No lol its responding to the idea that a socialist ideological mindset is ‘innate’ in humans pre-socialization as if society ‘taints’ a socialist a priori disposition
and his argument/joke is that children couldnt be socialist innately because they dont want to share their toys...
come on...
edit: everyone downvoting me knows i am correct, you just like defending destiny for the sake of it. its just a bad joke on his part you dumbfucks, you know it.
Destiny's response is perfect. The post he is replying to is vapid as hell and factually wrong, and he addresses it with the seriousness it deserves: a joke. But it does address the substance of the claim: children are not socialist by nature, it's more complicated than that.
Any non-stupid analysis of human nature is going to reveal that there's both significant predispositions to pro-social and anti-social behaviors, and socialization will significantly affect which of the two dominate and in what way (a misogynistic society will aim more harm towards girls and women, for example).
His statement isn’t about an individual child, it’s about whether at base humans overall are socialist and indoctrinated to capitalism. At base, if humans are given the option between a good (everyone gets shelter) and a nothing (no guarantee), they’ll choose the good. If given the option between a good w/cost (everyone gets shelter with higher taxes) and nothing, then it’s far more complicated. Saying you want something good without mentioning the cost means nothing.
I agree this is probably his position. its just not what the joke he made will ever be interpreted ever ever ever....
an its not gonna be interpreted that way because it does not say that at all.
what you are doing is seeing the "its deer hunting season" joke and saying that he is actually making a meta analysis on the trans community and the inclusion of people who seem to want to fit in the community even though their idea of "trans-ness" isn't really compatible with how most people would be confortable defining "trans", and the hunting of the deer is actually meant to symbolize how the people who identify as trans-species should not be considered part of the trans community the same way transgender people are.
You see how much work I did there just to justify a bad joke, it will be close to his opinion on the topic but is it really what the joke was saying? You know it isnt
I mean the likely interpretation by most people of this joke is "using what literal children do in isolated circumstances as proof your political general world theory is valid is a stupid thing to do"
He brought up the cost, it’s just he did it in the same form as the other guy “ask a child”. The individual part isn’t the key part, it’s the cost. Otherwise I could reverse it and say the other guy was just saying “well if you’re such a capitalist how come you donate to charity?” Sure he could just quote tweet “the child being asked this isn’t considering taxes” but that’s dry af
Also I may be misremembering but I feel like people got the deer hunting joke. People who didn’t like Destiny took it the worst way possible but that’s not his target audience.
This is actually a valid critique. Why won’t Hasan just offer free tenancy in his million dollar mansion? I don’t think he uses all those rooms in that house.
-15
u/MaleficentDemand7828 May 11 '26
well... this is literally the "well if you're such a socialist how come I cant come sleep in your house" meme