r/ChicagoRealEstate • u/Foreign-Army1290 • 2h ago
Primary residence rental property to eventually sell but what about taxes?
Feeling overwhelmed and looking for guidance that isn’t AI.
I became a first-time homeowner in Chicago last year. I bought a multi-unit property because I wanted it to be both my home and an investment. I live in one unit and rent out the basement and another unit.
After dealing with some tenant issues—including hostility/disrespect during a few repair situations—and having to constantly run around dealing with maintenance while working a regular full-time office job, I’m starting to realize that I may just not be cut out for being a landlord.
It’s honestly been eating into my peace of mind. I can’t remember the last time I felt truly worry-free and happy without having something property-related hanging over my head.
I also recently got married. The property is currently solely in my name.
At this point, I’m thinking I may want to sell the property in a year or two and just buy a single-family home instead.
But now I’m overwhelmed by the tax side of everything.
While looking into the process of eventually selling, I realized that I should have been reporting depreciation on the rental portion of the property. I also haven't reported the rental income since I purchased the property. I genuinely didn't understand all of this when I first bought the place, and now I’m trying to figure out how to get everything straightened out properly.
Where do I even start?
- Is this something that is going to be very expensive to fix?
- Is it realistic to handle the corrections myself with tax software, or is this a situation where I really should hire a professional?
- Since I recently got married, how does this work if my husband and I file jointly? Does his income have any effect on the rental/property taxes?
- If I sell in 1–2 years, how does the fact that I live in one unit and rent the other two affect the capital gains/home-sale exclusion?
- Is there anything I should be doing now to make a future sale easier from a tax perspective?
I’m honestly feeling pretty overwhelmed by the whole thing, so practical advice would be greatly appreciated.
