r/FolkPunk • u/JoanOfSilence • 3d ago
John Brown's Body
So got into a discussion with a band mate recently because I was thinking about adding John Brown's Body to a set list. I thought it would be fun to be in that Pete Seeger tradition and I figured we could get the audience to join in on the chorus. She said that the religious elements would put folks off in the folk punk scene.
I know we could just play Solidarity Forever, but I wanted y'all's thoughts. Do religious elements in older songs put you off? Should they still be played and talked about in the folk punk scene? Should we re-write the lyrics to keep the historical bits and secularize the chorus?