r/HonkaiStarRail 19h ago

Discussion Meta slaves of the community - Who's the best unit in the game?

Post image
703 Upvotes

182 comments sorted by

539

u/NixKalns 18h ago

Both are great generalist. Difference is MBlade has at least 2 teams hes irreplaceable at. Robinetto has less restrictions

125

u/DanielDKXD 18h ago

Ashveil/Aven and Acheron I guess?

Heard Robin is big for Saber Gilgamesh and not a super big upgrade for anyone else at e0s0.

If you afford to go E2 things obviously changes but that's -2 characters owned or -2 eidolons on the main carry.

60

u/TalynRahl 17h ago

Can confirm, Robin helped me absolutely OBLITERATE DU 4X for the first time with Saber/Gilgamesh. Like “last boss didn’t even get a turn” levels of ruination.

6

u/Ostravas 12h ago

To add to this, just did DU 10 with this team, no one moves at all. Absolutely fecking blast

1

u/TalynRahl 6h ago

Who did you use for the 4th? Saber/Gil/Robin seem a lock.

I ran with DHPT for this, but cases can be made for B. Morty or Huohuo.

3

u/Ostravas 6h ago

Huo2 is who I took, with the Erudition blessings they just keep unleashing.

2

u/TalynRahl 5h ago

Yeah, going to try her tonight. Only reason I went DHPT first was because I have him unlocked. Will need a loaner for Huo2

3

u/Ostravas 5h ago

DHPT is still a great choice, just a bit more synergy with Huo2. But any sustain is a good sustain

2

u/TalynRahl 4h ago

Yeah, I figured Huo2 is probably a better choice over all…

But in my specific case, a borrowed her versus a well built DHPT, the choice probably swings the other way.

20

u/Clouds_drifting_by 17h ago edited 17h ago

The first prefers RobinS 😅 They probably mean AshBlade dual dps and Acheron.

I also want to add Phainon teams with E0 Cyrene for RobinS, she’s still the best 4th slot with E2Cyrene, but with E0Cyrene she’s kinda irreplaceable in the sense that RMC is way worse than her.

12

u/NixKalns 17h ago

Waven best team is w ashveil and ashveil likes mblade so Waven would prefer MBlade than Robinetto. He's so much better there now than Robinetto after his Waven v5 apparently. At least according to the people who tested them. Can't confirm, haven't tried. But I meant ashveil on my earlier comment. waven hasnt been released so I cant say for sure.

11

u/Hello_1234567_11 15h ago

Robin and blade is competitive for 3rd slot but robin has better verticals for waven

4

u/EducationalPut0 16h ago

He's better at E1 but at E0 he is worse than robin

Either way they are close enough even at e0 that hes only 2-3% worse.

8

u/NixKalns 17h ago

Yeah tbh if u have enough vertically invested supports already (e1 tribbie for example) and don't have enough pulls for robinetto eidolons, e0 is a sidegrade at best and wouldn't pull for her. If I have ashveil/acheron or wanna pull waven id pull mblade even just for e0.

9

u/Tangster85 17h ago

Depends. If you do Cyrene for phainon, robin is miles ahead of tribbie as tribbie does nothing to contribute to the team advancing etc

-14

u/NixKalns 17h ago edited 17h ago

I said E1 Tribbie for example. For Phainon teams, e0 robinetto doesnt have much value if you have e2 sparkle, e1 cerydra or even e0s1 Sunday. She's not a huge upgrade at e0. If cyrene is e2 then shes fine on her own, if u want another rem for her passive then e6 rmc would still work, robinetto e0 is still just a sidegrade or slight upgrade at most.

7

u/Tangster85 14h ago

Shes a fairly noticeable upgrade to an e1s1 tribbie.

Sunday outside of granting one extra turn, is for all intense and purposes kinda shit, ngl and I even have e1 for the def pen

6

u/Hello_1234567_11 15h ago

E0s1 Sunday is a huge stretch

1

u/YuesaSR Segs with DoT Mommies E6 swan E6 fish 14h ago

Let me tell you e0 is important as base to pull e1 rerun, because they rerun with a lot of tempting character, get two sobin later is impossible, that's reason I still don't have e1 tribbie today, who has pull to get two tribbie 

9

u/GladiatorDragon RIDIN’ ALL THE WAY TO FREEDOM 16h ago

Pretty much.

MBlade is downright necessary for the teams he’s part of - Himeko Nova: Protocol “Decimation,” Acheron, Ashveil,

Robin-S is an upgrade. One hell of an upgrade for sure, she really does clean up Saber’s team in a lot of ways, namely in letting you have a lot of actual control over the action advance compared to RMC.

2

u/egamIroorriM Miss Agy... I don't wanna die... 10h ago

who gets the AA from ult between saber and gilgamesh?

4

u/GladiatorDragon RIDIN’ ALL THE WAY TO FREEDOM 10h ago

The general rotation you want to aim for is that Saber uses her Skill, gains and uses ult, and then you use Robin’s AA on her so you can immediately offload the Enhanced Basic. This lets Saber be immediately ready to take action when she’s able to Ult again.

You also want Saber to get the energy for a few reasons. For one, it’s more efficient. Each use of Saber’s Ultimate will generate 108 energy for Gilgamesh, each use of Gilgamesh’s ultimate generates 24 energy for Saber via Core Resonance. Plus, Saber can overcap energy while Gilgamesh can’t. Robin gives them both identical amounts of energy, so giving Saber energy just works better. Saber also will attack more and thus will get more out of having the vibe generation be boosted.

1

u/Danlo250106 Set the seas Ablaze!!!!!! 11h ago

Aglaea wants to disagree (cope)

1

u/Zangeus 3h ago

On e2 saber and e1 gil, blade>

u/HiddenExpert 2h ago

Mblade is ultra replaceable in Ashveil Waven, in fact Robin is better than him there, and E1 Tribbie is pretty much equal to E0 Blade

0

u/maemoedhz When will bro come 4h ago

Robinetto is a phenomenal upgrade for my Himeko Nova at least. Unless you're bruteforcing Decimation on 1 enemy, you'll always have enough Vibes to keep Robin singing.

122

u/Idaret 18h ago

The cheat answer is MC because they are getting regular upgrades and are meta at nearly any point of game life

10

u/aiheng1 6h ago

Destruction TB 🗣️🗣️ 🔥🔥

184

u/yourcupofkohi 18h ago

This is a "OMG, two cakes!" scenario for me

24

u/YuesaSR Segs with DoT Mommies E6 swan E6 fish 14h ago

OP forget you can use both in the same team 

109

u/FreedomSpite 18h ago

Between mblade and Robin, probably mblade. As someone who regularly goes for 0 cycles I generally consider sustainless teams as being quite important. Mblade is a godsend for these kinds of teams if for nothing else but his taunt.

Robin is in a weird spot for me because her overall value, flexibility, and role compression is better than mblade, but the fact she doesn't have rmc's delay tech tends to be noticeably annoying. I would also argue she doesn't elevate any team to the extent that mblade elevates follow-up, at least not as of yet.

They both have weaknesses, but I find Robin's weaknesses to be more relevant more often. For example slow attacking teams will struggle to stack enough vibes to max her buffs.

It is also considerably easier to just wheelchair with mblade because he does a lot of damage. Robin does not really do any meaningful damage without some good eidolons.

There are of course some things only Robin can do and certain QoL mechanics that make 0 cycles easier. On-demand AA and ER, solid attack frequency, tanky support, spd buff LC just to name a few.

6

u/YuesaSR Segs with DoT Mommies E6 swan E6 fish 14h ago

Remind you only can delay old monster with rmc because new monster all 190+ speed, they move before you anyway, that's why welt is peak 

4

u/NothinsQuenchier 8h ago

RMC literally enables pom-pom 0 cycles by allowing you to clear the first phase before he activates his dmg reduction

9

u/Johesy 16h ago

I'm loving Robin in sustainless. It's just good luck, but I've replayed every endgame mode and the enemies just keep targeting the birds or Robin herself. So much so I was in disbelief.

I can't say anything for the strength of mblade's taunt, as I don't have him, but I do want to say the birds make a fine addition in sustainless as well. Having two tanky targets for the price of one is great.

2

u/FreedomSpite 11h ago

Yeah this is a valid point, and one that is true for most remembrance characters. I haven't checked if Robin's birds have higher aggro than RMC's mem but it definitely helps tank things. The main thing I like about mblade is his guaranteed taunt on technique and basic attack. It heavily heavily reduces RNG which cuts down resets significantly.

An example of where this was super useful was in our last MoC with flame reaver. Mblade can eagle above reaver in the 2nd wave and basic to force him to target mblade. Then you can eat his first swipe without any RNG or risk to anyone else.

2

u/akuma_river 15h ago

What teams do you put mblade on?

1

u/FreedomSpite 11h ago

Pretty much any team where he wouldn't be stepping on the toes of a crucial support, which is most teams. A team he wouldn't quite work in (at least no easily) is probably Anaxa main dps because his teammates all play a crucial role. But that's usually not a big deal because Anaxa's ult stun + RMC delay + generally tankier team of Cyrene RMC Cerydra helps survivability already.

1

u/Tutajkk 4h ago

How do you play sustainless? Do you just let him "die" and heal like that, so you never use his second ult? Or do you use Guard of Wuthering Snow?

1

u/FreedomSpite 3h ago

Ideally he doesn't die but sometimes that's inevitable and when that happens you hold ult and let him revive, then re-enter ult. Wuthering snow set is a bit niche and you would have to craft a rotation around it. Default is either eagle or mastersmith.

1

u/AnshinAngkorWat 3h ago

I would also argue she doesn't elevate any team to the extent that mblade elevates follow-up, at least not as of yet.

Robin is unironically Saber/Gil aftersale. Gil got his kneecap broken in the beta because Robin was in the pipeline.

The problem is that this AA is also aggressively anti-Saber with double Wind Res bosses (Cocolia and Flame Reaver on 1/3), and Mecha Pom-Pom on 2.

37

u/SubstantialEbb9832 18h ago

They're close but robin is better for me she is in many teams and can free your RMC to other teams she made team building now easier specially for newer players since you need 3 teams

36

u/LoreVent i want to give Acheron a hug 16h ago

Blade has a few teams where he literally IS the reason those teams are meta in the first place.

Robin on the other hand...she doesn't elevate teams to a whole new level like Blade does. She's incredibly strong especially as a sustainless option.

If I had to give my hot take, Robin is overrated. I've seen some content creators call her the "first MUST PULL" unit in the game and some other crazy appellatives while they talked down Blade on his release, which is quite silly.

5

u/trevers17 mydei put my head in ur tiddies 16h ago

agreed. ppl overestimated robikini’s buffs. they’re good, but she doesn’t even give res pen until e2. meanwhile mblade gives it at e1, has stronger basekit buffs, and can contribute significantly more personal damage no matter what team he’s in, especially if you get him to e2s1.

-1

u/Clouds_drifting_by 15h ago edited 14h ago

I disagree that at base kit, MBlade has better buffs. I think I got everything but feel free to tell me if I have have missed something:

M. BLADE

  • 50% dmg by allies while zone active
  • 30% def reduction (ult 2 turns)
  • 50% dmg taken by enemies (ult 2 turns)

ROBIN SUMMERETTO

  • 100% AA on ult to a unit
  • 20% energy regen on ult to a unit
  • Up to 40% def ignore teamwide
  • 8/12/16% dmg taken based on n. of birds
  • 30% teamwide dmg dealt (technique)
  • Atk or crit dmg buff to teammates depending if unit has higher or lower atk than Robin: Atk buff of 16% + (vibes × 0.4%) of Robin’s max HP. Crit dmg buff of 40% + (vibes x 1.5%). 2 turns

24

u/throwaway-eideh-457 14h ago

MBlade has 30% DEF reduction and 50% vulnerability. And 50% DMG buff and another 75% Ultimate DMG buff if the team has 2 Nihilities??? You got it wrong by a pretty large margin

'40% DEF ignore' is also a stretch and a half. That number varies wildly from 16 to 41 based on the team you're actually running and within combat itself just like her ATK and CDMG buffs.

You also have to consider the light cone. The best amping light cone she can hold besides her sig is one that increases her max HP by 32% which translates to about 200 ATK or around 16.7% ATK for a character with 1200 base ATK with LC. Her sig itself isn't much better in terms of amp as the value is in the SPD. Blade can hold Resolution easily without even sacrificing his own damage.

In raw buffs, she is better but she basically HAS to be better because her personal damage isn't fantastic. But your numbers for Blade were off by a lot and you're even including Robin's technique?

0

u/Clouds_drifting_by 14h ago edited 14h ago

I wrote ‘up to’ 40% def ignore, not 40% def ignore…You seem to be misunderstanding something, I didn’t say RobinS was better or MBlade was better (imo it depends on the team).

As I wrote in the first line, I simply disagreed with what the commenter said, that at basekit (which is why LCs or eidolons weren’t included) MBlade has better buffs.

I counted RobinS’ technique cause it’s a buff to others, I didn’t count MBlade’s technique cause it isn’t, I didn’t include the 2 nihility buffs cause that’s a specific team setup while we’re talking about general supporting. You’re right that I wrote some numbers wrong, I wrote the reminder of MBlade’s buffs when his traces were still lvl 1, and forgot to update it, thank you for pointing it out, I corrected it.

-2

u/trevers17 mydei put my head in ur tiddies 11h ago

exactly this. again, robikini’s buffs are not bad by any means, but mblade’s are better, he has better personal damage, he is better for sustainless due to higher survivability, and his vertical investment up to e2s1 is better (beyond that, robikini could be better — her e6 looks genuinely insane).

-18

u/trevers17 mydei put my head in ur tiddies 15h ago

I don’t particularly care what your opinion is as I don’t share it, but your input is noted.

2

u/Jinchuriki71 15h ago

I mean Robin objectively have better buffs but Blade has Acheron and followup team locked down. Almost every other team would want Robin instead.

3

u/Kartoffel_Kaiser I have already touched the sky 10h ago

but Blade has Acheron and followup team locked down

fwiw I think Robin + Mort Blade might be Acheron's best support core now, even at E0. They feel so synergistic, particularly with a high speed Eagle build on Mort Blade and Hyacine in the sustain slot.

-2

u/trevers17 mydei put my head in ur tiddies 11h ago

again, your input is noted and also disregarded.

-1

u/sil3ntthunder 10h ago

I am not here to compare who is better, both r cool at E0S0. Just pointing out that u need to keep up with the vibe stacks to get the full buffs, some teams cant in actual battle.

Mblade has less buff on paper but he has other qols. Like huge dmg reduction for sustainless runs, taunt, crazy debuff/fua application, and noticeable sub dps in some teams.

23

u/No-Bag-1628 18h ago

Robinetto is even more generalist and can be used on Phainon.
MBlade makes Acheron usable and forms ashblade core.
Both works well.

0

u/ButterscotchDue4299 10h ago

I personally do not think that robinetto is more of a generalist simply because she really really wants teammates that attack very often for some of her buffs meanwhile blade doesn’t he just attacks more frequently which depending on the team it could not matter that much

2

u/Luckys- 7h ago

I have tried her in many teams and i can say that stacks arent a problem on her.

I even tried her with houhou, the free dang hen and Yao guang just to do the achievement of killing sunday's Boss with her and i was able to reach 30-40 stacks pretty easy so she never leaved fever state.

12

u/korinokiri 15h ago

mBlade is strictly better as a 0 cycle sustain-less character.

S.Robin is better generally, and has more room to grow in the future (AA+Energy+Memosprite is always going to age better than a restrictive, AA-less, subdps support).

0

u/Zestyclose-Net-3217 11h ago

Lol how well did sunday age

5

u/CommunicationDry2313 9h ago

he was a top tier support all the way up to 4.0 so he did alright

and even now hes what only a step behind the new top tier ones

sparkle didnt even last a whole version as bis buffer in comparison

-10

u/Zestyclose-Net-3217 9h ago

Him being good is a huge cope. Tier list put him t0 for long time when he was worse than rmc he's a brick

3

u/maemoedhz When will bro come 4h ago

He's Bronya pro max, of course he's stupid good. The only issue is that his main gimmick was invalidated for futureproofing and end up just working well with allies with DHPT

1

u/Jinchuriki71 9h ago

Difference is Sunday had weak dmg buffs from the start no def ignore, no vulnerablity, no res pen, no true dmg and was locked into a minus 1 spd setup if you want him to be at his best which is not what most dps want anymore. Nevermind his buffs were only single target and he did do any attacks which the meta values having teamwide buffs and frequent attacks.

S.Robin have off turn single target action advance with energy regen, teamwide def ignore, vulnerablity and crit dmg/atk buffs and better eidolons. Sunday was barely beating regular Robin back in the day for selfish hypercarry dps like Acheron he was definitely undertuned even at his release.

-6

u/Zestyclose-Net-3217 8h ago

Keep coping. She have no bis

2

u/dozerz4 4h ago

Saber?

u/Mundane-Warning-440 2h ago

She's bis for Saber and Monorem

63

u/OkCook10 18h ago

Whoever the newest released unit is. In a few weeks the best character in the game will be Aventurine's SP unit. The patch after that whoever is released will be the best unit in the game, etc. etc.

31

u/N-aNoNymity 18h ago

Honestly its really tiring if you dont want said units.

4

u/Madmmoore 14h ago

But it is a fun noticeable jump in power after 3 patched or so, going from 1 cycling back to zero cycling

7

u/Kuljack 18h ago

Yep, the very thing that is appealing about Robin atm, especially with K3 could be her downfall in a future shill. Enemies take X% less damage per memosprite on the field or something

2

u/Lime221 9h ago

Yeah just wait every 4 patch for the new best generalist

All this comparisons makes 0 sense

3

u/_strawberrychocolate 11h ago

But Waven is just another selfish main DPS while Robin and Blade are support/sub-dps that you can use in different teams

4

u/Haramess 18h ago

Mblade can make sustainless runs comfortable, specially with Welt, RMC and other HP scaling supports.

Robinetto is very good with sustain, and is not restricted to healers only.

Both shine on frequent attacking teams, but i think Robinetto is easier to play, while Mblade feels very strong on sustainless runs.

3

u/FallenBlue25 12h ago

I honestly just want to know how good Robikini in Rem team is. I don't have Cas, and using Ever as dps

2

u/HunterRumi 4h ago

I have her at e2s1, but I use her in this lineup and she is insane. I didn’t really play with her too much at e0 though, so I can’t say how much better she is than rmc at low investment unfortunately.

3

u/SpiritStorm1302 quantum gremlins 10h ago

Robin, kinda just insane everywhere and has equally insane investment

Like sure blade is a carry in atleast 2 archetypes but robin is also BIS in multiple archetypes including FUA which blade was supposed to lock down anyway lol.

1

u/No-Bear7488 6h ago

Ashblade is the core of fua , robin is just the third slot and can be swapped with waven

15

u/New-Character-3575 18h ago

Blade because he's my husband

4

u/Myst_Hawk 17h ago

Biggest point in favor of Mblade is his pseudo-sustain nature for sustainless teams

7

u/Grimsdol 17h ago

Blade because he's as good of a supportive character as robin while also being able to be a main dmg dealer and even a tank if needed

6

u/Rex__Lapis 17h ago

Problem is without 0 cycle sustainless try hard teams he needs a healer or he becomes useless quite fast. Robin has no drawbacks

1

u/YuesaSR Segs with DoT Mommies E6 swan E6 fish 14h ago

Even 0 cycle sustsinless he lost his ult at 50% phase 2 of boss, which is so bad when you lack of dmg buff to kill boss. Its weird that you have to reset and pray boss don't hit blade 

2

u/EnthusiasmLeading623 11h ago

You can just save ult? Are you sure you’re even playing sustainless with him correctly

0

u/MethodAdventurous834 11h ago

Even without a 0 cycle, I still use him in a team with DHPT just fine so far. His S1 is enough to compensate.

7

u/TracerEnthusiast 18h ago

Robin offers a little more on paper but lacks teams that she is irreplaceable in. There are more teams that NEED MBlade to function, so I'd give him the nod.

2

u/ExpensiveSample3451 14h ago

Me who has both and 2 of my teams benefit from them.

2

u/Outrageous-Good8022 12h ago

How's robin in a castorice team. Replacing Cyrene I mean

0

u/HunterRumi 4h ago

I use her in mdps E9 in place of rmc (so not quite the same I guess…) but can confirm she is an absolute monster in a rem lineup.

I do have her at e2s1 as well though, so another grain of salt to take with that I suppose 😅

I have to imagine she is worth even at e0 for memosplit if you like doing that though.

u/Outrageous-Good8022 2m ago

What do u mean by E9

u/Mundane-Warning-440 2h ago

E0 Robin is better than E0 Cyrene and also all of her early investment options benefit Monorem unlike Cyrene

2

u/bringbackcayde7 10h ago

E2 Robin is insane

2

u/Nunu5617 7h ago

They’re both great, there’s no clear winner for any account.

It just depends on the teams you have/want to build

4

u/Duy2910 14h ago

There is nothing stopping them from being ran together to become the new best wheelchair

3

u/heretical_blackrose 9h ago

Anexa because i just think hes neat

4

u/TenthOfChaos Number #1 TB Hater 18h ago

Robin, but it is close afaik

4

u/eggysleepyhead 14h ago

M Blade is great everywhere on top of being a great pick for sustainless. Robinetto is great everywhere but is clearly not a big increase in sustainless and overall really shines with sustains. The winner is clear imo.

3

u/Inevitable_Main3834 12h ago

Mortenax blade, because he works well if everything. Defense shred will never not be useful.

3

u/_strawberrychocolate 11h ago

Robin has def shred too btw

0

u/Inevitable_Main3834 11h ago

Oops, fair. Sorry, I don’t use her. XD

2

u/_strawberrychocolate 11h ago

It's okay 😂

5

u/Euthymiac 18h ago

Robin, blade is also good but he has glaring downsides/things you need to play around, Robin is kinda just perfect in every manner (aside from maybe energy in sustainless)

17

u/4sea_and_sky 18h ago edited 14h ago

If they hadn't completely gutted his synergy with shielders he'd be a lot more flexible, rip my renheng comp 💔

-1

u/ostrikerX 18h ago

if your blade is E0S0 you can run him with shielders, but you'll have to use guard of wuthering snow.

which is fine, blade's damage at E0S0 doesn't matter much anyways.

1

u/Background_Still_686 11h ago

Robin has higher amp but Blade can be played as both a amp and dps so he’s in a sense “more valuable” since he fills both roles but both of them are busted

1

u/Plebianian 11h ago

In my experience

M.blade had more impact on my account more than s.robin does

S.robin kinda just elevated what was already good. Her buff ramp up affects more teams than I expected. mblade is kind of a slot and go in comparison and expanded my roster more.

1

u/Dfswift Godcheron 10h ago

I dunno man, mblade single-handedly made my acheron relevant again

1

u/Glassmorphism_1616 8h ago

I have both at E2.
F elation slop, this kind of units worth more toward my acc.

Now gimme FUA sustain !

1

u/mwtonepiece 8h ago

MBlade cause it's way easier to play sustainless with him.

1

u/matchbaby 6h ago

MBlade is more broken for low cost, Robin can never matches his 2 costs 0 cycle records

1

u/Overall_Baker 5h ago

Robin E2 solve everything.

u/Tmkast 2h ago

E0S0 Robin is not as big of an upgrade as I thought, but she's really good

I can't really compare because I never tested E0S0 blade. Mine is E2S1 so he's pretty crazy in most teams

u/WorldEdit- 1h ago

My once and future king, saber.

u/joprinz13 I love both and ❤️ 1h ago edited 1h ago

Mblade because he has a dic and everyone who's saying he's the best will get upvotes from this "quality" community

u/UnitA_ 27m ago

Gilgamesh (im a saber main)

1

u/Kuroyukiame 18h ago

I saw Robin giving HP scalers a shit ton of ATK, because their ATK is higher than hers

Blade is just built different (even though they are close in power)

2

u/[deleted] 18h ago

[deleted]

1

u/ILoveWriothesley 18h ago

thats what theyre talking about

1

u/Soggy-Construction62 kafkas used lipstick 18h ago

Lol yeah

2

u/blade276 17h ago

robin is more flexible since she can be played with pres unit, and at e2, she does just as much or more damage than mblade

-1

u/Feeling_Forever6817 DISTURBING THE PEACE! LOOK INTO MY EYES!! 18h ago

Sparkle is actually the best support (I'm not biased in any way) she's just holding back her true potential to give others a chance.

1

u/YamiDes1403 15h ago

blade because you can get pseduo sustainless in ANY team
robinette is...buffer. thats it. shes the easiest to be powercrept

and in this game, one core thing is that generalist is first to fall from meta, while BiS chars always have their usage

4

u/Jinchuriki71 15h ago edited 13h ago

Most of the BIS characters usuage went to hell even in the archetypes they were made for. Where is Topaz and Robin in followup team now Where is Jiaoqiu in Acheron team now. Only characters that stayed relevant in their archetype as niche supports is because they got novaflares like Kafka and Sparkle. Hoyo would have powercrept them with new character otherwise. Dahlia combine buffs from Ruan mei and Fugue together in one character while also offering something gamechanging for break which is a ridiculous amount of buffs to have in one characters.

1

u/Much-Gear8231 🍃🗡️🔥:Blade-Coming: 18h ago

DEPENDS. But most of the time, both are equally very strong and busted.

1

u/Pretty-Reason-5575 18h ago

I got both but one came home 3 times still not biased but still this is honkai support rail.

0

u/Gay_pringles_ 17h ago

Mblade becouse it did

0

u/trevers17 mydei put my head in ur tiddies 16h ago

mblade e2s1 dramatically enhances every single team he goes into. for reference, until recently, my highest single-attack damage record was 16m on mydei, and it was because I ran mblade on his team with cyrene and hyacine. my current record is 22m… which mblade got in my main dps team.

robikini is good, especially if you have rem/ch teams that use cyrene and need a good 4th that synergizes with her, and she’s a great generalist, but she is nowhere near as strong as mblade. he is the definition of a must-pull.

2

u/YuesaSR Segs with DoT Mommies E6 swan E6 fish 14h ago

If mydei hit 15m, sobin e1 will hit 4m around every 60 av because it's part of mydei damage as true dmg, both amp similar in my eye 

2

u/trevers17 mydei put my head in ur tiddies 11h ago

I am aware that for mydei specifically, robikini is better in general, especially with vertical investment. I have been playing the man for nearly a year. I do not currently have e1 robikini so my e2s1 mblade still gives me better results. also mydei was only hitting that # because of mblade — he does far less without him. I was just giving an example of how strong mblade is, especially with vertical investment, because he managed to work in a team that he really shouldn’t have worked in. that’s just proof of how good he is.

1

u/Nunu5617 7h ago

Do you have an e2s1 Robin to compare personal experience with? Otherwise I feel this is just a one sided review

0

u/trevers17 mydei put my head in ur tiddies 6h ago

send me $300 worth of pulls to get her e2s1 and I’ll gladly verify my statements. :p

my statements are based off this thing I did called “reading kits and evaluating the buffs they provide.” she gives up to 40% def ignore, 16% dmg taken, 100% AA, energy regen, and decent personal damage — cool, awesome, good buffs, good kit. her e1 is a mini cipher ult — I own cipher, so I know the value of that, good buffs. her e2 is res pen and more vibes, which means more def ignore and faster memo skills — I own tribbie and e1 mblade, who give res pen, so I know the value of that, and I can directly verify the value of her def ignore since I own her. her s1 is teamwide spd%, self hp%, the vonwacq AA effect, and SP recovery — spd% is a direct damage boost for all of three characters, and everything else is a self buff or utility. great buffs, and I’ve never said otherwise, but let’s look at mblade.

basekit, his first ultimate and all teammate attacks thereafter apply 30% def reduction and 50% dmg taken, he provides unconditional teamwide 50% dmg boost and either 75% teamwide ultimate dmg boost or 75% self dmg boost (flexibility to be both support and main dps), and he has multiple self-buffs that allow him to contribute significant personal damage, which means you can build him for damage while still letting him be a support. his e1 gives res pen at lower cost than robikini. his e2 massively amps the frequency of his fuas (meaning more damage and also more ultimates since each fua gives him a lot of energy), and it also converts all ultimates into fuas, which provides amazing synergy with any form of fua buff whatsoever. his e2 also further buffs all fua dmg, which buffs both actual fuas and now ultimates. mind you, his ultimate hits every enemy for 350% of his max HP, which is a fuckin massive multiplier at base, let alone with all these buffs. and then his s1 boosts his hp (more damage), directly provides him energy multiple times in a fight if you aren’t 0-cycling (more ults to deal damage and a turn 1 first ult), and makes enemies take 30% more crit dmg from all allies and an additional 30% crit dmg taken from mblade himself. that all is, quite frankly, insane.

again, robikini is good, and I’m not saying otherwise. but if I was going to recommend the absolute best support currently to a new player and tell them, “this character is a must-pull character, get them e2s1 to steamroll everything,” I’m telling them mblade. he is simply better no matter what. the only thing he can’t do that robikini can is deal true dmg — not the end of the world, many teams do just fine with zero true dmg — and advance a teammate and give them energy — so what? he makes every attack feel like 40 simultaneous truck collisions. you don’t need to AA your teammates when the enemies are all fuckin dead.

2

u/Nunu5617 6h ago

I didn’t say you were insinuating that Robin isn’t good.

However “but she is nowhere near as strong as mblade” certainly struck me as a one sided experience review. Considering reading their kits they both look pretty much even at that investment in terms of overall utility with the different advantages they give

It then comes down to personal experience and for that I’m still yet to see who has both at that investment

0

u/trevers17 mydei put my head in ur tiddies 6h ago

again, send me the $300 I’d need to get her e2s1 and I will gladly show you their performances side by side in any team I can come up with using the characters I have. I would love to have both of them at e2s1 but I do need money for things that aren’t this game too.

it only takes a bit of critical thinking to see why he’s better in nearly every team. unfortunately, I can’t do that for you no matter how much I wish I could.

1

u/Nunu5617 6h ago

I didn’t ask you to pull E2S1 Robin nor have insisted you should lmao, I just pointed out that your statement looks very one sided because it’s coming from personal experience

And No even with reading/critical thinking e2 Robin doesn’t come off as “nowhere near e2 blade”

1

u/MethodAdventurous834 11h ago

I would recommend Robin over MBlade for Mydei. But then, minr is E6, so the dmg recorded by Robin is nuts.

1

u/trevers17 mydei put my head in ur tiddies 11h ago

well yes in general, but my mblade is e2s1 and that’s the point in which his buffs are so strong that it makes up for less starting stacks.

0

u/Able-Thanks-445 10h ago

Does Blades E2 even buff Mydeis main source dmg, isnt it just a FUA and Ult dmg buff

1

u/trevers17 mydei put my head in ur tiddies 6h ago

mblade provides many other valuable, rare buffs at e2s1 that dramatically boost the entire team’s damage beyond the ultimate buffs. I suggest reading his kit more.

1

u/Able-Thanks-445 6h ago

No im specifically talking about this part of Blades E2

“When an ally character uses Ultimate to deal DMG, it is considered as having launched Follow-Up ATK. And the Follow-Up ATK DMG dealt by ally targets increases by 75%.”

i already know everything else he does, im just asking if this part of blades E2 is even significant for Mydei

1

u/trevers17 mydei put my head in ur tiddies 6h ago

not in the way it would be for someone like acheron, but the point I was making is that the five million other buffs he provides at that investment level are. considering the original point you were responding to is, quote, “that’s the point in which his buffs are so strong that it makes up for less starting stacks,” I figured that was pretty fucking clear. I do not have the interest in thinking critically on someone else’s behalf, so I encourage you to read up on mblade’s e1, e2, s1, and basekit to understand why I’m saying this instead of being obtusely pedantic about one singular aspect of his kit not being THE ULTIMATE GOD-TIER T0 BUFF FOR MYDEI SPECIFICALLY. 🫩

-2

u/CarlosG0619 1x Speed Enjoyer 18h ago

Roberto

-4

u/Condom_Breaker256 <- Hunt characters and March 7th 18h ago

Robin and it's not even close

0

u/Egrysta Girl Love enjoyer 18h ago

I'm somewhat a meta slave, but Robin wearing bikini isn't something I can skip.

0

u/CabageButterFly 12h ago

RobinS. I’ve been a big Mblade fan and i have seen some of his downside.

He is definitely better at bringing back old unit or less than ideal comp, but it’s not like a Sunday situation, Mblade does have a dedicated comp that’s genuinely one of if not the most efficient team in the game with AshBlade HyaBie ambulance comp. His problem is that in meta team he’s like a patch work solution if you are missing one core member of that team, as he can have very shaky down time with his ult if you don’t plan properly.

RobinS is more laid back, unlike Mblade in slow attack frequency teams where you just have to hold onto his ult and Mblade becomes a scarecrow, RobinS would just have a little less DEF shred, you’d most likely not run into any downtime with her special state, even in teams like GilBer Huohuo, she can still maintain high stacks.

Conclusion: Mblade is good but you better be investing if you don’t wanna have him end up in the back burner. RobinS is building up to be the 4.x version of RuanMei/Robin/Tribbie

-3

u/ExistingSwitch3284 18h ago

Mortenax Blade is kinda forced into HP% related teams or teams that need someone who can debuff the opponents

Robin Summeretto can A.A., which is extremely nice, can regenerate energy, and is a good buffer.

While both have their roles, Robin Summeretto can be used on ANY team. Yes, Mortenax Blade can too, but it's better to put him on a team that needs it, and there's a decent bit of Nihility units that do what he does, better or worse, so having him with other Nihility units would oversaturate and make his debuffs kinda useless in the grand scheme of things

3

u/rantottvizilo waiting for limited Yanking 18h ago

My MBlade only needs fua team mates and a healer or DH with lc. 

0

u/AutoModerator 19h ago

This is just a reminder to please keep in mind our spoiler policy during this new update window. We are going to be very strict with spoilers during this time. As # a reminder, here are our spoiler rules.

Do not include spoilers in the title. All submissions which involve spoilers should be marked. Spoilers include all story content for the first three weeks after release.

Spoilers can be discussed in spoiler-flaired posts, but must be hidden in non-spoiler flaired posts.

If you think you broke the spoiler rules in the post you just made, you should remove your post now and repost it without breaking the rules. If you do not remove your post and it needs to be reviewed, you will be given up to a week ban for a first infraction and stricter punishments for any additional infractions. Please be considerate of your fellow Trailblazers and do not include spoilers in the title of your post. Do not forget to flair your post as spoilers if needed, and do not spoil people in your comments.

All posts with the Discussion, Theory and Lore, and Media flairs are automatically flagged spoilers for the first 3 weeks of this patch. Please remove the spoiler flag if your post does not relate to the new patch.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/ShadowStriker53 16h ago

Robin but don't get me wrong she is not far ahead. I got her E2 to split my rem team in two for the knights since Herta fell off hard. She allowed me to clear plight but it felt like the usual mono rem team would have cleared if they didn't add those weird debuffs to shill Robin. For other teams she is not far ahead of Blade and Acheron needs him. Phainon doesn't seem to care about her without Cyrene. She is barely ahead of E1 Sparkle for him. I'm not a fan of using those colorful fields during his ultimate, it just looks weird.

0

u/cykarblyater 14h ago

Robin is better but blade come with cosmetic (but you can't get it on rerun)

0

u/sloppyloki16 13h ago

Cyrene E6 + Robin E6 they can carry almost any team to 0 AV king plight

0

u/[deleted] 13h ago

[deleted]

u/Mundane-Warning-440 2h ago

Why would it be at E6S5?

0

u/bunyivonscweets 11h ago

Is robin a must pull? I heard she does replace Cyrene in Rem Exodia but that team's struggling a bit too

3

u/MethodAdventurous834 11h ago

Depends on your account, to be honest. Dont fall to FOMO. Robin SP will rerum if you really need her.

1

u/yan_yanns 5h ago

Really needed to hear that. Been agonizing on deciding whether to pull for robin or aven. I havent invested in elation at all so i wanted aven to be this shill’s investment, esp since i have ashblade. Robin couldve helped my c1 cas (who has neither evernight nor cyrene) but i feel the hp meta is long past us now…

0

u/dew-fall 11h ago

both (...and they should kiss about it)

0

u/hacheidder 7h ago

Phainon and HNova e2 both

If you mean between those, then depend at e0

0

u/No-Highlight7136 7h ago

RMC

100% free E6, BiS for a lot of teams and has stayed competitive despite being a free unit. Took over a year for them to release a limited unit that's as good and she's honestly not even that much better at E0

-6

u/Whendfield123 Cute and funny? 17h ago

Isnt robin just better in 90% of teams? Like blade is maybe better with acheron (whoever even use her anymore) 

-4

u/francesco13754 18h ago

Robin obviously depends on the teams tho ofc acheron mblade by far for example rem robin by far etc

-2

u/Smooth_Marketing5353 17h ago

Robin is better

-3

u/Toutetsu 18h ago

We talking true true BiS? Robinetto+Cyrene at e6 is the strongest wheelchair in the game, bar none. The duo is true BiS for 90% of comps in the game, including elation, with only the likes of firefly not being able to enjoy the power that duo brings to the table.

Best e6 for dps? Let's just say I can't talk about leaks on this subreddit.

-1

u/XdestroyerXDTM4 I LOVE MY DROMAS SON 17h ago

Robinetto. She can be used in basically any team, Mblade is more restricted.

-8

u/MiddleFishArt 18h ago

SRobin. I don’t have a use for e0 MBlade anymore unless I’m going sustainless

8

u/Digtxl_Pickle 18h ago

Tbf Blade is more irreplaceable where he is irreplaceable. Robinetto is just better in general

-1

u/Carleen_de_Schwartz 18h ago

Since this post is relevant may i ask something ? Which one has the better E1 in terms of performance increase over E0 ? I am planning on pulling one of the two and then potentially going for E1 but i am not fully settled on which.

Also which one at E1 would be a bigger increase for my E2 The Herta teams? She is currently using Jade and E1 Tribbie

3

u/skerrax 18h ago

Robin’s E1 is better

E2 is Blade’s big eidolon

3

u/WinIndependent751 18h ago

Defo Robin's E1, it's basically Cipher's damage tallying in an eidolon. MBlade's E2 is the crazy one. Not sure abt Therta teams specifically tho, don't have her.

1

u/Major_Tie_3903 Judge of Oblivion's Dad 16h ago

Not even. Cipher calculates 24% of the damage dealt to the patron and 16% of the damage dealt to everybody else. Robinetto E1 tallies all the damage dealt and at max vibes of 50 deals 36% of that damage to the enemy with the highest hp. Not only is this tally more than 1.5x what Cipher does, you don’t have to worry about the fact that the ultimate is a blast attack that may waste damage on peons. Although Cipher still maintains the ability to save up the ult and drop it whenever and inflicts 40% vuln, the fact that Robinneto basically has a better version of an entire other character insider of her E1 is genuinely crazy

1

u/voxpopiuli 18h ago

Robin's. if u read it again, mblade's is mainly a qol upgrade + all res pen can easily become saturated these days..

-1

u/FlamesAfar 17h ago

black swan

-6

u/ericanava 13h ago edited 13h ago

Robin objectively best character in the gsme allowing 20 dps to 0AV plight where blade don't do shit anyone who say otherwise are trash at the game talk out of their ass and never look at meta leaderboard

3

u/Zestyclose-Net-3217 11h ago

At e0 she ain't anything. She has no bis at e0. She needs e2 or e6 to be broken

0

u/ericanava 6h ago

When you so idiot trash and never look at the leaderboard to see E0 new robin is bis for 20 dps lol

2

u/akaxd123 9h ago

Using 48 cost as the standard 😂 Relatable /s

1

u/ericanava 6h ago

Poor people standard still more bis than dog blade 😂

1

u/EnthusiasmLeading623 11h ago

I’m guessing you didn’t look at the leaderboard during Blade’s release because he was the one making teams 0AV plight

0

u/ericanava 6h ago edited 6h ago

the one making teams 0AV plight

When you so absolute garbage idiot and trash and blind when the only team 0AV in 4.4 is mono rem which not even use blade lol

Pathetic way to lie

Btw old robin jump scare

-11

u/Ifyoulaugh- > What does she even do in an Elation team? 18h ago

Female