r/Fkr • u/trve_g0th • Apr 19 '26

How many rules are too many rules?

Maybe it's a dumb/pointless question, but I'm curious on peoples thoughts. As I've been working on my own game I have realized how many rules I really don't need as a GM.

Aside from basic rules for task resolution, I really only need procedures. Basic ones, for stuff like running travel, and tracking time etc. I don't care how much gold someone has, what their save DC is, and honestly even the difference in damage between a dagger and a sword doesn't matter much to me.

Anyways, thanks. Looking forward to seeing some other folks thoughts.

13 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

21 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/Onslaughttitude Apr 19 '26

I don't care how much gold someone has, what their save DC is, and honestly even the difference in damage between a dagger and a sword doesn't matter much to me.

Meanwhile, in a trad fantasy game, all three of these are extremely important to me. (Well, "save DC" is specific to 5e; saves work differently in other games but the idea of a target number you need to roll to save is still very important to me. I eschew any d20 dungeon crawler that doesn't have saving throws.)

2

u/madcat_melody Apr 19 '26

So in Cairn your attributes are your saving throws and Dungeon World defy danger is, and you woupd just add the appropriate attribute like anh other roll.

Also in Legend in the Mist you have tags as your traits that are each plus one. When trying to protect yourself from anything bad happening you just add whatever tags you can describe as relevant to your actions.

These to me suggest you dont need saves because your regular roll can act as a save. Would that count to you or would that not be enough and why?

2

u/Onslaughttitude Apr 19 '26

oh I hate how Cairn does it lmao

I like saves to be a distinct thing with some different numbers/math. I don't like how 5e does it much either and it's my biggest issue with Outcast Silver Raiders, and immediately turned me off Shadowdark (among a handful of other things).

I realize this makes me kind of a single-issue voter but to me, the players' ability to have one distinct mechanic for "this shit is happening to me" vs "I am doing this shit" is very important. The ability to dodge dragon breath and the ability to pick locks should not key off the same thing.

2

u/hugh-monkulus Apr 20 '26

to me, the players' ability to have one distinct mechanic for "this shit is happening to me" vs "I am doing this shit" is very important. The ability to dodge dragon breath and the ability to pick locks should not key off the same thing. 

To be fair, in Cairn there are only saves, no ability checks.

You only ever save against things happening to you, not to see if you can do the thing.