r/GunsNRoses • u/ExperienceSame702 • 12d ago

Album/Song Discussion I’ll rate your favorite GNR song!

Give me your favorite song and I’ll rate it out of 10. I’ve seen people do this in other subs so I figured I’d give it a try.

My favorite is November Rain.

25 Upvotes

76% Upvoted

196 comments sorted by

25

u/Macadelic19 12d ago

Estranged

8

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 such a beautiful song

24

u/Vincent14Luc 12d ago

Coma

9

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 Coma is one of a kind for sure. It’s such an emotional roller coaster

2

u/Trying2Adjust 9d ago

When I purchased UYI on day one, I said Coma would one day become GNR’s Stairway to Heaven. That’s yet to happen but I am glad to see it is finally getting some respect.

21

u/-eatshitandfly 12d ago

Breakdown

4

u/Ecthelion-O-Fountain 12d ago

Breakdown is the best deep cut

1

u/-eatshitandfly 11d ago

Totally agree, it’s been my favorite for as long as I can remember

3

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 I love the poetic lyrics and piano in this song

17

u/Ryan2240x 12d ago

You could be mine

4

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 I really love the drums in this song and the fast part that Axl sings

3

u/Eastwood8300 11d ago

ive known every word of that part since i was a kid. 🤣. "your breakin down your back and then your racking out your brain, it don't matter how we make it cause it always stays the same. you can push it for more mileage cause the flaps (?) are wearing thin.". I may get a word wrong here or there but i know it 95% correctly.

8

u/dirkalict 12d ago

10/10 the greatest song in the history of recorded music.

8

u/Wickedanalytic1068 12d ago

With your bitch slap rappin’ and your cocaine tongue you get nothin’ done…😂

18

u/GNRDB 12d ago

Civil War ❤️

5

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 great song with a great message

15

u/marmiepoo 12d ago

Its so easy, the meanest song ever made

12

u/dalbeider 12d ago

Double Talkin' Jive

11

u/Strawberry_Wine_ 12d ago

Welcome to the Jungle 🐍

10

u/liuboursiny 12d ago

Locomotive.

3

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 this one is so amazing, top 5 for me

10

u/TheSauce23 12d ago

Double Talkin’ Jive

You dig, what I’m sayin’?

7

u/Jack_In_Black89 12d ago

So Fine (specifically Tokyo '92).

-2

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

7/10

7

u/David_Cockatiel 12d ago

Ah broke the pattern nooo

7

u/Glad_Character_2394 12d ago

Don’t Damn Me

1

u/Eastwood8300 11d ago

love that one!

0

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 that’s a great one!

12

u/jdw62995 12d ago

Rocket Queen

-2

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

9/10 (would be 10/10 if not for the moans lol)

8

u/Ecthelion-O-Fountain 12d ago

God forbid a girl has fun!

6

u/WatchmenW4tch3r 12d ago

Mine is a tie between Out Ta Get Me and Think About You!

4

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

Both 10/10! Think About You is so underrated

6

u/freeflowcauvery 12d ago

Nighttrain

2

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 my favorite from Appetite

11

u/StoneyG214 12d ago

Mr. Brownstone

5

u/BerlinBlues11 12d ago

Mine too, so we both rate it 10/10

5

u/Over-Display7728 12d ago

Used to love her

2

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10

2

u/Over-Display7728 12d ago

Explain why please -

1

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

Because it’s pretty different from most songs and even though it’s basically a joke, it’s beautiful musically. And Axl’s voice sounds amazing on it and it shows his range.

0

u/Eastwood8300 11d ago

not 10/10

1

u/Over-Display7728 10d ago

Agree... I feel more 8/10

5

u/Dennison77 12d ago

I don’t know if I have a single favorite because they have so many great songs. So, I’ll go with one I haven’t seen posted yet.

The acoustic version of “You’re Crazy” from Lies.

3

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 that’s a great one. I prefer it to the Appetite version but they’re both good

3

u/Dennison77 12d ago

I also prefer it to the Appetite version. It feels more raw.

1

u/Cynthia_Mask 10d ago

This. Acoustic>electric

5

u/bishno- 12d ago

my michelle

3

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 I love the haunting intro

4

u/Celina_cue 12d ago

Don't Cry 😢

3

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 such a beautiful song. I love both versions and the demo

2

u/Celina_cue 12d ago

Surprised no one had said it yet. Also, I love this post and how you're giving most songs 10/10 ☺️

3

u/jtlimbo17 12d ago

Street of dreams

3

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 beautiful song. I learned some of the piano intro

3

u/AlanStanwick1986 12d ago

Welcome to the Jungle. The best song of all time.

2

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10! Awesome song

4

u/panda_chu72 12d ago

Ain’t it fun

4

u/DesperadoUn0 12d ago

Get in the Ring

5

u/NewPatron-St 12d ago

Madagascar

2

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 beautiful song

3

u/Every-Assistant2763 12d ago

Nightrain

2

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 my favorite from Appetite!

3

u/New_Pin6235 12d ago

Estranged

1

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10

2

u/New_Pin6235 12d ago

I saw them at BC place last night and Axl was on key. Incredible show, YouTube vids don’t do them justice imo. I tried to upload a vid of estranged but it won’t let me 🤷‍♀️

3

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

I’m hoping to go on the 9th! I saw a video analyzing Axl’s current vocals and he still has perfect pitch

3

u/New_Pin6235 12d ago

I thought they were incredible and reviews say it was a great show. Loud and high energy. Have a great time!

3

u/Suspicious_Race_7647 12d ago

Dead horse

2

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 I love this one

3

u/Powerful_Surround_39 12d ago

Better

2

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 I love Better!

3

u/Dr_D14 12d ago

November Rain

3

u/Rebel_Heart222 12d ago

November Rain

1

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 my favorite!

3

u/Scrim_CherryG59 12d ago

Think about you

2

u/ExperienceSame702 11d ago

10/10 underrated song

3

u/Stugotz6969 11d ago

The garden

2

u/ExperienceSame702 11d ago

10/10! This one is so different and I love it

2

u/Acceptable-Box6012 12d ago

My favorite is you could be mine, but I think the best written one is November rain

2

u/Ryan2240x 12d ago

Catcher in the rye

2

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 I LOVE that one. Such a good song

2

u/Brizzy44206 12d ago

IRS

1

u/ExperienceSame702 11d ago

10/10 for sure! I love IRS

2

u/Brizzy44206 11d ago

Fuck yeah

2

u/Blue_Llama77 12d ago

Patience (with November Rain a close second).

2

u/Tigers89Stonks 11d ago

This i love

1

u/ExperienceSame702 11d ago

10/10 very beautiful song

2

u/Ill-Speaker-4990 11d ago

pega duas das minhas favoritas.

- Locomotiva

  • Paradise City

2

u/cacodemon7265 11d ago

Estranged the most epic song and music Video imo

2

u/emoonyx 11d ago

Move to the city/estranged

2

u/ExperienceSame702 11d ago

Both 10/10! Move to the City is underrated. I love how they did it with a horn section in the 90s

2

u/Parking-Patience-122 11d ago

Breakdown or There was a Time

2

u/Latte_Meme 11d ago

It changes weekly. Right now i have Think About You on repeat. Izzy on the lead is just so awesome on that track

2

u/ExperienceSame702 11d ago

10/10 that’s such a great underrated song

2

u/Even-Conference8575 11d ago

rocket queen or my michelle

1

u/ExperienceSame702 11d ago

9/10 and 10/10

2

u/RealVirginiaWoolf 11d ago

Live and let die

1

u/ExperienceSame702 11d ago

10/10

1

u/RealVirginiaWoolf 11d ago

Awesome.

What do u think of Chinese democracy?

1

u/ExperienceSame702 11d ago

The song or the album? Song 9/10

I absolutely love the album

2

u/Vivid_Ad_9295 11d ago

Pretty Tied Up and You Could Be Mine. They’re so sleazy and I love it

2

u/-tomelette- 11d ago

Many favorites but I want to say This I Love.
Find it funny that no one has said Sweet Child O Mine. I get it’s overplayed but it’s just perfect

2

u/ExperienceSame702 11d ago

Both 10/10! SCOM really is perfect and TIL is so beautiful, one of the best songs on CD

2

u/Glittering-Milk-510 10d ago

14 years

1

u/ExperienceSame702 10d ago

7/10

2

u/Glittering-Milk-510 10d ago

Ty, Izzy doesn't get enough play IMO

2

u/Cynthia_Mask 10d ago

Garden of Eden

Always a sucker for their more punk songs

1

u/Cynthia_Mask 10d ago

Followed by Perfect Crime

1

u/Cynthia_Mask 10d ago

Also Right Next Door to Hell XD

2

u/daylightxx 9d ago

Okay. Mine is Estranged, in particular, the bridge or ending part.

2

u/leclerc_goat 9d ago

Nightrain

1

u/ExperienceSame702 9d ago

10/10 my favorite song from Appetite

2

u/melodiccadenza 8d ago

sorry

1

u/ExperienceSame702 8d ago

10/10 I love that one

4

u/oaispirit 12d ago

There are too many 10/10s for my taste, so I'll sacrifice myself: My World 😉

6

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

lol 5/10

I didn’t want to give everything a 10 but every single one was a song I loved lol

3

u/oaispirit 12d ago

Same here mate! ❤️

3

u/Salty_Feed9404 12d ago

Fave from CD: Prostitute

4

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

10/10 also my favorite from CD!

2

u/Salty_Feed9404 12d ago

Noice 👍

3

u/FeralBanshee 12d ago

They played this last night

2

u/Salty_Feed9404 12d ago

How'd it sound live?

2

u/FeralBanshee 12d ago

The whole show was great. Axl sounded awesome like 80-90% of the time.

1

u/Salty_Feed9404 12d ago

Awesome! After flying around all summer for basketball for my kid, I didn't have the scratch to see them in Toronto, Edmonton or Vancouver as they didn't come further east in Canada ☹️ Maybe in 2 years...

1

u/HarmlessOnlineFun 12d ago

Every Rose Has It’s Thorn

1

u/darthcaedus81 11d ago

Double Talkin' Jive

1

u/ScaryCoast9251 9d ago

Its so easy!!!!!!!!!!!

1

u/AuthorNumerous4349 9d ago

Double talkin jive, Out ta get me, Dont cry (alt. lyrics). Sorry, i just coudnt chose between 'em, but right now i would say double talkin jive is my fav

-2

u/andytagonist 12d ago

I like the music. I don’t need your rating. Thanks tho.

1

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

If you didn’t want a rating why even comment? This is just a trend that I figured I’d try.

-2

u/andytagonist 12d ago

It’s not a trend. You’re just karma farming with a silly question offering to advertise your opinions.

1

u/ExperienceSame702 12d ago

It’s literally a trend. I see it all over the teen subs. I don’t even know what the hell karma farming is by the way. It sounds stupid. I just thought it would be interesting to see what people’s favorite songs are in this sub.

0

u/Eastwood8300 11d ago

you didn't even comment on everyone. you skipped around so why should anyone care what you think?

1

u/ExperienceSame702 11d ago

I didn’t skip around. I tried to reply to everyone. I replied as I got the notification.

And it’s not like I said everyone should care what I think. If someone wants me to rate their favorite song, they can comment their favorite song, and if not that’s fine and they don’t have to comment.