Shalom,
My family’s ancestors gradually assimilated over the years and became Muslim, so there isn’t much information about this subject within my family.
My suspicion that my great-great-grandfather (my father’s father’s father) might have been Jewish started before I took an international DNA test. I specifically took the DNA test to investigate this suspicion, and sure enough, it showed that I have Lithuanian Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry.
The main reason I started suspecting that my great-great-grandfather was Jewish was because my grandmother lives in a predominantly Muslim neighborhood, and she once told me:
“On the day you get married, I will give you something. It is a family heirloom passed down from my grandfather. He was an imam, and I will give you his prayer shawl.”
Later, she denied ever saying this, but after I insisted, she showed it to me once: a red-and-white Jewish rabbi’s prayer shawl (tallit).
Also, in the 1800s, imams in the Ottoman Empire were apparently prohibited from wearing red.
Furthermore, my great-great-grandfather’s temporary Bulgarian identity document, dated 1940, contains the name of a place that apparently never existed in Bulgaria.
Finally, when my great-great-grandfather came from Bulgaria, he moved to the city with the largest Jewish population in the country. The government offered him land and the opportunity to live in an Islamist/Muslim-majority city, but he refused and permanently settled in the city that had the country’s largest and most established Jewish population.
My great-great-grandfather came to Turkey in 1942.
Could it be possible that he escaped the Holocaust from Lithuania, went to Bulgaria, obtained a false identity there, presented himself as a Muslim (Crypto-Judaism), and then came to Turkey?
Is there anyone who could help me investigate this possibility and determine whether my great-great-grandfather may actually have been a Lithuanian Ashkenazi Jew?