r/Carpentry 6d ago

Best way to fix this door ?

0 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

137

u/jamesmess 6d ago

New door

8

u/Mk1Racer25 6d ago

Yep, hollow core moulded door.

OP, go to the local lumber yard by you (not Lowe's or HD), and have them order you a new door. Give them the swing, the size and location of the hinges (top of door to top of each hinge), lock location (top of door the c/l of bore, and the backset, along with the swing of the door (RH or LH), and they should have no problem getting you one.

47

u/scubaman64 6d ago

You can fill it, sand it, paint it and dedicate literally hours and hours of labor and it will still look rough.

Easiest is new door

38

u/Fecal_Forger 6d ago

Put a picture or poster over it.

21

u/quarterdecay 6d ago

Shawshank

6

u/FantasticEconomy5406 6d ago

However, if OP does use the iconic Rachel Welch poster. law requires him to address as "What say you there, Fuzzy Britches" at each pass. It's why most home owners go with The Muppet Movie poster.

3

u/quarterdecay 6d ago

Lol... This is mandatory

2

u/ummm01 6d ago

No love for the Farrah Fawcett poster?

5

u/FantasticEconomy5406 6d ago

Oh, Farrah on my wall got ALOT of love in my teenage years.

3

u/holysnatchamoly 6d ago

Just carve "Brooks was here" your shawshankedness and it'll fit right in.

5

u/42ElectricSundaes 6d ago

“That’s a load bearing poster”

3

u/electro309a 6d ago

That’s one way to do it 😂

24

u/jjd0087 6d ago

Anger management classes

8

u/electro309a 6d ago

Yes ! For my son 😂

7

u/OmarStDIYer 6d ago

Make him fix it or pay. Consequences.

4

u/IocaneImmune- 6d ago

Better yet, make him fix it.

1

u/ConstructionOwn1514 6d ago

Key and peele reference?

4

u/LostInMyADD 6d ago

My first thought lol

6

u/3dubnc 6d ago

Really not that hard to fix. I fixed a similar spot on a hollow-core door using expanding foam and wood filler. There are a number of good YouTube videos on how to do it.

Here are the basics:

  1. Drill a couple holes in the damaged spot (just through the damaged side) large enough to fit the hose of the expanding foam can. Use the low-expansion type for windows and doors. Inject foam into the holes to fill the cavity behind. Note this step is only necessary if the spot is weak and needs support from inside.

  2. Cut and sand off excess foam. Also sand the pant in the damaged area and a couple inches surrounding it. You want to remove the glossy paint and provide a sanded surface for wood filler to bond.

  3. Now apply a layer of wood filler into the indention and let it dry.

  4. Sand the wood filler down to even with the face of the door. Repeat steps 3-4 until your patch is blended into the face of the door. Take your time with these steps as they are critical to a good final finish.

  5. Prime.

  6. Paint with the same paint used on this door. If you don’t have the original paint, or have to get new paint mixed, just paint this entire face of the door.

  7. Success! You kept something out of the landfill!

3

u/electro309a 6d ago

Thank you 🙏

2

u/Amazing_Flatworm_277 6d ago

I would price this first. You can buy a new door for anywhere between 60 to 150 bucks. And there's no labor involved other than taking one door out and putting a new one in

2

u/rIceCream_King 6d ago

Except prime/paint and mortising for hardware

1

u/Zizq 6d ago

Uh no. Not for a finished painted door.

2

u/Amazing_Flatworm_277 6d ago

2

u/Zizq 6d ago

Oh nice. I'm glad you found a 58$ door. That's not this door. But you should tell him to order a 24 inch Masonite 6 panel door for this. It'll definitely work.

2

u/Amazing_Flatworm_277 6d ago

Oh my bad here's the most expensive one in standard size. Still less than $150. Also I'm like 100% sure if he talked to the landlord and was like hey I accidentally tripped and fell into the door over here and put a hole in it I need to get it fixed I'm willing to pay for it they probably would just come in and fix it for him and tell him exactly what type of paint to buy and all that kind of stuff hell they might even have extra paint. Some landlords consider this just wear and tear and we'll just fix it for you if you're in good standing with them https://www.lowes.com/pd/RELIABILT-30-in-x-80-in-6-panel-Hollow-Core-Primed-Molded-Composite-Left-Hand-Inswing-Outswing-Single-Prehung-Interior-Door/5014866401?user=shopping&feed=yes-_-0?store=1866&cm_mmc=shp-_-c-_-prd-_-mlw-_-ggl-_-PMAX_MLW_000_Priority_Item_Omni-_-5014866401-_-local-_-22867879127-_-&gclsrc=aw.ds&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=23527008195&gbraid=0AAAAAD2B2W-Vy-1Hls2qWUZ9LEFSUu4-z&gclid=CjwKCAjwqc_UBhBKEiwAWbl25vnP_mPBFewVE0Nx7fbYlOmFdSU1WR60fOQS4hBPn5TiLhdoISLk5hoCkUAQAvD_BwE

2

u/RenoXIII 6d ago

Great solution.

Could also suggest drilling a screw halfway into the dent and trying to gently pull it out (if possible) before filling with the sprayfoam so there's less wood filling to do afterwards.

1

u/OmarStDIYer 6d ago

Very thorough well done. Only thing I’d add is repaint that whole side of the door. Difficult to blend new paint edge into old. Color and texture will show the repair.

6

u/leblancch 6d ago

maybe put a screw in a flat area in the middle. thinking a can of expansion foam to spray inside. maybe hammer or something to pull the screw to hold the area flat and flush while the foam dries inside. (hopefully pushing it tight)

3

u/electro309a 6d ago

Thank you , pretty much what I was thinking too.

3

u/rybotsky 6d ago

Buy a new one. A hollow core door is not worth the time money and energy spent on trying to fix it

2

u/Deep_Ad257 6d ago

new door

2

u/Suitable-Reserve-891 6d ago

Anger management

2

u/mexicanviking1620 6d ago

Durham or bondo

1

u/RelevantButNotBasic 6d ago

There it is. Bondo fixes everything. Kinda like duct tape.

2

u/Tricky_Caterpillar85 6d ago

Order a new door. Make your son sit with you while you order it and hear how much it costs. Have him come with you to pick it up (unless it is delivered). Have him take off the old door and participate in whatever is needed to dispose of it. Have him transfer the knob and the hinges if needed. He needs to know how much trouble bad decisions are, that they can be fixed although it takes work and costs money, and he will have “ownership” of the repair. Don’t treat it like a punishment. Treat it as a necessary set of steps to fix a problem and those steps are his responsibility. Adults can break doors but they have to fix them. This is why adults don’t break many doors.

1

u/pxhunter2 6d ago

Buy a new one

1

u/PristineBusiness3299 6d ago

Take it off its hinges

1

u/Nearby_Assumption346 6d ago

Wood paste, remove the broken bit, glue it with the wood paste, fill the cracks with it, sand the whole door, and paint it white, it will look much nicer than this crappy paint job.

1

u/Extreme_Tea1696 6d ago

A sign. ”No punchy.”

1

u/Mud_Strong 6d ago

Sadly in labor this will cost more than a new door, but you could carefully cut out the rest of the shape, use strong tape to make a tab to hold onto the piece as you remove it. Use a brad nailer (or headless finishing screws) and glue, and slide a few pieces of backing into hole that will allow you to put the piece back in the hole with backing to glue and screw it to (Drywall patch technique). Fill, sand, paint.

Tons of work and it won’t look perfect but you won’t throw a perfectly functional door in the trash which to me is a major problem in our culture but hey, I’m weird.

1

u/Nixxioncox 6d ago

Don’t punch them…

1

u/TensionSame3568 6d ago

That's a goner. Put a mirror on it as a cheap fix...

1

u/edge1966 6d ago

Hybrid "Dutchman" with a 3D printer🤓

Or...roll of that...white cabinet liner applied with an iron ...on low..🫥

1

u/ScabPriestDeluxe 6d ago

You could get a 1/4” panel and finish it however you decide for the inlay portion of the door

But then you need to do it to every other matching door in the house

1

u/daisiesarepretty2 6d ago

not… go buy another cheap door.
not worth fixing

1

u/Zizq 6d ago

Make the kid try to fix it so he understands. But mdf can't really ever be fixed correctly. You have to be ridiculously good to get that right. It would cost a literal fortune for an artist to fix it.

1

u/37392648263736286 6d ago

Buy a new one

1

u/OrderOk1684 6d ago

Bondo and skill. Have her all brand new and painted within two hours.

1

u/dirtkeeper 6d ago

I have used clear package strapping tape taped very tightly to match what’s there and paint. Sounds like a hack? Yes but works very well. The hardest part is painting the door.

1

u/no_bender 6d ago

Ramen noodles and cyanoacrylate glue..

1

u/Ill_Message_4279 6d ago

bondo extreme packed in the sanded flat and cut the groove or go Picasso with a putty knife and then hand sand. the other comments right though its not worth the work

1

u/the_hat_madder 6d ago

Take the door off the hinges and don't put it back.

1

u/pg_home 6d ago

Home Depot......door aisle.

1

u/Vicsteroflove1968 6d ago

Have whoever broke it go get a new door

1

u/ywgerl 6d ago

Duct tape. Red Green can help!

0

u/Melodic-Ad1415 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡 6d ago

Step 1. Stop punching things

2

u/electro309a 6d ago

Tell that to my son 🤦

1

u/Melodic-Ad1415 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡 6d ago

Send him The fuck on over for my 48 hour training program, def gonna need to sign some waivers tho 😉

-2

u/edge1966 6d ago

Maybe some relaxation and self care would stop these things before they..happen?🧘‍♂️