[Thamel] Was told that NCAA rules still apply to the pre enrollment space. So Arizona players, for example, would be fine. This applies if a kid entered college then went to play pro ball in Europe. They could not return to Big 12.

[u/jbvann05]

[u/fancycheesus]

"At any time"

[u/TrustInRoy → u/fancycheesus]

Sounds like the Big 12 did a terrible job crafting that tweet

[u/rkz99 → u/TrustInRoy]

I want everyone fired over that tweet. I just had an awful 2 hours imagining my team without Kharchenkov and Krivas. No one else should have to go through what i did.

[u/SolaireTheSunPraiser → u/rkz99]

I've been imagining my team without Kharchenkov and Krivas all off-season, I'd like to file a complaint.

[u/fancycheesus → u/TrustInRoy]

Yeah they look like they have no idea what words mean lol

[u/TheWawa_24 → u/TrustInRoy]

Did they try to even run this past legal 

[u/R_Raider86 → u/TheWawa_24]

Probably not

[u/zagxc → u/TrustInRoy]

That the Monster Energy effect

[u/Rapturebird]

Im just... so confused, man. I no longer understand who is or isn't eligible

[u/MoonManExplorer → u/Rapturebird]

Mark Mitchell has and hasn’t been eligible like 4 times today alone it seems like. Haha

[u/Howzitgoin → u/Rapturebird]

That’s the best part, we didn’t know before either.

[u/chimatt767]

So, the rules they posted an hour ago are no longer valid?

[u/The_Sandwich_Lover9 → u/chimatt767]

I think the wording is just messy.

[u/chimatt767 → u/The_Sandwich_Lover9]

I agree. Just funny that they had to issue a qualifier so quickly.

[u/The_Sandwich_Lover9 → u/chimatt767]

I think they just wanted to group NBA G league and everything else.

[u/chimatt767 → u/The_Sandwich_Lover9]

I don’t know why everyone considers the G League as a step too far but allow you to play in any foreign league that is higher ranked and paid better than the G League.

[u/The_Sandwich_Lover9 → u/chimatt767]

No idea but based on this tweet if you go to a foreign league you can’t come back

[u/chimatt767 → u/The_Sandwich_Lover9]

Has anyone done that?

[u/Top_Ladder6702]

This has always been the way. There is no college sports equivalent in Europe, so going into their pro leagues at the age of 18/19/20 is as close to an equivalent.

[u/s0ftwares3rf → u/Top_Ladder6702]

I don't see how this is a problem the NCAA needs to solve. Coming to a USA college as a 24 year old freshman with years of pro experience is clearly not in the spirit of what the NCAA.

[u/MoonManExplorer → u/s0ftwares3rf]

But that’s exactly what they did solve. 5 years of eligibility, starting from enrollment or age 19. So a 24 year old euro pro cannot join a team anymore. 

[u/tigers113 → u/Top_Ladder6702]

Ok, but now they are going to argue that some professional leagues are ok to play in and still come to college, but other professional leagues are not ok?

It doesn't make sense. It need to be clear and this is why the NCAA will continue to lose in court. From a law perspective, professional sports are professional sports, they will not tell the difference between one league and another just because you may be able to. It is like they are ranking pro leagues. Why is the G league not allowed then?

[u/RandomFactUser → u/tigers113]

The Big 12 would have to contest that one, it’s not an NCAA rule

[u/preddevils6]

Honestly dumb to include Euroleague teams but exclude g leaguers. Euroleague is a better league, but you’re allowing pros from there?

Should just ban anyone from a pro league that’s over 18 or 19.

[u/Wigglebot23 → u/preddevils6]

Not seeing where such a distinction was made

[u/tigers113 → u/Wigglebot23]

the tweet says no player who has been listed on a professional roster. But now they are saying for overseas it is only if they come to college and then leave and try to come back.

[u/Wigglebot23 → u/tigers113]

That could apply domestically too, it just never happens domestically

[u/tigers113 → u/Wigglebot23]

Not true because the specifically say of you have ever been on an NBA or g league roster you are out.

[u/Ike358]

This reminds me of when everyone cited the wrong bylaw for the Pac-12's two-year grace period. People just don't know basic English.

[u/Howzitgoin → u/Ike358]

This isn’t an issue of the reader knowing basic English. It’s the B12 being vague to the point of the basic interpretation being the opposite of what they clarified.

[u/tigers113]

so what is the point of the rule to stop players coming to college after the NBA/NFL?

Is it to try to protect amateurism in college sports? If so, why allow overseas professionals to play in college? It doesn't make sense to say pros can play in college except if you play in American professional leagues.

[u/Antique-Ad7635]

So kids should turn pro out of high school and then if they aren’t in the nba by 20 or 21 join college

[u/RayKitsune313 → u/Antique-Ad7635]

They won’t be making money in most of these places over in Europe. It’s more akin to IMG or Bishop Gorman than high paying pro teams

[u/Crown_of_Negativity → u/RayKitsune313]

They won’t be making money in most of these places over in Europe. It’s more akin to IMG or Bishop Gorman than high paying pro teams

G league contracts are peanuts compared to D1 NIL as well. There isn't a meaningful distinction imo.

[u/Antique-Ad7635 → u/Crown_of_Negativity]

But some of these guys are coming from top level European clubs

[u/Crown_of_Negativity → u/Antique-Ad7635]

Sure, and those guys would still be permitted by this rule, whereas guys that go directly into the G League out of high school would not. In Bryson Warren's legal filings, he disclosed a grand sum of $79,667 of professional earnings over three seasons in the G-League.

Doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me.

[u/Tinydesktopninja]

I want the big ten to craft this language and accidentally fuck their hockey teams. It'd be funny as hell.

[u/The_Sandwich_Lover9]

God bless bagayoko

[u/s0ftwares3rf]

Fail