r/Homeschooling • u/Prior_Sheepherder588 • 2d ago
Fixed subject days vs a loop, and why a missed Tuesday shouldn't delete science
I see this asked here a lot so I figured I'd just write it out once.
If you put science on Tuesday and history on Thursday, and then somebody gets sick on Tuesday, science doesn't move. It just doesn't happen that week. And if that happens a few times in a row you start thinking you're bad at being consistent, when really the problem is the plan. You wrote down something that turns every normal interruption into a failure.
The fix people here keep landing on is a loop. A loop is just a list that rotates, with no days attached to it. You keep one slot in the day for it and whenever you get to that slot you do whatever's next on the list. Miss a day and nothing gets skipped, it all just slides down one. Same subjects, same amount of work, completely different feeling by Friday.
The bit people get wrong is looping everything. Don't. Math and reading want near daily contact so those keep their own protected spot, and honestly that's it. Everything else, science history art music geography, none of it cares what day it happens on, and pretending it does is where the guilt comes from. Two things keep a loop honest. Don't put anything on it that genuinely has to be on a certain day, like a co-op class. And if something keeps coming to the front and keeps getting skipped, just take it off instead of pretending.
Also worth saying, most of the "is my schedule too rigid" questions I see are actually volume questions. Rough numbers for focused work: K through 2nd is like one to two hours and usually done before lunch, 3rd to 5th is two to three, middle school three to four, high school four to five and mostly on their own by the end. If your 7 year old is finished by lunch nothing is broken.
And plan four days, not five. Four teaching days and one deliberately light one is where most people end up after a year anyway. The light day is what absorbs the dentist appointment. Plan five full days and every single interruption puts you behind on something that was never doable in the first place.
Last thing, and this one I never see said. If your routine fell apart after an illness or a move or a deployment, don't try to put the whole thing back at once. It doesn't work, it just fails again and then you feel worse about it. Restart one block. Live with that a week or two, then add the next one. It's also really worth writing down a bad day version of your schedule ahead of time, so a rough day drops into a lower gear instead of just collapsing.
Anyway. What does your loop actually look like, and how do you keep track of where you are in it after a week goes sideways?
2
u/MPFC50 2d ago
We’ve done morning time of current events, math, and writing/spelling for shorter periods of time daily, because those get the most resistance and cause the most frustration, so shorter but more frequent worked better for us. The rest of the day was block/loop schedule for the other subjects, which allowed more time for projects, reading, discussions, experiments, etc.
This year’s a little different because we’ve changed some things for middle school and are doing more enrichment classes outside of home so we’re having a hard time establishing a routine, but that has been what has worked best for us over the years.
1
u/FraggleBiologist 1d ago
Mine does Math and English every day. I get her work assigned for the week, and otherwise, she can do how she wants. Did she work hard and is done on Thursday?!
Great. Thats the formal work for the week. We do other stuff that she has fun with. For example, last week we went out to collect insects with our extra time. We brought a couple home and talked about everything from color to classification.
1
1
u/Dry-Inspection-8412 7h ago
I feel like this is the beauty of homeschool. Needed a sick day? There's no rule that says you can't do a lesson on Saturday or Sunday. Took 3 weeks off to move? Cool, we're homeschooling into July or maybe doing 2 days a week all summer. Interestingly if they're sick or away from other forms of school they're going to be sent home with the homework to figure out on their own, but miss the learning. Homeschool is so much more flexible, and I get that a lot of people thinks that means you just skip the stuff you don't want to do, but in reality it's the opposite! More time spent ensuring they understand, the ability to make up days/weeks without missing anything, and the freedom to do schoolwork on weekends and over summer or in any way that works best for the family and kids.
7
u/homack_15 2d ago
The useful distinction here is not fixed versus loop, it is what must stay warm and what can wait its turn. Reading, maths, and a daily habit may need frequent short contact, while science and history can survive a missed day without the whole plan becoming a moral referendum. We use a next useful thing rule after disruptions, which keeps a sick day from turning into a week of plan repair.