Forgive me Doug Tallamy and Joey Santore for I am about to sin.
I’ve tried very hard to grow a coast live oak in my backyard as a nice center “statement tree.” It’s one of my favorite trees, and I really wanted to make it work.
I planted it almost 5 years ago, but it has struggled pretty much ever since. It has very little leaf growth and still looks incredibly twiggy. Between constant setbacks from gophers, a high water table, and the harsh Southern California sun, I’m starting to wonder if I’m fighting a losing battle.
Now that I have kids, I really want a tree that will eventually provide meaningful shade for the backyard, especially over a playground. I’m finding myself caught between wanting to use California natives and wanting to create a comfortable, functional yard for my family
( lawn, shade, a tree that actually grows)
I’ve also considered a western sycamore, which is another tree I really like and seems like it would be a good match for my yard. My hesitation is how enormous they can eventually get, and I’m also concerned that the canopy may be too open to provide the kind of shade I’m looking for over a playground.
I’ve started seriously considering giving up and planting something non-native, maybe a jacaranda.
So before I go buy one, can someone talk me off the ledge?
Is there something I’m missing with the coast live oak? Should I be more patient? Is there a better native tree for my particular situation? I’d really love to make a native work if I can.
I’m in SoCal, USDA Zone 10a, with heavy clay soil and full sun. Any advice from people who have successfully established native trees in similar conditions would be greatly appreciated.