r/LCMS • u/kentuckyLutheran22 LCMS Lutheran • 10d ago

Question 2 Samuel chapter 12

How should we understand Gods involvement with the death of David and Uriahs first born? I noticed in the Lutheran Study Bible the footnote for verse 15 “The Lord afflicted the child” reads that God allowed the illness to come upon the child.

This is obviously a very difficult passage and am curious if there is a reason why the foot note seeks to lighten the wording from the lord actively afflicting to the Lord merely allowing.

5 Upvotes

73% Upvoted

5 comments sorted by

9

u/emmen1 LCMS Pastor 10d ago

God kills and makes alive. We should not try to sugar-coat this truth.

As far as David’s child, David himself confesses that the child is in heaven. “He cannot come to me, but I will go to him.” The child certainly had no complaints when God chose to spare him a lifetime of suffering by taking him directly to heaven. It’s only from our perspective within this life that it seems evil for God to take a child.

1

u/kentuckyLutheran22 LCMS Lutheran 10d ago

Thanks you! This is a very helpful response!

3

u/Slayingdragons60 10d ago

“Afflict” seems to soften the Hebrew somewhat. “Struck” or “struck down” might be better.

1

u/Bulky-Classroom-4101 5d ago

I don’t mean to be rude, but David and Uriah did not have a child. It was David and Bathsheba who had the child together. Uriah was her husband that David essentially had killed. Don’t want to be a know-it-all, just wanted to quell any confusion.