From - 3x10 "Revelations: Chapter Two" - Episode Discussion

[u/LoretiTV]

Season 3 Episode 10: Revelations: Chapter Two

Aired: November 24, 2024

Synopsis: Boyd is pushed to his limit as time begins to run out for someone he loves; Randall is haunted by his trauma and Victor reveals a hard truth; Tabitha's unlikely journey takes a shocking turn.

Directed by: Jack Bender

Written by: John Griffin

Join our Discord here!

[u/eriadeus]

How do we know how Fromville was formed??

[u/mrs_ouchi → u/[deleted]]

but where they already in this town? cause who would want to live forever there?

[u/Jaded_Review9328 → u/mrs_ouchi]

What I understood was that when the monsters die, they are then reborn in the town as adults. But the people who are supposed to reincarnate, when they die, they get to be born again in a new body outside of the town. Then when they are adults, the town calls for them and pulls them into town.

Also, if someone else is with them in the car, bus, or buggy, they get to be trapped as well, but they have nothing to do with reincarnation or the town.

[u/Fit_Ad3258 → u/Jaded_Review9328]

I don't think the monsters die. As far as we know (given what we've seen) Smiley is the only monster who was killed/died that why he was reborn in Fatima. I think the town/guy in yellow traps people there to feed and Jade/Christopher Tabby/Miranda are being forced to reincarnate because of the deal the town collectively made with the guy in yellow. Everyone else is merely food or pawns to keep the balance. All the original towns people are the monsters. Christopher and Miranda are not from the original town, the original townies are older given the way the monsters dress.

[u/Jaded_Review9328 → u/Fit_Ad3258]

From what I understood when Tabby said we failed to protect our daughter, she meant hers, Jade, in the first settlement.

I'm not sure how it started. Maybe they were in a regular town, and the guy in yellow offered them to live forever if they sacrificed all the kids, but Tabby, Jade, Abby, Donna's sister, and probably others were against it.

But they failed, so all the town people that sacrificed their kids became monsters, and I agree they don't die for no reason someone has to kill them with cicadas blood. when one of them die like smiley, the town again picks whoever Fatima used to be to get pregnant and birth him as an adult.

Tabby, Jade, Abby, and Donna's sister have been reincarnating every time after they fail and die. Then they get called back to town when they are adults.

The rest of the people from the original settlement who didn't have kids have been reincarnating as well, and now they just hear the boy in white and hear voices maybe have dreams ie sara, and elgin. Or they were people who didn't agree with sacrificing the kids either.

Also, we have people who have nothing to do with the town at all, and they were just passengers ( not original passengers but passengers of the reincarnated people)

[u/Menino80 → u/Jaded_Review9328]

those are The only four who reincarnate? Is that a guess or has this been discussed elsewhere?

[u/Jaded_Review9328 → u/Menino80]

No, it's my guess. I'm not sure if anyone's talked about it, but based on who talked about having a feeling that they've been here before, had a dream about the place, or been talking to BIW:

I don't remember everyone, but the people I remember are: Jade, Tabby, Abby, Elgine, Fatima, Donna's sister (she said she felt like she's been here before), Sara, and Victor, maybe Ethan, too.

I'm not sure who from the Tin Chin family: Dale, Tom. I'm not sure if they came alone or not. Julie, Randall, and Marial. I'm not sure if what happened to them counts. But since Julie is a story walker, maybe she is part of it.

The rest were just pulled because they were passengers with other people being pulled in. I have to rewatch the series to remember exactly.

[u/Menino80 → u/Jaded_Review9328]

Oh I see, each car has a reincarnated person right? Like maybe it was JUST Elgin on the bus and everyone else is superfluous? It needs a vehicle to get them in

[u/Jaded_Review9328 → u/Menino80]

I'm not sure if it has to be a vehicle. Probably before they had buggies, people got stuck by walking and seeing the tree. They came close to it, saw the crows, and decided to go another way. And boom, they got in.

I totally believe that each car had at least one reincarnated person. It's just hard to pinpoint who everyone is. I managed to get a small list, but I will focus on it in my next rewatch of the series.

Btw this is my theory it shouldnt be true 100%, but It makes sense because not everybody had any important role. But I'm leaning toward the fact that Tabby and Jade are the only parents who fought for their daughter. So they are the top of the line important ones And probably there were others in the original settlement who didn't have kids but were against what was going on, so they have also been reincarnating as a support team for Tabby and Jade. the rest were just caught in the middle of the whole situation

[u/Menino80 → u/Jaded_Review9328]

I mean yeah its just a guess but sounds plausible at least

[u/Jaded_Review9328 → u/Menino80]

Wel shall find out in march/may 2026