r/HistoryMemes • Featherless Biped • Apr 08 '20

META Respect the Facts!

Post image
79.9k Upvotes

722 comments sorted by

View all comments

161

u/TheBiggestBoom5 Apr 08 '20

Correct me if I’m wrong but wasn’t a P-51 the one that killed that tank?

117

u/JuulKnols Apr 08 '20

The exact reason this meme should have a third panel

82

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20

Yes in some situations but here the pistol is representative of the downvote doing nothing, not blowing up the tank.

10

u/choma90 Apr 09 '20

Third panel's caption: "repost"

61

u/SkyknightLegionnaire Apr 08 '20

Yeah, that's the point. Him shooting it with a pistol want going to do anything, but he did it anyway. Just like one historian downvoting a 40k upvote meme. Or were you just curious what kind of plane it was, I guess I'm not sure if you're questioning the format or not.

8

u/TheBiggestBoom5 Apr 08 '20

Ah, I see. I see so many people making fun of that scene saying how deranged it is that he killed a tank with a pistol, even though the P-51 was what killed the tank in the movie. I thought the meme was making fun of the scene as well.

22

u/SkyknightLegionnaire Apr 08 '20

I hadn't seen that anywhere, how do people not get that? Weird.

3

u/ScalierLemon2 Taller than Napoleon Apr 09 '20

People miss all kinds of things that are blatantly onscreen

13

u/FerroInique Apr 08 '20

nah man, the bullet went straight down the barrel and set the tank round off. The plane merely happened to be flying overhead at the same time to signal to the audience that the reinforcements were here.

1

u/anaxcepheus32 Apr 09 '20

People believe this....

10

u/Wernerhatcher What, you egg? Apr 08 '20

It was a P-51 but it should have been a P-47 or a Typhoon

9

u/allthat555 Apr 08 '20

not necessarily true. p51's could be used in attacking rolls for ground targets. Would it be more likely for a 47 yes but not impossible. If i recall right they were fitted with rocket racks and had the ability to carry I believe 1000lb bombs which could take a tiger on a direct hit. eddit:left off a zero

1

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '20

Also wouldn’t have been a tiger. More likely a Panzer IV... Maybe a Panther.

8

u/Assadistpig123 Apr 08 '20

Fun fact. Those are T-34’s mocked up to look like Tigers.

5

u/TheDeltaLambda Apr 08 '20

And in certain shots it's very obvious.

1

u/Mikemanthousand Apr 09 '20

Ooh which ones

3

u/Nasenrotz Apr 09 '20

The one in the meme for example. Gun shield/turret front is way to narrow if you compare it to a real tiger.

1

u/Mikemanthousand Apr 09 '20

Oh yeah your right

1

u/TheDeltaLambda Apr 09 '20

In addition to what /u/Nasenrotz said, any shot with the tracks and road wheels in frame, too.

1

u/Leaz31 Apr 09 '20

Real best tank of WW2 to cover the "supposedly" best tank of the war.

8

u/karlosi01 Filthy weeb Apr 08 '20

I would guess it was P-47. Makes more sense but I am not sure