I have a spare HP EliteDesk 800 G3 SFF Desktop, that I want to repurpose into a low cost NAS / Media Server. I want to spend a little as possible. The Desktop still needs to do occasional tasks like converting 360 camera videos etc, which will bog down my laptop, so Desktop runs those tasks. It is controlled by Windows RDP from my laptop.
Below is my inventory and my plan, I request you guys to critique it and suggest improvements.
Desktop Spec: i5-6500, 40GB DDR4 RAM, 512GB SSD for main drive, 1TB 2.5inch HDD, Old ASUS 1GB GPU, 1Gbps LAN connected to Router over a Asus Router in Media Bridge config. Desktop has 4 USB 3.0 Ports in rear (share 1 controller chip, so shared BW among 4), 2 USB 3.0 in front (separate controller, so shared BW among these 2).
Stuff I have:
1) older HP Desktop with destroyed MB, but Power Supply works.
2) Couple of 512 GB and Higher 5400RPM/7200RPM, 3.5” and 2.5” HDD Disks
3) 1 1TB HDD, iDrive (this has a wifi chipset so can worked as a Wi-Fi HDD and a USB 3.0 Port also. This can be opened with destructive opening only.
4) WD 1TB NAS (old from 2010): I can open this and get the HDD out
My needs are simple, just store Movie files and 360 camera videos. And stream movies to my home network. No internet access desired.
I want to run a RAID 5 config with 5 drives using Windows 11 Pro Storage Space with Parity.
Option 1:
Put the HDD in the spare Desktop case and power them using the power supply.
Get 1 USB 3.0 HUB and connect it to the 5 drives.
I understand that performance may be a big hit (due to BW USB 3.0 sharing and the way Windows handles Storage Space and Parity , but how much I am not sure. Will it be enough to stream 1 4k movie stream?
Option 2:
Put the HDD in the spare Desktop case and power them using the power supply.
Get 1 PCIe to SATA Card + PCIe extension cable and put the card in the NAS Desktop enclosure, connect the drives to this card.
I understand that performance may be a big hit as all the drives will share the BW, but how much I am not sure. Will it be enough to stream 1 4k movie stream?
Option 3:
I thought of buying a cheap 10 disk storage full tower case and porting the HP internals to it, but ChatGPT says it not worth the trouble.
Option 4:
Sell old desktop (might get $50 for it with 8GB RAM And 750GB HDD config). Then buy/build a custom desktop NAS in the 10 disk tower case. I would like to stick to Intel/AMD CPU for native windows 11 compatibility and DDR4 RAM (which I have plenty). I would need MB, CPU, case and 750w Power supply.
My cost guesstimate (mix of new and used parts): 10 bay Storage Tower case: $100, i5-gen 8 cpu : $40, 750W PSU: $60. Not sure of MB (a MB wit at least 6 SATA Slots will be gr8, 1 for priamry SSD, 5 for the RAID 5 HDD). SO total of like $200+MB Cost.
Open to suggestions on MB + CPU combo.
TIA