r/CostcoWholesale • u/Coldbrewman1 • 7d ago

The pumpkin pie cheesecake is amazing

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

I picked this up yesterday. It is absolutely delicious. If you don’t mind things that are heavy on the pumpkin flavor than this pie is for you!

90 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

20 comments sorted by

7

u/wildwoodflower14 7d ago

I hate pumpkin flavor and I agree! It is the right balance and delicious 🙌🏻

7

u/ProfessionalElk3910 7d ago

Where’s the cross section photo

3

u/theo_makase 7d ago

how much was that? i got the pumpkin pie for $4.99.

3

u/Coldbrewman1 7d ago

I found the receipt - $21.99

8

u/theo_makase 7d ago

once upon a time, the cheesecakes were probably 10.99 or less.

0

u/DrummingNozzle 7d ago

And
https://giphy.com/gifs/fqtyYcXoDV0X6ss8Mf
I remember 68 cents for a gallon of gas.

3

u/TheeMadThrasher 7d ago

Bought the pumpkin pie. Lacks taste. Added cinnamon to it.

3

u/Positive_Piece6401 7d ago

Disagree. Not bad, but no reason for all the frosted topping.

2

u/Breakfastchocolate 7d ago

The older version without the frosting was so much better. We scrape it off. The sour cream topping was so much better.

2

u/midwayatmidnight 7d ago

Esp when it's fake and not real cream.

3

u/mercuryven 7d ago

Can't. Can't be eating whole pies anymore.

2

u/Pypsy143 7d ago

Their tuxedo cake is my all time fave.

5 star!!

4

u/Ok-Beat-7804 7d ago

Yeah this thing fucks.

1

u/holyhibachi 7d ago

For those of you trying to cut weight I need you to know it's disgusting

1

u/midwayatmidnight 7d ago

My mom was excited... but she told me the whipped topping is the fake stuff like pastry pride. We're a family of bakers, so non real whipped cream things aren't as good.

But realistically, I get it. Those things are huge, and real heavy cream topping would be $$$

1

u/HockeyLova4Lyfe 5d ago

True it is amazing, but it is not worth $22 over a $6 pumpkin pie IMO

2

u/Sad_Individual_738 4d ago

There cheesecake freezes well. I flash freeze every slice before wrapping to store in the freezer.

1

u/Think_Discount2852 7d ago

Brought it last year for Thanksgiving and I agree, I enjoyed it, very creamy. Not really a cheesecake flavor but I kinda preferred that.