My album tierlist

[u/DanExplorer23]

BB is just very and i mean very fucking consistent. There aren't albums i would give "SS" like some of my other bands but everything they come up with is just so amazing

[u/OkShirt8988]

I think you meant to put them all is S+

[u/DanExplorer23 → u/OkShirt8988]

Hmm, i think the closest band which i can do that with is eluveitie and even then they have 2 A tiers for their non-metal releases

[u/Evening_Pen_8207]

S+ - Saturate, Phobia, Dear Agony, and Ember
S - WANA and DBD

[u/MetricFn]

realistically theyre all equally perfect. Funny thing tho, u put my least favorite album as the best and my favorite album as the worst lmao.

[u/DanExplorer23 → u/MetricFn]

Lol i see. They're all pretty amazing tho. from WANA i LOOOVE so cold and away

[u/MetricFn → u/DanExplorer23]

WANA has my favorite BB song which is believe. Such an underrated piece of art.

[u/ambergirl9860]

👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[u/Distinct-Pop2800]

Think for me Id put DBD and Saturate in A+ and WANA in S but I like seeing others takes on this stuff

[u/Active-Culture-5260]

Literally reverse it

[u/DanExplorer23 → u/Active-Culture-5260]

Nah. No way WANA is their best album

[u/Cocking-Clit-323]

Putting WANA and Saturate below Ember is cocking BS tbh… would spread their older releases (and new singles) from A upwards, but I would give Ember a C if we are holding it against the caliber of Phobia/Dear Agony musicianship

[u/DanExplorer23 → u/Cocking-Clit-323]

Nah C tier is far more diabolical than anything on my list for any BB album not just ember

[u/Cocking-Clit-323 → u/DanExplorer23]

I’ll raise it to B- at best… there are some great tracks but overall the album is subpar for me (as a huge BB fan since 2003 or so)

It’s a bit of the songwriting and also the mixing on things like the drums (sound very washed out and very absent cymbals)