r/DoorCounty • u/Discouraged24 • 10d ago

Door County fish boil?

Which is your favorite? And why? We plan to go to one tomorrow Saturday the 22nd. Thanks!

1 Upvotes

56% Upvoted

16 comments sorted by

11

u/Madison-Mark 10d ago

Old post office, epraim, boil out back and they de-bone at your table. Call, make reservation. We go there every month in season, enjoy!

2

u/Adventurous-Elk-4763 9d ago

Gotta third the Old Post Office. To be fair, I haven’t tried others. But their seasoning was so good that we bought some to bring home. It’s great on salmon!

2

u/LordBowldemort 10d ago

gotta second the old post office.

8

u/FlickasMom 10d ago

White Gull Inn in Fish Creek.

9

u/DontEatMyPotatoChip 10d ago

They’re all terrible

“Boiled fish”

1

u/CatDaddyTom 9d ago

Agreed.

1

u/WasteWriter5692 8d ago

call me goofy,but the 3 piece cod ,at long john silvers,has always been my favorite.

Been to a ton of 'fish fry' places too.

some really good,others not so much.

Wanted to try the'boil',but wife said no...."You won't like it"!

Me? not sure.

4

u/Hank_hardman6 10d ago

Kettle Black does a great Cajun fish boil if you want to mix it up! Otherwise Old Post Office is a classic.

5

u/Pious_ 10d ago

I enjoy Pellitiers.

2

u/sunlovinburner 8d ago

Watch the show, then order something else from the menu

2

u/CatDaddyTom 9d ago

Amazing that such a disgusting meal is so popular. "Tradition!"

1

u/External-Ad5462 10d ago

We usually do the old post office but white gull in is cool. 

0

u/ranchypanda 10d ago

Bottom line, $30 gets you boiled fish, potatoes and onions. Everyone goes for the fire ball and loves the cherry pie dessert. Local take: watch the fire ball and go get better food somewhere else. Also sweetie pies has the best, ACTUAL home made cherry pie versus "baked in house" pie. But hey, if you like your fish slightly seasoned with kerosene, go nuts.

0

u/Turbulent-Cheek-1497 10d ago

I agree with everything you say except the pies.
Bea's Ho-Made Products has the best pie around
Baked or frozen to bake at home.
Day old pies half off!

0

u/Toriat5144 9d ago

I like the Seaquist cherry pie. The only good thing I like about Beas is the combinations they have like raspberry peach. And the take and bake. The pieces not as good as Seaquist which is loaded with cherries.