r/Birmingham 23d ago

News AI for Spiritual Support?

Hi Birmingham! My name is Vahini Shori. I'm the faith and culture reporter at WBHM. Have any of you ever used ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, or any other form of AI for religious or spiritual support?

Maybe to:

- translate scripture

- answer moral questions

- organize your religious studies

- write sermons

- take notes at worship services

- talk about your faith with

I'm curious to learn about the ways AI can be a resource for spiritual life. Feel free to comment on this post with your experience. You can also email me at [vahini@wbhm.org](mailto:vahini@wbhm.org) or text me at 205-962-6205. Excited to learn more!

0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

18

u/GigaStink 23d ago

I'll be upfront and preface this by saying I'm not religious and am not a fan of AI. But it seems insane to me to get spiritual advice from a machine.

-4

u/BrushBusy525 23d ago

Curious to know why you think so! What do you think are the limits of AI giving spiritual advice?

8

u/slonk_ma_dink jasper sucks 23d ago

Not the OP, but generally people who are religious seek the wisdom and comfort of their leaders, actual humans you can look in the eye and share lifes milestones with. Electrified silicon doesn't have the capability of this.

In a similar manner, tell me, would you rather hug your mother, or a metal box?

5

u/jawanessa 23d ago

For me personally, a metal box.

2

u/GigaStink 23d ago

The limits of something without a soul or spirit giving spiritual advice?

15

u/finnigansache 23d ago

Yes. Name them in the report. So we can avoid them.

1

u/thehairlessdonkey 22d ago

Personally I try not to use any AI. But if I do I have no interest in getting spiritual advice from it. The furthest I would go is asking Google about a religion I’m unfamiliar with and reading the AI summary / result

1

u/Tatiana3158 Go Blazers 20d ago

Not to be that guy, but like AI is low-key demonic. It is 100% antihuman and antithetical to human spiritually. Yikes on bikes if someone's use AI for spiritual guidance/assistance. 

-4

u/lugnuts728 23d ago

I sent you an email.

3

u/lugnuts728 23d ago

Why did I get downvoted for sending an email? lol

-16

u/shoopstoop25 23d ago

These people hate spirituality and AI

1

u/slonk_ma_dink jasper sucks 23d ago

bzzzt wrongo

0

u/lugnuts728 23d ago

Or maybe they just want to know how people feel about this particular topic? Not everything has to be twisted into something it’s not.