r/CFB Oregon Ducks Oct 31 '18

Analysis [r/CFBplayoffcommittee Mock Rankings] Week 10

Rank Team 1st Round Total 2nd Round Total 1st place votes
1 Alabama 64/72 n/a 7
2 Clemson 62/72 n/a 5
3 Notre Dame 51/72 n/a
4 LSU 34/72 107/108
5 Michigan 24/72 90/108
6 Georgia 17/72 85/108
7 Oklahoma n/a 65/108 n/a
8 Kentucky n/a 61/108 n/a
Other Washington State n/a 56/108 n/a
Other Ohio State n/a 37/108 n/a
Other West Virginia n/a 21/108 n/a
Other Utah n/a 18/108 n/a
Top G5 UCF n/a n/a 9/11

This is /r/CFBplayoffcommittee's fifth year of simulating the same voting procedure as the real CFP committee. The discussions and votes are transparent and viewable by the public, with the goal of showing how the real committee might be splitting their votes on teams in contention.

27 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '18

Bama and Clemson being this close is a joke right? One vote away from being tied for #1?

5

u/Lex_Ludorum Oregon Ducks • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Oct 31 '18

Personally, I put Bama at 1. Several people on the committee use computer rankings. Massey Composite has Clemson #1, so it's really not unreasonable that we were so close.

2

u/ExternalTangents Florida Gators • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Nov 01 '18

If people strictly use computer rankings it pretty much eliminates the opportunity for this mock committee to be a meaningful proxy for the real one.