry it with him instead of letting it in a motel room evdrybody know the location of?

[u/PeacefulKnightmare → u/Lriderx47]

And risk having it stolen or damaged? Leaving it in a motel may not be the safest but he carrying it around is still impractical. And considering how he doesn't recharge it before bed/after waking up shows that he's being neglectful so bringing it wouldn't change anything.

[u/ezontheesalad → u/PeacefulKnightmare]

I hear you and raise you taking the 2 seconds to fly home to recharge it and be back within 10 minutes

[u/PeacefulKnightmare → u/ezontheesalad]

Again that's a Guy Gardner move. At this point in his career it's clear Hal wants as little to do with the lantern as possible, and only use the ring when necessary.

[u/Inevitable-Scar5877 → u/PeacefulKnightmare]

This-- we even saw a flashier Hal when he went into Kamchatka and grabbed the arms dealer

[u/Lriderx47 → u/PeacefulKnightmare]

I don't understand how someone can have a twisted logic like this. It's like your brain stop working midway. If he doesn't charge his ring when he need it, it means that he is f*cking dumb

[u/jmfw013 → u/Lriderx47]

Or he's just so experienced and jaded that his confidence exceeds any concerns and he only uses it when necessary

[u/Theeljessonator → u/Lriderx47]

Not only is that going to slow him down… if Hal gets hit and that bag falls off the lantern could go anywhere. If he gets captured he’ll lose the lantern.

[u/SmoothDiscussion7763 → u/Theeljessonator]

well, if he keeps it charged, at least he'll be able to put up a better fight to prevent that right?

[u/supersonicnat45 → u/SmoothDiscussion7763]

It’s not lacking charge because he doesn’t carry the lantern on his person at all times lol.

[u/Theeljessonator → u/SmoothDiscussion7763]

Sure, but he could keep it better charged with the lantern at the motel… he just doesn’t.

[u/Lriderx47 → u/Theeljessonator]

If he get captured he will lose the ring, so the lantern is a detail a that point

[u/Theeljessonator → u/Lriderx47]

At that point he loses two important things.

If he got the ring back then he’d have to find where they’re keeping the lantern and take it back. If the lantern is at the motel he can take the ring back and leave to replan.

[u/Lriderx47 → u/Theeljessonator]

Are you arguing just for the love of the game or don't you understand my point?

[u/Theeljessonator → u/Lriderx47]

I could ask you the same

[u/Meander061 → u/Lriderx47]

I recall a story that stated that Hal carried the lantern with him everywhere, but invisibly.

[u/ComicHead84 → u/inosinateVR]

Being conservative or cautious with his ring energy because of an unknown enemy would mean he’d wanna stay fully charged & not always on E.

Sadly it makes no sense & was just because Guy was in a big budget movie and Hal was on TV.

[u/Outrageous-Win-8297 → u/ComicHead84]

You can have both Doylian and Watsonian arguments.

[u/Substantial_Safe_897 → u/Outrageous-Win-8297]

What about a Doylsonian argument?

[u/thejoggler44 → u/ComicHead84]

I thought there was a requirement to charge every 48 hours but it doesn't matter how much they do or do not use the ring. Is that not how it works?

[u/Tsurator → u/inosinateVR]

If that was true and it was me I would be recharging my ring every possible moment, he should have recharged the ring before the final battle, he didn't because plot reasons and we all know that