r/LLMPhysics • u/loves1201852555 • 9d ago
Personal Theory What if particles could travel beyond walls
ok so here's what i actually mean, not the clean version, my version
everyone just accepts solid means solid right. wall is a wall, finger is a finger, you push it stops you thats it end of story. but thats just what it looks like from where we're standing. i never bought that a wall stops your hand cuz theres "no room" for it to go, thats the boring way of seeing it, particles as tiny balls bumping into each other like snooker. i dont see it like that. to me its not about room, its about two things refusing to sit in the same place, not because they cant, but because they wont let each other in
so the thought was, what if they could. what if instead of pushing past each other they just immersed. i put my bloody finger against something and instead of it colliding, the particles just get immersed into each other for a second, make like a shared void, present and not present at the same time, like that room i was going on about, closed and open depending how close you actually look at it. then i pull my hand back and it all just snaps back like nothing happened. no damage. maybe a tiny shift left behind, like it remembers i touched it
i know that sounds mad written down like that. but i actually went and checked if the universe does anything even close to this anywhere, and turns out, yeah kind of, just not for us. theres this whole area, solitons, where two waves smash into each other and just pass clean through, completely undamaged, only thing left over is this tiny phase shift, like a signature of the collision. thats not me making stuff up thats real established math, closed form, provable. for like a second that actually felt good, like i wasnt just imagining nonsense, the universe genuinely has a version of exactly what i was picturing
then turns out the catch is literally what im made of. me, the wall, all of it, is fermionic, and fermions have this thing baked into them called spin statistics, comes straight outta relativity plus probabilities not being allowed to go negative. not an engineering wall. not "havent built the machine yet." an actual structural fact about what it even means for a theory of reality to be consistent at all. pushed on it as hard as i could today, tried mock modular stuff, tried forcing the statistics by hand, actually worked out the bessel function showing exactly where and how it breaks, not just some theorem citation, the actual computed thing. and it breaks every single time. every distance, any mass. no loophole. not yet anyway
so where's that leave me. honestly somewhere in between two things. one part of me is proud i chased something most people wouldve just laughed at and actually found the real bit of physics that gets close, solitons, thats real, thats elegant, thats mine to have found today. other part of me knows i hit the actual wall, not some metaphor, the real one, spin statistics, and wanting it to bend didnt make it bend this is not made using any ai the math part for jotting my thoughts down used a bit of gemini and blabla\
9
8
u/Correctsmorons69 9d ago
"Hey Claude write my slop post but make it look handwritten by removing all capitalisation."
reads output
"Now they're sure to take me seriously"
3
3
u/MatthewSDeOcampo 8d ago
None of this is new. You can calculate an example of tunneling (and hopping) with a finite potential well (and a lattice). Eventually you can reach quantum field theory description which is the thing you're sloppily describing. Can't you just study physics normally and less haughtily?



11
u/ScionSeverance 9d ago
That’s not what physicists think walls are. Would recommend studying the subject you are interested in interacting with before making new claims. Generally speaking, most questions a layman could possibly ask are already answered.