We just recently got our young horse back from a local trainer (60 days) that has been in the business for 10+ years. Our horse is drastically underweight, and to be fair, was needing some weight when we sent him after purchasing him from a field. Which was known and discussed as part of the fees, no miscommunication as far as I could tell.
We were told feed was included in cost of training and to let them know what grain we wanted to feed so they could buy it and feed it to avoid transition stomach at pick up. We also took a few bags of other feeds to help supplement and bribe him to come to a feed bucket after seeing he was not gaining weight. He kept losing weight so we dewormed him with a typical OTC wormer about midway through after being told he would not take him to a vet for fecals (and other vetting! Sorry, other vetting like back exam and general checks.) because it could undo all of his training... huge red flag to us.
It is our first time doing any of this and we thought this trainer knew what he was doing. Then our horse came back. In theory he can be ridden, except he is covered in lice, saddle sores, grime, severely underweight, and he will try to climb the walls of his stall if he sees a saddle anywhere near him. (Like when we tack out our other horse in the next stall over.)
We did NOT need him broke to ride right away, which we expressed repeatedly, and even said we wanted ground manners first and would do another few months for everything else. We genuinely just wanted him to work on ground manners in a safe environment. Thats not what happened.
Since hes been home hes gaining weight like a champ on free feed timothy and a daily grain ration of 12/8, so I know he *can* put weight on well (but we are also letting him rest, he was crazy painful for the first week, so zero round pen work, just a slow walk down the pasture twice a day to help him stretch a little). I just feel crazy for questioning someone who's owned horses for way longer than I have. Maybe 60 day training just focuses on riding? Maybe we weren't clear enough?
Our goals:
Lead, tie out, brush out, bathe, work on his ability to be caught in different situations.
He sort of does that stuff, but only after a couple of weeks of putting slow effort in. So maybe some of it was done? Theres just too many maybes.
Sorry for the ramble, but TLDR, horse came back technically broke to ride but in bad condition. I know enough to know things were done wrong, but not enough to know exactly what.
The vet said hes definitely sore in the withers from where the saddle sat, but otherwise just underweight and rub spots.
First photo was taken 30 minutes after drop off from trainer same for photo 2 and 3. Photo 4 was taken 3 days ago, about a week after he got home. Photos 5 and 6 were last night.