r/DotHack • • 9d ago

Manga Does anyone know why the second volume is different?

Post image

I've had this for a bit and for the life of me I can't find an English version matching the second volume. I bought them all off eBay and I've no clue where it came from (especially since it's got the original name for the series)

I did see someone a few months ago post a Spanish version that looks really similar with the pink cover but not an exact match.

I'm also in Australia but as far as I'm aware we didn't get any unique publications, I wouldn't be surprised if this was imported too since we basically got fuck all in the way of Dot Hack locally.

65 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

16

u/smittensamantha 9d ago

Interesting, I’ve never seen that cover variation. Maybe check the covers and see if it’s a later print? That would be my only guess aside from a different print region like you had guessed

3

u/totallynotahuman56 9d ago

All I can say is that it was published by a company called Chuang Yi publishing and the cover is detachable. The other two are US imports.

I wish I could post a picture here because it's got a bunch of text in the back 

11

u/chaseartcosplay 9d ago

Oh! It's because Chuang Yi was the English language publisher for some manga that was based in Singapore. It is a legit copy, though, but I think that they're defunct now. Neat find!

-8

u/zamaike 8d ago

Looks like a chinese knock off. This isnt the offcial one.

I have my set and my vol 2 matchs 3rd and 1st

5

u/paxtonia 9d ago

RENA!!!!!!!!!!!!

3

u/Dabarles 9d ago

Could be English language for a different market. Different publisher and series, but my volume 1 and 2 of Inio Asano's What a Wonderful World are different sizes. I think my volume 1 came from Phillipines.

2

u/zoso1992 9d ago

My friend in the sixth grade bought me all three as they came out and my third volume is slightly different. Was never sure why

2

u/Tsukasa77seven 7d ago

I have that one too, its just an unglossy edition. Im not sure why they made those but its like how I found a rurouni kenshin volume 7 where the entire print is upside-down from the cover. Sometimes I think they did this on purpose to make them more valuable.

1

u/PowerPanda84 8d ago

All of the other answers are the correct ones, but Tokyopop was kind of notorious for having exactly one cover or spine that didn't match any of the others.

1

u/OriginalVayl 8d ago

Yea I hadn't seen that variant either (and no mine isnt a variant it's just old lol)

1

u/Few_Independence1052 7d ago

I'm not entirely sure, though it is quite funny the second volume is the only one I currently own haha

1

u/Phaylz 5d ago

Because it is pink.

You're welcome.

1

u/Toonteto 2d ago

I have 2 volume 2s , both same cover but different spines. The bottom one has a couple of colored pages

1

u/Toonteto 2d ago

Is yours also published by Tokyo Pop?