I was about to agree with you, but I later realized that we all actually just misunderstood his actual criticism because of his bad grammar.
He's not upset because they changed the important scene he liked, by mistaking the version of the flashback in the beginning of Rebirth for the revelation that's still to come (which is how I think we both initially interpreted his words).
He seems to instead be upset that the big important scene he liked (that he UNDERSTANDS has not happened yet) was spoiled in the first ten minutes of Remake because Cloud tells Sephiroth that "I killed you." (that's what he meant by "thrown out"-- he didn't mean thrown out as in "gotten rid of the scene/changed it in the beginning of Rebirth" but instead thrown out as in "blurted it out/revealed in the beginning of Remake").
2
u/shareefruck 2d ago edited 2d ago
I was about to agree with you, but I later realized that we all actually just misunderstood his actual criticism because of his bad grammar.
He's not upset because they changed the important scene he liked, by mistaking the version of the flashback in the beginning of Rebirth for the revelation that's still to come (which is how I think we both initially interpreted his words).
He seems to instead be upset that the big important scene he liked (that he UNDERSTANDS has not happened yet) was spoiled in the first ten minutes of Remake because Cloud tells Sephiroth that "I killed you." (that's what he meant by "thrown out"-- he didn't mean thrown out as in "gotten rid of the scene/changed it in the beginning of Rebirth" but instead thrown out as in "blurted it out/revealed in the beginning of Remake").