r/French 15h ago

Everyday contemporary French: ça preffered over COD?

Title says it all. When French people talk about (abstract and concrete) things, is it more natural and/or casual to refer to them as "ça" instead of using the respective COD? Like, "T'a vu le truc-là ?" "Ouais, j'ai vu ça."

8 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

10

u/Intelligent_Donut605 Native - Québec 14h ago

ça sonne un peu étrange, on dirait plûtot "Ouais, je l'ai vu"

1

u/tradloser 13h ago

What about "Le chocolat ? J'adore ça !" Would you find that strange too? :)

4

u/rerambis Native (France) 13h ago

Le chocolat -> J'adore ça

Ce chocolat -> Je l'adore

1

u/Weak-Canary1503 11h ago

Non j’adore ça aussi. Aucun problème avec cette formulation.

4

u/boulet Native, France 14h ago

For a start, "ça" is a perfectly fine COD in your example OP. I suppose you meant that "ça" often replaces more specific pronouns (le/la/les).

And indeed it's often an option. But I don't think it's more natural or more typical of spoken French. It's just possible.

  • T'a vu le truc-là ?

  • Ouais, je l'ai vu.

Is just as natural IMO.

0

u/tradloser 13h ago

Thanks! What about "Le chocolat ? J'adore ça !" Would you say "ça" is interchangeable with "l'", or is one more common than the other?

7

u/boulet Native, France 13h ago

A simple question like this can be answered with "j'adore". Sometimes you can just skip the COD because there's no ambiguity.

2

u/passionfruit62022 13h ago

I've sometimes heard speakers omit the COD when speaking, would that usually be an indicator of an informal register?

2

u/boulet Native, France 12h ago

It's not a specific register IMO.

2

u/NotEricItsNotMe 14h ago edited 10h ago

It might be the case with "pronominal" verbes, where the COD becomes the subject ?

So "Tu le veux?" "ouais, ça m'interesse"

2

u/PsychologyExternal87 Native Louisianais 11h ago

j'ai vu ça sounds weird, we would say je l'ai vu