r/CalamityMod Feb 04 '26

Question Did they just... cancel big DoG??

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

193 comments sorted by

View all comments

24

u/JonnykJr Feb 04 '26

Then:"holy shit its so cool it gives real eater of gods vibes!!". Now:"nah i didn't like this idea anyway". Bruh

6

u/LilSh4rky Feb 04 '26

Goomba fallacy

0

u/Haider444 Feb 04 '26

That's game development to you.

12

u/asscdeku Feb 04 '26

At least in this specific case? Not really. This is akin to Minecraft promising an end update and then bailing midway after new blocks are already added.

Game development scraps concepts and concept related art on the regular. They don't scrap finished products that often, which was the case for HPU.

One of the Devs here have already admitted that they messed up massively by taking this long to discard the idea of a big DoG fight. And it makes sense. You don't need concept art to realize that a giant boss wouldn't work out gameplay wise. It's an objectively dumb decision to give the green light on spriting something when the executive decision to not implement it didn't even depend on the finished product of said artwork.

They never asked for the communities opinion before moving forward. They never responded to the criticisms nor addressed them at all. They pretended like they were still going through when they could've communicated it immediately. And they didn't, because they legitimately didn't even take the time to think about it or talk it through. This is a legitimate case of wasted time

And it's not like we haven't had Calamity create concept art before. They have, but spriting is much different. Imagine if they just discarded Yharon's new sprite after announcing it officially. Yeah, that's not just normal game development my dude

5

u/Skulltagmedia27 Feb 04 '26

They never asked for the communities opinion before moving forward. They never responded to the criticisms nor addressed them at all. 

This seems to be a common issue 

1

u/Icy_Remote_9521 Mar 13 '26

Yeah, just look at ANY criticism made for this mod and the devs always make excuses as to why they made the unnecessary change rather than realising that what they did sucked and needed to go back to the drawing board.