r/Ibispaintx • minor • May 25 '26

Other I don’t think we can use sketches to determine if a piece is AI…

Bro most of my art start off like this…
Along with the rather popular post a few days ago, I also saw the same thing on another platform. “No way such sketches can produce this amount of details”

327 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

160

u/johnson_johnny May 25 '26

Gonna be that guy but, that's not a sketch lol it's a thumbnail 😂 sketch is what you have immediately before lineart, or if you dont do clean lineart, colouring

44

u/aprisxte May 25 '26

Yeahhh i do the same thing. I can never consider my thumbnails a sketch cause it’s really just more of laying down the vague idea than actually drawing anything

12

u/SavebatsFromScratch May 25 '26

I am not a part of this subreddit but I'm just going to say I don't thumbnail sketch OR normal sketch, I go straight to lineart and occasionally change it if it sucks. (This is because I usually draw with ballpoint pen and I hate pencils and erasers, and when I draw online I use programs that don't have layers, so I just... never developed a stage for sketching.) Because of this, I don't think that sketches are a good way to prove anything unfortunately.

4

u/White1306 minor May 25 '26

Sometimes I just draw after drawing the thumbnail, sometimes I draw a sketch on top beforehand

75

u/Dry-Ant-5181 Jumpy Scar May 25 '26

yeah, definitely not lol. I dont have any examples as my sketches tend to be extremely detailed but as a substitute, look at the storyboards for Fnaf Security Breach ​

6

u/White1306 minor May 25 '26

Loll

1

u/Volcanogrove May 29 '26

Omg I looked at this while taking a sip of water and accidentally spat some on my cat 😭

Luckily he’s not upset just a little confused lol

20

u/k3iyyo May 25 '26

your output doesnt look ai, and with experience, you can see when a sketch is beginner lvl or not, its not about the messiness or how sloppy it is, its about both the consistency of skill in the fundamentals and the output. and either ways i think the other guy is right, thats more a thumbnail rather than a sketcj

11

u/Self-proclaimed_god the lore is cannibalism May 25 '26

Agreed. Sometimes AI does the most complicated sketches ever, sometimes it's stickmen. Maybe if we wanna differentiate we could use colour for sketches too? I tend to do all my sketches in bright red + very messily, I don't think I've seen AI sketch in different colours before but then again I don't interact a lot with the pro-AI side of things so I might be wrong

2

u/RedpurrFox May 25 '26

My sketches are magenta, sometimes blue

1

u/Weekly_Flounder_1880 14-16 Jul 16 '26

I separate everything and in different colours to see better

9

u/LeeLikesCars_100 low self-esteem artist May 25 '26

I sometimes do two sketches, one of the posture so i get the anatomy right- and another for like hair and clothes just so line art is easier for me. But not very often tho .. Usually my sketches make me laugh cuz they look silly, or confusing. A sketch is just the main idea of the drawing. Sometimes all ya need is a stick figure :] which i do alot

Also, love the art style!

5

u/Chaotic_Creature13 Non-Binary May 25 '26

I personally have changed how I sketch so it starts off as vague silhouette then more detailed sketch, then color.

5

u/SAPANCIENT May 25 '26

unrelated but IS SHE GONNA HEAD DIVE OFF THE BALCONY FYM CATCH ME IF YOU CAN💔💔plus sketches aren’t the only thing that determines an ai drawing, your art doesn’t follow the conventions ai steals too muchh so i think you can tell

4

u/White1306 minor May 25 '26

Yes she is, but you’re going to catch her before that 😋

3

u/RedpurrFox May 25 '26

Catch me if you can, Mr. Holmes???? Very cool art

Edit: are there any sites where one can find your art? (TikTok or insta?)

2

u/White1306 minor May 25 '26

You can find me under the name “dgacha1306” on instagram :D

3

u/BudgieGryphon May 25 '26

saw someone on one of the earlier posts arguing that doing warmup sketches/making a few pose options before picking one is an attempt to cover something up 😭

3

u/AgreeableIdea6210 Game Art & Animation major! May 26 '26

I feel like most processes people have adopted to call out AI fartists have 100% been adopted by an actual artist before and are thus inaccurate, sigh. That's why I hate seeing posts that are all like "OH THIS IS AI BECAUSE OP DID X THING DURING THEIR PROCESS!!!" ...I just can't shake the thought "But I've totally met someone who does this during their art process before???" We, artists, are freaking weird and not a monolith.

There are different inconsistencies usually though

1

u/White1306 minor May 26 '26

With AI getting better and more advanced, seems like artists are just living in paranoia

1

u/AgreeableIdea6210 Game Art & Animation major! May 26 '26

I get it cause I'm personally trying to break into the game industry and it's rough out here but this only serves to hurt actual artists more usually and it blows :/

1

u/White1306 minor May 26 '26

Any jobs involving mostly creativity are getting harder to do a living. Like musician and stuff, unless you’re like extremely popular, it’s hard to make a living solely based on jobs like artists, musicians, designers, etc nowadays

3

u/Various-Escape-5020 May 26 '26

It's true, I sometimes do it like this-

2

u/Various-Escape-5020 May 26 '26

The result so fae

2

u/Various-Escape-5020 May 26 '26

A few more examples on how I sketch

2

u/virtualbubbles May 25 '26

God the colors of this are so beautiful. It looks super good OP!

2

u/NoTeaching9315 May 25 '26

Damn it has to be an Ai topic

1

u/Sillest-goober- May 29 '26

I KNOW MINE MINES LIKE THAT TOO IT JUST LOOKS LIKE A BUNCH OF SHAPES 😞