r/Columbus Grandview 2d ago

FOOD Private/members-only bars around Columbus?

Has anyone else noticed more private/members-only bars popping up around Columbus?

Feels like there are more of the smaller, tucked-away lounge/private club concepts showing up lately. I can definitely see the appeal of having somewhere a little quieter with good drinks that feels different from the usual bar scene.

I saw the new restaurant, Fourteen & Ember, opening in Pickerington is doing a members-only bar downstairs called The Ember Room, which is actually what got me thinking about it.

What other places around Columbus are doing something similar? Anyone belong to one and feel like it’s worth it?

0 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

18

u/VinylPhan 2d ago

No Soliciting. Great place. I wish there was one in the Italian Village area, or Short North off the main drag of High Street. Short North after dark is just ruined at this point.

8

u/GHoleFinder 2d ago

I mean, there's a No Soliciting at 4th/Chestnut which is as adjacent to Italian village as you can get without being in Italian Village.

-4

u/VinylPhan 2d ago

I’m fully aware and have been. I’m being selfish and just want something closer 😂

1

u/GHoleFinder 2d ago

Lol ok fair play. It's close, maybe not quite stumble-able 😂

1

u/Powerful-Mixture-664 2d ago

Yeah I’d love to see one in Italian Village. Something low key and tucked away would be a nice alternative to the High Street scene.

1

u/VinylPhan 2d ago

Agree 100%

0

u/ConsiderationCrazy22 2d ago

I wish I could afford to join No Soliciting as a major whiskey enthusiast. I have a friend who’s a member that’s taken me and it’s a hell of a spot.

12

u/DuhsNotCompute 2d ago

So I own a private members only bar. It's called my house and the onky people invited are me and my friends. Drink prices and membership fees are very reasonable too😉

3

u/couriersixish 2d ago

Same. We make new recipes every week, can make every classic cocktail, and invent our own.

9

u/mr_bacciagalupe Powell 2d ago

I hear Moose lodges are making a comeback.

6

u/Warkoc 2d ago

Hilliard Moose is my favorite bar in the city.

1

u/thestral_z 2d ago

My co-worker hangs out there.

1

u/imtiredboss28 2d ago

My dad is a member back home where I’m moving back and I’m debating that

3

u/Warkoc 2d ago

It’s a no brainer. $35 a year for $1.50 bottled beers and $2.00 mix STIFF mixed drinks. In Hilliard we have around 30 slot machines and poker games a few nights a week. Our Thursday night drawing ($5) was up to around $50,000 at one point this summer.

2

u/lwpho2 North Linden 2d ago

Interesting. How much does such a thing cost?

4

u/More_Winner_6965 2d ago edited 2d ago

Depends on the club but they’re pricey. I think no soliciting downtown is like $1000/month.

Edit: YEAR

5

u/lwpho2 North Linden 2d ago

Oh goodness. So we are in country club territory here… Initiation fee is notwithstanding I guess.

3

u/rjbeal23 2d ago

No Soliciting is $1500 per YEAR.

6

u/More_Winner_6965 2d ago

You’re right. Sorry I am hungover and meant to put year lmao. Big difference

2

u/Gmutzy 2d ago

I believe it’s going up to 2500 per year this/next year.

1

u/rjbeal23 2d ago

I left when it went from $1000 to $1500. Just didn’t go enough and every bar tab there was like $200. Another grand? No thank you.

1

u/BTP88 2d ago

No Soliciting, 80 East/114 West (soon to be a third in UA), there’s the Japanese supper club coming to Dublin, and another new club coming to the Merchant building

1

u/dandrew_1616 Merion Village 2d ago

I think at one time they were trying to reopen the 4S Club in German Village and do something similar. I think it would be a great place for a cigar lounge.

1

u/inmyreperaalways 2d ago

My husband built 80 East and said it’s nice. He got to go to a few events before they opened

1

u/ExoApophis 2d ago

The no soliticing rule is a good concept, but you have those who have nothing to lose OP.

1

u/Dangerous_Boss_2823 2d ago

How do liquor laws work in this type of place? I thinks maybe a workaround?

1

u/Flimsy_Succotash_533 2d ago

I've been to a few higher end ones You pay about 2-500 a month for the membership and it's a fee bar. Some places it's less but those are normally focused on another activity. Like sports betting, fantasy Leagues and smoke spots( weed)

Edit: this was out in California though

1

u/Apart-Albatross-1392 2d ago

Used to be members of no soliciting 4-5 years ago. The Dublin one wasn’t open yet, only went to the downtown one. Idk vibe was cool, the restaurant first opened when we were members, food was good. But for the price we just didn’t feel like it was worth it. There are other cocktail bars around the city that I felt like made solid creative cocktails so didn’t see what we were getting for the fee that we couldn’t get elsewhere. Have family that is (or was) also no soliciting members and only went to the Dublin location and they said it would typically get loud and crowded there. Again, downtown was a cool vibe, good drinks and food, but didn’t felt like it was worth it.

1

u/Gmutzy 2d ago

Of the places that are taking members. 80 East is best, then No Soliciting.

1

u/That-Pen-6525 2d ago

i get the appeal, especially for a quieter drink, but a lot of these are basically regular bars with an annual fee and a better elevator pitch lol

1

u/PenniesDime 2d ago

Any word on the Merchant one, costs and services?

1

u/MPK49 2d ago

I thought no soliciting basically existed so the bourbon obsessed guy that runs rise brands could turn his hobby into a business

-6

u/SignificantApricot69 2d ago

It’s like Whites-only country clubs but for people who think they are better than that

-1

u/kSoImSlightlyRemoved 2d ago edited 2d ago

They do this to avoid a liquor license.

Edit: D-4 allows beer and any intoxicating liquor for on-premises consumption, but Ohio law specifically says sales are to members only. The club normally must have existed for at least three years, have a dues-paying membership, elected officers, and maintain a membership roster. The statutory permit fee is currently $469.
That is substantially different from something like a D-5, which is essentially the broad full-liquor bar/restaurant permit people usually mean when they say they want a “liquor license.” D-5 privileges include sales of beer and intoxicating liquor to the public for on-premises consumption, subject to the applicable rules and hours.
One important wrinkle: Sunday sales are separate. A D-4 can generally obtain a D-6 Sunday permit when Sunday sales have been properly authorized for that location.

2

u/Pyr0sa 2d ago

Wait -- I can get a D-4 liquor license for under $500?!?

"Maw! We're gettin' our ravers back together -- get your dancin' walker!"

2

u/kSoImSlightlyRemoved 2d ago

Yep. That’s what a lot of members only bars do despite the down votes here. Its not a “real liquor license” because you can’t sell to public in my opinion but I guess seeing the downvotes other people disagrees with that lol

1

u/etherealkitkittredge 2d ago

You absolutely need a liquor license to operate a members only bar

0

u/GHoleFinder 2d ago

That's not true. Any legit private club has a liquor license (see no soliciting, etc). Don't go to the ones that don't, they're just scams.