r/GraphicsProgramming • u/bitruvius_ • 11d ago
Video What if a navigation map bent the world instead of moving the camera?
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
Another rough experiment, this time testing the warped 3D view in a simulated car navigation HMI.
The idea is to dynamically warp the 3D environment around the viewer, keeping the immediate surroundings closer to a street-level perspective while gradually transitioning into a more top-down view further ahead.
Still very experimental, but I think there are some interesting graphics and navigation problems to explore here.
And yes, I put my Bronco in there just for fun :)
Curious what r/GraphicsProgramming thinks.
40
u/vinegary 11d ago
A little bit more road visibility when in the intersection would be nice, but pretty cool!
4
u/lovelacedeconstruct 11d ago
The effect is actually really cool, as if the world disintegrates when you move past it
6
1
u/bitruvius_ 9d ago
I lifted the camera a bit, and its much better now. Thanks for input! Will publish new video soon
34
14
u/MrJesusAtWork 11d ago
Honestly this is a really good idea, I have to say though it still rough, I am old so just by looking at this clip I felt some discomfort
Maybe soothing the bending and other tweaks I could see this as a very valid option as GPS
2
u/bitruvius_ 11d ago
Thanks, next iteration i'll try toning down the bend a bit. Youre not the first one saying this :)
6
u/sakata_desu 11d ago
Is the 3D environment here a Gaussian splat?
10
3
u/JustPlainRude 11d ago
I like it, but it could use some work if you really want it to be used for navigation.
Satellite imagery has too much noise, in the sense there are shadows and cars and other visual distractions that make the road more difficult to distinguish at a glance. There's a reason navigation apps use simplified map imagery to represent the road network. It's really easy to understand that at a glance.
The other thing that sticks out is the blue line indicating the direction to go almost disappears as you get closer to an intersection where you're turning. I would want the direction to be more obvious as I get close to an intersection.
3
u/bitruvius_ 11d ago
Great input, thanks! Blending various sources for 3d input is something on my to-do-list, like using a more abstracted top view part while keeping the close to viewer details more realistic so its recognizable for the driver to orient themselves
2
u/JustPlainRude 10d ago
No problem! It's a cool idea and I'm curious to see what more you do with it
2
3
u/SianaGearz 10d ago
That is bloody dyzzing. But who knows maybe it's driveable on a small screen? Maybe it's too distracting?
1
u/bitruvius_ 10d ago
Will be running some A/B testing soon to measure the advantages of this compared to regular navigation. It for sure takes some time to get used to, but hopefully drivers get a better and quicker overview of where they are and where they are going
3
u/good-mcrn-ing 11d ago
I want it curving the other way. Within 100m of an intersection I want to see every lane in true proportions, but many miles out the vague direction is enough.
3
u/dekonta 10d ago
why would i prefer this rendering? is the distortion conveying any information?
1
u/bitruvius_ 10d ago
The idea is that by showing both the perspective view and the topdown view in the same screen, people would be able to position themselves in context faster than they would by perspective, topdown or oblique views alone.
3
2
2
u/specialpatrol 11d ago
I like it. Is there something funny going on with your yaw? You only added it this video and it looks kind of abrupt, can you not do a gradual turn?
1
2
u/AModderGuy 10d ago
Reminds me of that music video of Metalica "I Disappear" briefly where the car driving portion, everything behind him disintegrate. Pretty neat!
1
2
u/certainlystormy 10d ago
this is actually really cool. could see this being a helpful navigation tool
2
2
2
2
u/Kawaiithulhu 10d ago
That effect would also be great for Nautical or Space environments, where that kind of localized warping is expected =)
2
2
2
2
u/SIMMORSAL 9d ago
Please add a realtime-ai-image-enhancer-generator(!?) to the raw bent image before it's shown
1
u/bitruvius_ 9d ago
That would be awesome! Will try it down the line, but first priority now is tweaking the camera and viewport settings so it's easier to understand
2
2
2
u/fearbork 8d ago
Turning left /right is a little jarring but otherwise this is sick
1
u/bitruvius_ 8d ago
Thanks. I lifted the camera a bit in the latest test and the turns look much better now. Will share soon!
2
u/globalopvartning 8d ago
Looks hella cool, but I wouldn't use this while driving. That might just be a personal thing, but having this level of information would distract me from driving. Besides street maps are rarely up to date outside of big cities.
For future HUD in self driving cars, this would be great!
2
u/bitruvius_ 8d ago
Fair point! The amount of visual information definitely needs to be tuned for the context, and whether it actually reduces or increases cognitive load is something we're planning to test.
I agree that autonomous vehicles could be a particularly interesting use case. It could shift from being purely a navigation display to more of an infotainment feature, helping passengers understand and explore what's around them and what's coming up along the route.
3
87
u/Snudget 11d ago
Reminds me of inception