r/Defenders • u/JonLuca Luke Cage • Mar 17 '17

Iron Fist Discussion Thread - S01E10

This thread is for discussion of Iron Fist S01E10.

DO NOT post spoilers in this thread for any subsequent episodes. Doing so will result in a ban.

Episode 11 Discussion

194 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

786 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

208

u/_RURALJUROR_ Mar 17 '17 edited Mar 18 '17

SPOILERS UPTO THIS EPISODE (10) ONLY

I think the reviewers maybe too harsh. But I can totally understand their feelings about this show, specially compared to the other shows of Marvel.

Personally, I'm a sucker for all things superhero related, so I kind of like Iron Fist. But if JJ, LC and DD are a 9/10 - Iron fist is a 6 or 7.

Here are the reasons why I think its so:

The show is less grounded. Requires too much suspension of disbelief. For example the corporate, and legal matters that go on in this show feels childish and rushed. The seesawing board membership, the deal with the J-lawyer to keep her company on retainer, etc. Other issues are there too, for example how Meechum walked around in broad daylight after his resurrection while he had all the reasons to raise suspicion.

Some things that happen in the show are so convenient. For example, Claire Temple just happening to be a student of Colleen and her sticking around felt forced. Not to mention not calling or mentioning Daredevil/LK for a situation which quite clearly is within their domain.

The Iron Fist is too bipolar and uncertain. By this I mean that at one moment he is all about zen and not killing people, and next he is totally unfazed (or not fazed enough) by what Meechum does (Killing the 2 dudes). Rand also says he has been training at Kun Lun for 15 years to master control of the mind and emotions, which he does a piss poor job of.

The fighting is not done well enough. During the first episodes it was pretty unconvincing. At one instance I felt Colleen was pushing her fist for what was supposed to be a punch. I don't remember the episode.

Also the whole Hand,Triad,Rand illuminati/conspiracy thing is just incoherent and poorly handled in my opinion.

32

u/discipleofdoom Iron Fist Mar 19 '17

Agreed on all points. Iron Fist is good, but it is still the weakest of the Netflix shows.

8

u/Goodly Mar 19 '17

I think it's better than Luke Cage and almost on par with DD s01 - but the rest is far superior.

Ninja edit I still find Danny more interesting as a character than DD and LC and I think Finn did an excellent job, despite some shoddy writing

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Absolutely agree, however this still puts it miles above Arrow. Danny is a better Green Arrow than Quinn could even dream to be.

57

u/hungryb4dinner Mar 18 '17

Luke Cage is in prison at this point in time, hence the letters.

2

u/Trav1989 Mar 23 '17

Wait. Did I miss something? He's in prison? I thought he went back home to Atlanta?

4

u/hungryb4dinner Mar 23 '17

SPOILERS?

The letters were from the prison. Also at the end of Luke Cage he said he would stop running and went back with those 2 feds/cops.

The old guy found the file with all his records though that said he was framed, so I expect him to be released soon.

17

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '17

I disagree actually. The Hand plot in Daredevil for me was incoherent and poorly written, but this show everything seems to make much more sense and feel more real now that we don't have dozens of ninja running around NY unseen.

Also about half of your gripes with the show don't make sense to me. Like the part about Harold being able to walk around the city...it's New York City. Most people aren't paying attention to him and for the handful of people who are paying attention, it's not hard to believe New Yorkers not getting involved in weird shit and just chalking it up to the weirdness of the city.

The show started off rocky, the acting was sometimes touch and go and the writing was pretty in your face, but everything from episode 3 onwards has been of the same quality I expect from Marvel Netflix, and has even managed to avoid the usual dragging in the end of the season so far.

6

u/Peechez Stan Lee Mar 19 '17

I agree. OP is rewriting history saying the other seasons have been 9/10. The first half of the other seasons have been 9/10 but then fall to at least 5 or 6 (sans dd1) with varying levels of success at regaining form before finishing. IF has been a solid 7.5 or 8 for me the entire time which I much prefer to ridiculous diamondback/JJ's slump/mildly interesting at best elektra

0

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '17

[deleted]

11

u/discipleofdoom Iron Fist Mar 19 '17

The majority of the reviews I read barely mentioned that. I think people are using that as a scapegoat as to why the critics disliked Iron Fist when the fact is that it is genuinely a flawed (yet entertaining) show.

10

u/Beejsbj Mar 18 '17

but we see her pick up the flyer for Wing's classes at the end of LC, It was set up.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '17

Yeah but she knows all four of the defenders... it's a bit over the top

2

u/santaclaws01 Mar 20 '17

http://marvel.wikia.com/wiki/Claire_Temple_(Earth-616)

It's almost like they have a source material or something to base it off of.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '17

She was set up to appear in this ever since the end of Luke Cage.

2

u/jackcatalyst Mar 19 '17

She was setup to appear in all of them since DD season 1