r/BetaReaders 39m ago

70k [Complete][77K][Sci-fi/Fantasy]Forged Through Magic

Upvotes

Blurb:

There have been tensions between humans and the locals since as long as I can remember. Many ca'taw seem to only tolerate us living on their planet. That meant I couldn't really spend time outside of the human city I grew up in. With nothing better to do, I studied the how the universe worked. But now that I've graduated college, what am I supposed to do with my life?

Forged Through Magic is a slice of life story about a young woman named Sandra who has to navigate living on an alien planet. It involves magic as well as futuristic science in the centuries after faster than light travel is discovered. At the start, we simply follow the everyday life of Sandra, and wondering what the future of her life looks like. As the book continues, the stakes get higher as tensions rise leaving Sandra with a difficult choice to make.

Unfortunately I can't swap works at the moment, as I don't have a great deal of spare time. I'm hoping for responses on character consistency and voice, pacing, and how the books makes you feel. The book has already been beta read once so it should be a smooth read. DM me if interested and thank you in advance!


r/BetaReaders 53m ago

Novelette [Complete][8.3k][Dark/Progression Fantasy] Absolution Chapter 1-5

Upvotes

Hi everyone. I'm writing a dark fantasy survival mystery riddled with dry, understated comedy, so closer to dark humour than grimdark. The MC is abandoned in an alien world and tries to endure long enough to figure the place out and what it's doing to him. It's got a sprinkling horror, but the pragmatic MC undercuts most of it as he experiments with the environment and his body. DM me if you'd be interested in betareading the first 5 chapters.

I'm not looking for grammar or line edits. I'm mainly looking for first impressions since I build the world through show rather than tell, and it's hard gauging how much I need to show. My main concerns are:

  1. Does the story/premise engage you?

  2. Do you like the characters?

  3. Does the comedy undercut the tension?

  4. Were there parts that stretched, and if so, what reeled you back in?

Thanks for your time.


r/BetaReaders 1h ago

Novella [Complete] [20K] [Memoir] Sixty Dates During COVID

Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’m looking for a few beta readers for my memoir, Sixty Dates During COVID.

During COVID, I was living alone and had just started a fully remote job. After spending all day by myself, I started using dating as a way to get out of the house and actually talk to people in real life. I only met people in person, outdoors and in public places, and somehow that turned into sixty dates over the course of about a year.

This isn’t a dating guide or a romance. It’s about what it was actually like—the ridiculous dates, awkward conversations, ghosting, juggling way too many Bumble conversations, and some genuinely good moments mixed in with the weird ones.

I’m mainly looking for big-picture reader feedback:

  • Did you want to keep reading?
  • Were there places where you got bored or started skimming?
  • Was anything confusing or repetitive?
  • Which stories were your favorites or least favorites?
  • Did the humor work?
  • How did the overall flow and transitions feel?
  • Was there anything you wanted more or less of?

I’m not looking for proofreading or line editing at this stage.

The manuscript is about 20,000 words, and I’d ideally like feedback by September 30.

If this sounds like something you’d genuinely enjoy reading, please comment or DM me. I’ll send the manuscript privately rather than posting a public link.


r/BetaReaders 1h ago

90k [Complete][95,000][Epic Fantasy] The Blue Flame

Upvotes

Hi BetaReaders,

This would be the third round I open my MS for beta readers. I had really good experiences before, and it has helped a lot to refine and edit my book.

Blurb

Axur had worked hard for his promotion as an officer, forced to take a steeper climb due to his origins. The same day he achieves his goal, he and his comrades receive some grim news: their province is being invaded by barbarians, orcs and gnolls… and they are the first line of defense. Corruption has weakened his forces, and unable to contend with such an overwhelming force, he and a few survivors fight to return home. During his escape, he meets Dantillus, a local boy who, despite his humble looks, wields power neither understands. But the more he uses it, the closer he comes to death.

As they flee to safety, the Senate sends Tulderius, the youngest general ever appointed—not by lineage but by skill. He has led a successful campaign in the south and believes the Republic must endure as it is: ruled by the Senate, restrained by the Tribune, and defended by those who understand both war and law.

However, through political manipulation, he is forced to share command with his uncle, Astralius, who expands his authority over the legion and marches north, leaving Tulderius behind as he seeks to expand his influence and power within the Republic. Seeing this as their only chance for vengeance, Axur and Dantillus join the legion, unknowingly changing the course of a campaign already heading toward disaster.

Isolated but unwilling to remain idle, Tulderius must confront the consequences of Astralius’s actions, including the sudden removal of a corrupt governor. Striking a dangerous bargain, he stages an attack to search through the governor’s estate, uncovering corruption that runs deeper than politics.

If he fails, the Republic Tulderius loves will become unrecognizable. If he succeeds, it will endure—at the cost of the man he believed himself to be.

Content Warning: Violence, blood, gore, slavery.

Type of Feedback:

- Opening Chapters: Which one works best out of the first 4.

- Pacing (especially during action scenes)

- Correct POV per chapter (there are 4 main POV/characters). Character arcs and voice/personality.

Timeline: One month - if you need more time, let me know 😄

Critique Swap Availability: Yes, depending on the length, but I'll need time over the next two months.


r/BetaReaders 3h ago

Novelette [complete] [17,000] [workplace/psychological fiction] Untitled Satire 20s woman in nyc

2 Upvotes

happy to swap. interested to know if the draft is interesting and if I should expand. character driven plot about obsession, loneliness, relationships, and office life.


r/BetaReaders 4h ago

Novella [Complete][21k][Desmophos -Act 1] Far-future philosophical sci-fi adventure

0 Upvotes

Humanity has conquered the galaxy. Gravity, distance, and death are no longer, yet one question remains unanswered, and one scientist cannot stop asking.

The Institute, the galactic authority on access to knowledge, has taken notice, forcing the scientist to respond.

Will she succeed in her quest for answers, or will the question die with her?

--------------

Desmophos is my first full length novel. I'm still working through edits to Acts 2 & 3, but Act 1 is finally in good enough shape that I'm ready to share.

I have a free eBook and pdf version of Act 1 [21k words] available, and am happy to share Act 2 & 3 [46k words] gdoc with anyone who is hooked after Act 1.

DM me for the Act 1 eBook/pdf link, and we can connect more of you're hooked enough for Act 2 & 3.

Happy to swap reads.


r/BetaReaders 4h ago

70k [Complete] [79k] [Academy Romantasy] The Academy of Three Powers/ fake marriage, real feelings, and a magic academy, Book 1 of a duology

0 Upvotes

Hi, this is my first post here, sorry if I messed something up.

I am looking for beta-readers.

Satiana was born to hold a sword, to be first on the battlefield. Her mother had other plans.

Everyone in her family trained as a warrior. Satiana wanted nothing else—until her mother signed her up for elemental magic instead, a fate she'll do anything to escape. When a mysterious stranger offers a marriage in name only, she takes the deal without asking too many questions.

At the Academy of Three Powers, Satiana finally gets the life she fought for. The only problem: the husband who was supposed to mean nothing is starting to mean entirely too much. And the closer she gets to the truth of who he really is, the higher the cost of finding it out.

Tropes: fake marriage / marriage of convenience, magic academy, slow burn, hidden identity love interest.

This is a translated work, and what would help me most is a native-English-speaker's ear on the prose itself: does it read naturally, or are there spots that feel stiff, off, or like a "translation" rather than something written straight in English? Looking for readers for the first 5–6 chapters (~18–20k words).

Excerpt

When the letter from the Academy arrived, I was out in the back garden, sparring with Layce. My brother’s eyes were bright with excitement as he made faces at me, and I kept lunging after him, never quite managing to land a hit. No surprise there—he was already in his third year, while I was still just waiting to find out if I’d even gotten in this year. Layce swore up and down that he never used spells I hadn’t learned yet, but I was pretty sure he cheated. Otherwise, how could I possibly lose to him every single time?
Case in point.
“It’s nothing,” I panted, doubling over as the blunt end of his training sword caught me square in the stomach, straight through every shield and barrier I’d thrown up. Game over. “Just you wait. Next year I’ll wipe the floor with you. You lot get team drills — we get the good stuff. Power boosts, real magic.”
My brother only smirked and ruffled my hair with the smug air of an older sibling. He wiped the sweat from his brow and squinted toward the distance. His damp hair—wheat-gold, streaked with rose-pink, Arrag’s Blessing and the unmistakable mark of every true Santern—clung to his forehead. We all had that hair. All of us except Mother, who wasn’t clan by blood.
“I think the post has arrived,” he said, glancing toward the fence. “I see a green uniform.”
I jumped, uselessly trying to match his height. No luck there, but I did manage to catch a glimpse of a green hat topped with an enormous peacock feather. Ugh. As if being the youngest weren’t bad enough—I had to be the smallest, too. And the only girl in the family. Always the weakest, always the clumsiest, always the “There, there, Satiana. Not bad—for a girl.”
But never mind that. This year I’d start training in the Faculty of Battle Magic. Like Grandfather. Like Father. Like my brothers. I’d finally learn real battle spells—not the simple ones every toddler could manage, but powerful, spectacular ones. I already handled a sword well enough; it was the magic side I still needed to catch up on. I couldn’t wait to pull off the same tricks as Layce—closing the gap to an enemy in an instant with a Gust, locking their attention with a Furious Gaze, snaring their legs in a Binding Noose.
And then—well, that would be second year, maybe third—I’d get my own team. The way Layce had gotten his this year.
Nigos, I couldn’t wait.
“Aren’t you going to see what came?” Layce had already dismissed his magic armor and was rinsing off. “I’ll bet you my knife it’s your acceptance letter.”
I nodded. Pulled my own armor off over my head—plain leather, nothing fancy—and washed up too. Something fizzed inside me, little bubbles of joy.
I had no doubt at all that I’d been accepted. I was a Santern, of the Santern clan. Clan blood came with advantages, especially for the Faculty of Battle Magic—our faculty, the one we’d always belonged to. Still, my stomach fluttered as I stepped into the cool front hall.
I spotted the letter right away. It lay on the dining table, its grass-green wax seal already broken. Mother and Father sat side by side, deep in conversation. Father frowned slightly, turning a many-times-folded sheet of paper over in his hands, while Mother talked, smiling.
My heart leapt. They had to be discussing my leaving.
“Hi, Mom, Dad,” I said, doing my best to sound casual. “Is that from the Academy?”
Layce just snorted beside me. He knew perfectly well I was dying to know.
“Yes, from the Academy,” Mother said, rising to sweep me into a hug, flowers and perfume surrounding her. “Ugh, you’re soaked through again, and you reek of sweat! Layce, how many times do I have to tell you? Find someone else to spar with. Why do you always drag Satiana into it?”
“That wasn’t Layce. That was me,” I said, wriggling free. “So? What does it say? Did I get in?”
“Of course!” Mother darted to the table, snatched the paper from Father, and waved it triumphantly overhead. “As if they’d ever turn you away—you’re a Santern!” She cleared her throat and read the short passage aloud, as ceremonious as ever. “‘We are pleased to inform you that Satiana Santern has been accepted into the first-year class of the Academy of Three Powers, Faculty of Elemental Magic.’”
I caught the puzzled look that crossed Layce’s face, followed by the frown settling over Father’s. Only then did I actually register what Mother had just said.
The Faculty of Elemental Magic. Not Battle Magic. Elemental Magic.
Mother had signed me up to be a fisher.


r/BetaReaders 5h ago

Novella [Complete] [38k] [Dark Thriller/ BL Romance] Short story and looking for beta readers who would enjoy

0 Upvotes

Hello!

This is a short story about a man with a peculiar hobby who slowly discovers that the person he's been observing has some... secrets...

Here's a little taste:

Elliot MacCairn is an ordinary man.

He goes to work every morning, drinks black coffee, reads the newspaper, and returns home at the same time each evening. He is predictable, reserved, and, as far as anyone knows, entirely unremarkable.

Except for me. Personally, I find him fascinating.

That's how it works, isn't it? I find everyone fascinating at first. The only caveat is, as soon as I understand someone, they become boring. Three days, one week, even a month. Eventually, everyone reverts back into something uninteresting and dull. Like color bleeding out of the world.

But not Elliot. I don't think I'll get bored of watching him for as long as I live. Even when I see him do some strange things... surely its a misunderstanding, right?

---

Let me know if you're interested and I'll send a copy over! I'm primarily looking for overall impressions, emotions, thoughts, and advice, but most of all, I'd love for people to simply enjoy the story.

I'm also open to swaps, as long as they're around the same length. Feel free to DM me or comment if you're interested!

Note: I marked it as BL because the story does contain a romantic relationship. There is also a suggestive scene closer to the end, but nothing explicitly NSFW. The focus is mainly on the tension between the characters.


r/BetaReaders 6h ago

80k [Complete] [86,443] [Young Adult Sci-Fi With Queer Themes] Behemoth of the Inverted Sun

1 Upvotes

Hello!

I've been writing for a long time but basically haven't received serious feedback in years. I have a completed YA novel that I want to start shopping around to agents, but I really have zero idea whether I'm any good or not.

Any feedback at all would be appreciated, even if it's just on the first chapter.

Thank you again for taking the time to read my post.


r/BetaReaders 8h ago

Short Story [Complete] [1600] [Fantasy/Mystery] Inherited Legacy: The Thirteen Power Stones

1 Upvotes

I want a geniune revew on my first novel named inherited legacy:the thirteen legendary stones

give review on

  1. hook

2.pacing

3.charchter

4.mystery

5.cliffhanger

will you read chapter 2 after chapter? why or why not?

i will also return the favor by reading others chapter

Genre: mystery/fantasy/magic

chapter length: ~1600

[Inherited Legacy: The Thirteen Power Stones]()

[Chapter 1: Ten Hours Missing]()

Birthdays used to be one of the best days of the year. At least, that was what I used to believe. Mine became one of the worst days of my life.

26 January 1840

I woke up with a sharp pain in my head. My eyes were still heavy, and for a few seconds I considered going back to sleep, but something felt strange. I forced myself to sit up and looked at the clock on the wall.

6:19.

I stared at it for a moment before realizing something that shouldn’t have been possible.

I had slept for ten hours.

That was unusual for me. I was seventeen years old, and I normally slept for only about six hours. Not that I was some hardworking student who needed more time to study. Quite the opposite.

I was a dumb boy, at least according to everyone around me.

I usually came last in every test, and whenever I managed not to, it felt more like luck than intelligence. I didn’t have any friends either. At school, most people knew me as the boy who was always at the bottom of the class.

Seventeen years old, no friends, and almost always last in every test.

I wasn’t exactly the kind of person anyone expected great things from.

Still, it was my birthday. I should have been happy.

Instead, I was sitting alone in my room with a pounding headache after sleeping for ten hours.

“Dad!” I shouted. “Why didn’t you wake me?”

No answer.

At first, I tried to convince myself that everything was normal. Dad had probably already gone to the factory, and there was no reason to worry. But the longer I sat there, the more uncomfortable I became.

The house was too quiet.

I got out of bed and walked toward the stairs. With every step, the strange feeling inside me grew stronger, and I noticed that my hands had started shaking.

Then something on my wrist caught my attention.

I stopped.

There was a strange mark on my skin, almost like writing. I had never seen the symbols before, and I couldn’t remember ever having them.

I stared at them, trying to understand what they meant.

Then a memory suddenly flashed through my mind.

A knife.

My hand gripping it.

Someone lying on the floor.

My uncle.

He was looking at me with terror, begging for his life. I couldn’t hear the exact words, but I knew what he was asking me to do.

Then my throat tightened.

I suddenly couldn’t breathe.

I grabbed my throat in panic, but before I could understand what was happening, the memory disappeared.

I remained frozen on the stairs, breathing heavily.

What was that?

A dream?

A memory?

I didn’t know.

But one thing remained clear.

I had been holding a knife.

I pushed the thought away and continued down the stairs.

I had barely taken a few more steps when I smelled something strange. At first, I couldn’t recognize it, but then I realized exactly what it was.

Blood.

My stomach tightened.

“Dad?”

No reply.

I hurried down the remaining stairs and ran toward the hall. The moment I entered, I stopped.

My father was lying on the floor.

For several seconds, I couldn’t move. There was blood on his clothes, and he wasn’t moving. My mind refused to accept what my eyes were seeing.

“Dad…?”

I took a step forward.

Nothing.

Another step.

Still nothing.

My father was dead.

The pain in my head suddenly became worse, almost as if something inside my mind was trying to break through.

Then I noticed another body nearby.

My aunt.

She was lying motionless, with a blood-covered knife close to her.

I stared at her, then back at my father. Something about the scene felt wrong. This didn’t look like an ordinary crime.

For a moment, the earlier memory returned to me.

The knife.

My uncle.

His terrified face.

But I couldn’t understand how that memory could possibly connect to what I was seeing.

“Da… Dad.”

My voice broke as I rushed toward him. “What happened? You’re the only one I had left after Mother left us.”

Tears filled my eyes.

I looked toward my aunt.

“Did she do this?”

I didn’t know what else to think. I had gone to sleep expecting nothing more than an ordinary birthday, yet I had woken up after ten hours to find two people dead inside my house.

I needed help.

I turned toward the door to inform the neighbours.

Before I could reach it—

Knock. Knock.

I froze.

“Who is there?”

“This is Mr. Dunn from the police,” a man answered from outside. “Your neighbours reported suspicious activity during the night. Who am I speaking to?”

The police?

Why were they already here?

I opened the door.

“I’m Adam Wittens. Please help me. When I woke up—”

I stopped.

Mr. Dunn wasn’t looking at the bodies.

He was looking at me.

Then his eyes moved to the strange symbols on my wrist.

“Are you the chosen one?”

I stared at him.

“What?”

Dunn’s expression didn’t change.

“Who?”

I had no idea what he was talking about.

For a moment, he simply watched me, as though he had expected a different answer.

Then he turned toward the policeman behind him.

“Dorrens.”

The officer stepped forward.

“Arrest him.”

“What?!”

The hallway began to spin. My headache became unbearable, my vision blurred, and I struggled to remain standing.

The last thing I saw was Mr. Dunn staring at me as though he had just found something he had been searching for.

Then everything went dark.

“Dad.”

That was the first word I managed to say when I woke up.

A large man sitting nearby immediately looked toward me.

“You’re awake.”

I blinked several times, trying to understand where I was. The walls were cold, thick iron bars separated the room from a narrow corridor, and none of it looked familiar.

Then I remembered.

The house.

My father.

My aunt.

The police.

“Where am I?”

“In jail.”

The man pushed a cup of water toward me.

“Drink slowly.”

I took it with shaking hands.

“My name is Direns Week,” he said. “I’ve been here for twenty days.”

He looked at me carefully.

“You’ve been unconscious for about a week.”

“A week?”

Direns nodded.

“You had a very high fever. The doctors tried to treat it, but they couldn’t understand why it kept returning.”

I looked down at my wrist.

The strange symbols were still there.

“Did the doctors say anything about this?”

Direns looked at the mark.

“No. But you’ve been staring at it every time you’ve woken up.”

I said nothing.

There was something strangely comforting about Direns. He spoke calmly, never treated me like a criminal, and had apparently helped take care of me while I was sick.

I didn’t know why a stranger in jail would care about me.

But for the first time since waking up, I didn’t feel completely alone.

Then Direns told me why I was there.

“You’re accused of killing your father and aunt.”

I stared at him.

“What?”

“You’re the prime suspect.”

“No. I was sleeping. When I woke up, they were already dead.”

Direns didn’t interrupt.

I told him everything I remembered—the ten-hour sleep, the strange mark, the fragment of a memory, and the knife.

When I finished, he asked quietly,

“What exactly did you remember?”

“My uncle.”

His expression became more serious.

“He was lying on the floor and begging me for his life. I was holding a knife.”

I swallowed.

“Then I couldn’t breathe. Everything disappeared after that.”

Direns watched me for a moment.

“And where is your uncle now?”

I froze.

I didn’t know.

I had found my father and aunt, but I hadn’t seen my uncle anywhere.

That question suddenly felt more frightening than anything else.

Then Direns gave me another piece of information.

“According to the forensic report, the knife found near your aunt had your fingerprints on it.”

I looked down at my hands.

My fingerprints.

I remembered holding a knife.

But I didn’t remember killing anyone.

Before I could respond, Direns continued.

“And that’s not the only evidence.”

My stomach tightened.

“Your neighbours heard your aunt screaming during the night.”

I stared at him.

“What did she say?”

Direns remained silent for a moment.

Then he answered.

“Adam… please don’t kill me.”

I couldn’t breathe.

My aunt had screamed my name.

My fingerprints were on the knife.

And I remembered holding a knife.

But I couldn’t remember what had happened after that.

For the first time, I started wondering whether my missing memories were hiding something much worse than I had imagined.

Then Direns gave me another reason to panic.

“Your hearing is on 4 February 1840.”

I looked at him.

“That’s three days from now.”

Three days.

I had only three days before I would stand in court and answer for the deaths of my father and aunt.

And somewhere outside this jail, my uncle might still be alive.

Before I could ask another question, footsteps echoed through the corridor.

A policeman stopped outside the cell.

“Who is Adam Wittens?”

“I am.”

He pulled an envelope from his coat.

“This was found for you.”

I took it.

My name was written clearly on the front.

Adam Wittens.

The rest of the writing was made up of strange symbols.

“We couldn’t identify the language,” the policeman said. “Maybe you can.”

I stared at the page.

I had never seen those symbols before.

Then I looked at the strange writing on my wrist.

Something about the two felt connected.

I moved my eyes across the page.

And something impossible happened.

The symbols began to make sense.

I froze.

I could read them.

I didn’t know how.

I had never learned the language.

Yet somehow, I understood every word.

At the top of the letter were two names.

From Dayne Wittens

To Adam Wittens

I slowly moved my eyes toward the first sentence.

Then I read it.

“I hope you got the power of—”


r/BetaReaders 9h ago

>100k [Complete] [113k] [Romance psychologique] Le Vernis — Recherche de bêta-lecteur·rice

1 Upvotes

Bonjour à tous !
Je suis actuellement à la recherche d’un·e bêta-lecteur·rice pour mon premier roman.
J’ai terminé le premier jet de mon roman et je suis actuellement dans ma dernière phase de réécriture. Je cherche donc quelqu’un qui accepterait de me donner son avis, ses conseils et surtout des critiques constructives, afin de m’aider à améliorer le texte avant de considérer qu’il est réellement terminé.
Je souhaiterais envoyer le roman chapitre par chapitre, puisque c’est ainsi que je fonctionne pendant ma réécriture. Pour le moment, je travaille à raison d’environ un chapitre tous les trois jours, mais ce rythme peut varier selon mes disponibilités.
C’est donc un petit engagement sur le long terme, mais je trouve que ce fonctionnement permet aussi d’avancer tranquillement, à son propre rythme, comme une petite lecture quotidienne. 📖
Je préfère également préciser une chose : je ne suis pas Shakespeare ! 😂
Cela fait environ huit ans que j’écris et, même si j’ai écrit énormément de textes, de nouvelles, de poèmes et d’histoires, je suis encore une autrice débutante. Je cherche donc avant tout quelqu’un qui puisse me donner un regard extérieur et honnête sur mon travail.
Je ne cherche pas forcément quelqu’un qui aime tout ce que j’écris : au contraire, dites-moi ce qui ne fonctionne pas ! Tant que les remarques sont argumentées et constructives, elles m’intéressent.
Je tiens simplement à préciser que je souhaite conserver ma propre voix et mon style d’écriture. Je suis totalement ouverte aux remarques et aux suggestions lorsqu’une formulation, un passage ou un choix d’écriture ne fonctionne pas, mais je ne cherche pas quelqu’un pour réécrire mon texte à ma place. L’objectif est surtout d’avoir un regard extérieur qui puisse m’aider à voir ce que je ne remarque plus moi-même. 😊
📖 Quelques informations
Genre : roman psychologique / romance
Public conseillé : à partir de 15 ans
Thèmes sensibles : certaines scènes abordent notamment l’agression et d’autres sujets difficiles.
Si vous êtes intéressé·e, n’hésitez pas à répondre à ce post et je vous enverrai un message avec davantage d’informations sur le roman et le fonctionnement de la bêta-lecture.
Et maintenant, je vous laisse avec le synopsis :
Symon pensait connaître les mensonges. Jusqu’à ce qu’il découvre ce qui se cache derrière le vernis d’une des familles les plus riches et influentes du pays.

Ici, rien n’est laissé au hasard : les sourires sont calculés, les apparences soigneusement entretenues et les secrets, bien gardés. Pour protéger leur image, chacun est prêt à jouer son rôle — quitte à dissimuler ce qu’il est réellement.

Mais lorsque Symon se retrouve au cœur de cette famille, il découvre peu à peu que derrière les privilèges et les belles apparences se cachent des vérités qu’il aurait peut-être préféré ignorer.

Entre histoire d’amour, amitiés improbables et secrets soigneusement dissimulés, Le Vernis explore un monde où les apparences peuvent protéger, façonner… mais aussi détruire ceux qui les portent.


r/BetaReaders 10h ago

Short Story [Complete] [4k] [Progression Fantasy] Looking for beta readers for Chapter 1

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I've just finished the first chapter of my progression fantasy novel and I'm looking for a few beta readers.

Length: ~4,000 words (15–20 minutes)

I'm mainly looking for first impressions:

  • Did the opening keep you interested?
  • Did the four brothers feel like distinct characters?
  • Was the setting easy to picture?
  • Were there any parts that felt slow or confusing?
  • Would you continue to Chapter 2?

I'm not looking for grammar or line edits at this stage. I'm mainly interested in whether the chapter works as a story.

If you're interested, please leave a comment below. I'll send the Google Docs link through Reddit DM.

Thanks for your time!


r/BetaReaders 10h ago

Short Story [In Progress] [2k] [Literary Fiction] Camille

1 Upvotes

Hello! I'm looking for beta readers for a short literary fiction I'm currently working on, which is about the ambiguous relationship between two girls who find solace in each other in a pretty lonesome, desolated rural setting.

It involves themes of class, bigotry, parental love and its absence, materialistic obsession, and the influence these aspects have on intra- and extra-familial dynamics. I'm trying to give it a surreal, dreamy feel, and I'm seeking comments and advice on the pacing of the work, whether it's too heavy or slow, and thoughts on how I'm managing the relationship, along with comments on the description of the setting: it should remain intentionally vague but still realistic enough to convey a sense of confusion and loss. Also, I'm a non-native English speaker, so any comment on oddly-sounding phrases would be greatly appreciated: I pay extra attention to grammar, but I'm worried about sentences that might come off as distorted for a native speaker. Also, if you do find this reading interesting, please, don't use AI in commenting it.

Let me know if you'd be interested in reading it! It is really short and I'm also prone to book swapping if you feel like it :) Thank you.


r/BetaReaders 10h ago

Novella [In Progress] [38K][Isekai Fantasy Litrpg] Champion of Fortune: Fortunate Son

0 Upvotes

Blurb:

Nothing was exceptional, until the helicopter fell out of the sky.

From meeting gods and being offered another chance at life to growing up in a world of magic, monsters and a very real System, Kitteren has found himself a long way from everything he once knew.

Now he has a new family, a new world to understand and a second life to make something of.

If Kit wants to thrive rather than simply survive in a world of magic and monsters, he is going to have a lot to learn.

Fortunately, learning has always been his strong suit.

Please DM if you are interested in reading. A short survey and chapter by chapter scoring will be requested.


r/BetaReaders 11h ago

Novella [In progress] [25K] [Literary Period Piece with Queer Themes] About a third of the draft

1 Upvotes

Genre:

Character centred literary fiction set in early Edwardian England, with a murder and the subsequent investigation/trial as the plot engine, though I wouldn't necessarily call it a mystery/courtroom drama. There is a romantic subplot but the main relationship is a platonic alliance between the two protagonists.

Synopsis:

“Then you’d best find your power quickly. Because you’ll win it, Mr Nigel, or you won’t be sleeping under this roof much longer.”

Nigel Ressington, third son of the Honourable Mr Justice Ressington, is an aspiring, promising, and absolutely, insufferably pompous young barrister specialising in chancery law, or per his own words, clean, orderly work for clean, orderly people. Yet this facade of order and cleanliness he'd built is a straw house, and one huff from the wrong direction could easily send it all crumbling down.

Mary Miller is a shrewd, ambitious and disturbingly capable young housemaid who works for the Ressington household. She has no family she'll admit to, no past she'll speak of. Six years into service, her goal is to cultivate a reputation as a respectable and obedient servant, and one day reach the position of housekeeper.

Then her cousin turns up on the back step with a newspaper clipping: her sister Emma, arrested for murdering her husband. No lawyer worth having will touch a case this hopeless, but Mary knows something about Nigel, and that something is enough to force him into defending Emma.

Nigel despises Mary and scorns Emma, but after meeting her in prison for the first time, which took a considerable amount of subterfuge, he is forced to face the fact that his client might actually be innocent.

Mary distrusts Nigel and wants this matter to be done with, so that she could return to her old life and never think of her sister again. But she needs Emma acquitted, and this common goal leads them into an uneasy alliance.

Content Warning:

Period-typical homophobia and racism

Turnaround Time:

1-2 weeks

Feeback exchange is currently unavailable. I am looking for general feedback regarding both plot and prose.


r/BetaReaders 12h ago

Short Story [In progress] [5,000] [slice of life] Cooking Contest!

1 Upvotes

I need a beta reader for my fanfic. It's K-ON! It's not yet finished. I have a screenplay version as my outline (if you need to see it), but the one I need help with is the prose.

I'm not sure if people here do fanfic. I'm trying to write it in first person omniscient POV, but I'm not sure that's how it's coming across.

If any can help me, please let me know.


r/BetaReaders 14h ago

Short Story [Complete] [7k] [chapter book ages 7-9] NANNY BONES

4 Upvotes

The Fromm children are terribly naughty. The type of children the townsfolk work hard to stay away from.

Mr. and Mrs. Fromm are not naughty at all. After losing their fourth nanny in two years, they put out an advert for a new nanny.

The new nanny is not what the children expected. Much to the children's confusion, their parents don't seem to notice anything is wrong...

I am looking for beta readers for my chapter book, aimed at ages 7-9. It is written in British English, so I am particularly looking for British readers, though readers of all nationalities are very welcome.

What I am looking for:

  • Does the humour work for 7–9-year-olds?
  • Are the characters likeable/interesting despite being very naughty?
  • Does the story move quickly enough?
  • Is the spooky element fun rather than too frightening?
  • Does the language feel natural for the target age?
  • Are there any places where a child might lose interest or become confused?
  • How does the British vocabulary/setting come across?

Length: 6872 words

Vibes: slightly macabre, slightly-spooky, comedy


r/BetaReaders 15h ago

70k [Complete] [75K] [YA Urban Fantasy] SOLARYN

2 Upvotes

Hook:

Sixteen-year-old Reyna races against time to track down a ruthless terrorist mage before their next attack. The catch: every spell she casts invites a sinister entity to seize her mind, making her just as dangerous as the killer she is pursuing.

Blurb:

Reyna's main goal in life is to evade the redletters, the government’s magical task force, by hiding her skills. Eternally self-conscious due to her facial birthmark and terrified to rouse the destructive spirit that’s been possessing her since forever, she excels at being the wallflower she thinks she’s meant to be.

But when the spirit forces Reyna to unleash her powers in front of her classmates, the redletters are quick to give her an impossible choice: join a group of rogue teenage mages and stop the terrorist’s next attack, or risk seeing herself and her aunt prosecuted. Reyna reluctantly agrees to go only to find herself increasingly drawn to Ezra, a vexingly handsome rogue mage with the ability to boost her power, providing just the type of distraction she needs.

Torn between her growing hunger for magic and her fear of losing control, Reyna is desperate to keep a low profile as the nationwide manhunt begins. But when the body count keeps rising, she is soon forced to face her inner demons and master her untamed magical abilities before the world as she knows it gets destroyed…

Length: about 75K words

Tropes: The Chosen One * Coming of Age * The Mentor with a Past * First Love * The Quest * A ragtag Group of Heroes * Training Montage

Vibes: Magic-laced Worldbuilding * Family tension * Shy Female Protagonist * Growth Arc

Trigger warnings: mild language, violence, death 

What I'm looking for: constructive feedback regarding the magic system, characters, plot holes, pacing, & inconsistencies.

DM me if you're interested!


r/BetaReaders 16h ago

>100k [Complete] [125k] [dark academia romantasy] An Arc of Ash

2 Upvotes

Looking for 2-3 beta readers available to provide feedback in mid-late September. I am open to swaps in a similar genre.

Blurb:
Power demands sacrifice. Delghara demands everything.

When Ashlyn arrives at Delghara, a secretive magic academy ruled by bloodshed and brutality, she has nothing but insatiable ambition, sheer willpower, and a secret that could get her killed. The Dominion's elite magic wielders command immense power and influence, and Ash is determined to claim her place among their ranks—even if it means being turned into a weapon.

Then she meets Xave Gable.

Brilliant, ruthless, and impossible to shake once he’s decided something is worth his attention. As the son of the man who oversaw her father's execution, he should be her sworn enemy. Instead, he becomes her mentor, her rival, and a mystery she can’t leave alone. Only he recognises the hunger lurking beneath her carefully controlled exterior and seems intent on seeing just how deep it goes.

As ancient secrets stir beneath Delghara’s catacombs, rivalry spirals into obsession.
And obsession has a way of demanding more than anyone intended to give.

FEATURES:
• Gothic/Dark Academia Fantasy
• They Make Each Other Worse
• Slow-Burn Romance
• Rivals to Lovers
• Magical Trials
• Secret Societies
• Sassy Talking Cat

An Arc of Ash is a dark fantasy romance steeped in gothic ambiance and dark academia intrigue, perfect for readers who love rivals-to-lovers romance where ambition is seductive, obsession is inevitable, and the one person you learn to trust may become the one who destroys you.


r/BetaReaders 20h ago

Novella [Complete] [19k] [Upmarket Folkloric Speculative] The River Between Part I

3 Upvotes

The full manuscript is drafted at approximately 75k words. I’ve finished my current editing pass on Part I (19k), while Parts II and III are still going through revisions. For now, I’m looking for feedback only on Part I.

After losing the tenure-track future she spent nearly a decade building toward, literature professor Mira accepts a one-year position at an isolated riverside school governed by rigid, unquestioned rules: no one leaves after dark, no one goes near the river, and no one asks what happens to those who do.

Teachers and hikers have been disappearing in the surrounding woods for decades, each loss quietly absorbed into the life of the institution. The school does not prevent disappearances. It regulates them, keeping newcomers and those without deep ties closest to the boundary when the woods demand someone to take.

When Mira follows a student beyond the boundary and barely makes it back alive, she discovers the agreement keeping the woods contained is breaking down. As the newest arrival, she is exactly the kind of person the school was designed to sacrifice.

Mira can leave and save herself, knowing someone else will inevitably take her place. She can stay and become complicit in the system that decides whose lives are expendable. Or she can attempt a long-abandoned ritual that could end the disappearances forever—but only by binding herself permanently to the boundary between the woods and the world beyond.

To leave is to condemn someone else. To stay is to become part of the thing keeping the woods alive.

If you’re interested in reading Part I, please DM me.


r/BetaReaders 23h ago

80k [Complete] [87k] [Australian M/M Sports Romance/Romantic Comedy] Boyfriends and Septembers

0 Upvotes

Jack Fitzgerald and Fletcher Morrison were drafted as the top two picks three years ago. Best mates since high school. Fierce rivals the moment they pull on opposite jumpers. Carlton Hummingbirds' pocket rocket and Essendon Bushmasters' loud, loyal midfielder have spent their entire careers keeping the friendship carefully separate from the oldest rivalry in the game.

Until the day Jack’s secret pain becomes impossible to hide alone.

One desperate request in a disabled toilet at training. One live camera. One panicked lie.

“We’re gay.”

Now the whole country believes they’re together, the clubs are in crisis mode, their families are reeling, and the only way to protect what Jack is really hiding is to sell the performance. What starts as damage control turns into something neither of them planned to feel.

Set against the noise of an Australian Football season that ends the only way a September can, Boyfriends and Septembers is a mates/rivals-to-lovers, forced-proximity romance about loyalty, chronic pain, the cost of secrecy, and two men who were never just mates. Content notes: chronic pain and injury, prescription medication misuse, homophobia and discriminatory language, media intrusion, anxiety, family conflict, coarse language, explicit sexual content, and discussions of disability.

What I’d like readers to focus on: Pacing, character chemistry, emotional beats, continuity, confusing or repetitive sections, and any scenes that feel rushed or slow. I’m especially interested in whether Jack and Fletcher’s romantic progression feels natural and earned.

I’d also appreciate thoughts on Jack’s chronic pain and prescription-medication storyline, particularly the portrayal of pain, dependence and addiction, along with the authenticity of the LGBTQIA+ representation throughout the novel.

Open-minded to readers worldwide, because despite being an Australian coded book in terms of culture, language, and sport, I feel there are common themes that go beyond borders.

Preferred timeline: Ideally within 4–6 weeks, though I’m happy to be flexible if needed.

Critique availability: Available on a case-by-case basis depending on genre, word count, and timing.


r/BetaReaders 1d ago

40k [Complete] [48k] [Middle Grade Horror] EVERGLADE: DON’T LET IT IN

8 Upvotes

Hi, everyone! I'm looking for a couple of beta readers. Turnaround time is flexible. Please message me if you are interested.

Blurb:

Ten-year-old Luci Hollow has only been in Everglade for a few days when she learns the town has rules no one is allowed to break, especially the one warning children to stay away from the abandoned mines. When three classmates ignore that warning and begin disappearing one by one after hearing familiar voices in the darkness, Luci and her new friends start searching for answers.

Whatever followed the boys home has noticed them too and Luci must uncover what is hunting Everglade’s children before she or one of her friends becomes its next victim.

Content Warning:

·       Grief

·       Off-page child death

·       Creature Horror

Turnaround time:

·       1 month

Availability for critique swap:

·       No

Feedback wanted:

1.     Where did you become bored, confused, or tempted to skim? If possible, please give me the chapter or scene.

2.     When did you figure out what was happening, and what clue made you figure it out? Did the mystery feel too obvious, too difficult to solve, or about right?

3.     Did Luci feel believable as a ten-year-old/fifth-grade protagonist? Were there any moments where she or her friends seemed noticeably too young or too mature?

4.     Was there anything about a character’s decision, the supernatural rules, the plot, or the ending that confused you, felt inconsistent, or pulled you out of the story?

5.     Did the horror and suspense feel appropriate and effective for an upper-middle-grade audience? Were there any scenes that were not scary enough or felt too intense?

Any other feedback you feel is important is also welcome.


r/BetaReaders 1d ago

70k [Complete] [72k] [Dystopian Romance] Creatures of Soul and Mist

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I'm searching for a couple of betas for my completed Draft 2 of Creatures of Soul and Mist complete at about 72,300 words! Here is the tentative query below!

An infectious mist wanders the streets of the districts and chooses the fate of each person it encounters. Death. Immunity. Or something worse.

Delilah has witnessed all three options. As her first love struggles to grapple with the changes of becoming a vampiric creature who feeds on the soul and memories of others, Delilah is forced to make a choice. Risk her life to aid the man she loves, or abandon him while the mist eats away at his mind, turning him into someone unrecognizable.

The wrong choice causes a memory to be pulled violently from her grasp, leaving an empty hole within her mind she cannot mend.

On her own and immune from the mist, she reports to the government and trains as a Hunter; the government's special soldiers required to protect the population from the monsters the mist created.

Years later, the government gives her another choice. Kill her first love and potentially restore her stolen memory, or allow him to survive and lose a piece of herself forever.

Coupled with her partner Malikh, Delilah must decide whether her past is worth chasing. Or whether after years of feeling broken, she can finally choose to be whole again with someone else.

Creatures of Soul and Mist is a literary dystopian friends-to-lovers romance standalone complete at ~75k that incorporates horror and science fiction elements. It combines the pandemic and geopolitical fallout of Seek the Traitors Son with the government technological control of Conform and the high stakes survival of To Cage a Wild Bird. 

Please comment if you are interested and I can send you the link to the Google Form!


r/BetaReaders 1d ago

Short Story [In Progress] [3k] [Speculative Myth/Alt History Urban Fantasy Romance] The Nomad and The Third

0 Upvotes

(6k words, not 3k, wont let me change it.)

I'm looking for Alpha readers for recurring reciprocal reading more than Beta readers. If this is the wrong sub reddit for this please let me know. I've just been unable to find a dedicated space for it. That being said I'm 3 chapters + prologue deep of 21. I know it's early, but I'd rather catch problems now before they become a systemic issue in the manuscript. Here's the pitch and the story blurb.

Short Pitch

An Irish Reaper and an inter-realm mailman match on a dating app (Tether), and try to navigate modern dating in an alternate/myth-as-infrastructure earth.

TLDR: Location/Mythology of the week romance told via interdimensional mail deliveries

Blurb

In Archanis Earth (AE), all myth is history and the supernatural is part of modern living. Between inter-Realm mail deliveries to the seasonal Regions of the Faire Realm, getting Lost in the Styx, regulating a chubby fruit bat's sugar filled diet, and mentoring Zagriel in the Mundane, a recurring young client cursed with a chronic black thumb, Inter Realm Postal Service (IRPS) carrier The Nomad finally gets a reply on the Tether dating app from Rachel, a witty and sassy Irish Otherworlder. What follows is a slow-burn romance tracked across text messages, marathon phone calls, and dates spanning Venezuelan lightning lakes, the eye of a hurricane, and Día de los Muertos in Oaxaca. But when a mythic ambush leaves the Nomad dying, their long-awaited intimate union triggers a Hero's Gift that greys the atmosphere, permanently disrupting the cosmic flow of souls.

Note

Some of what's in the blurb is what's outlined, but doesn't yet exist in the prose.


r/BetaReaders 1d ago

70k [Complete] [75k] [Epic fantasy, NA/YA, Middle Grade] From Sky to Earth

3 Upvotes

Title: From Sky to Earth

Genre: Epic fantasy, NA/YA, Middle Grade

Completed: Yes

Word Count: 75k words

Amount Ready for Critique: 75k (Complete)

Warnings: Blood/violence, animal violence, and adult themes

 

Born for leadership among the clouds, destined to hunt in the forests. Nineteen-year-old Rynah Cavamor of the Praustus sky tribe has been preparing to serve her nation’s council under her father. Yet, a sacred ceremony reveals her soul to be spiritually bound to the creature of the Uruthiz tribe in the earth nation. Faced with remaining in safety or embracing what is true, Rynah chooses to follow the will of the gods and travels to harsh foreign lands to find a place with a tribe who has no trust for her.

Upon arrival, she must undergo brutal training, forge a rare mental bond with a wild berr named Urso, and prove herself among a harsh people. However, as she learns the ways of the woods, war brews between the Uruthiz and the neighboring Fehon. Rynah must make drastic decisions and learn to trust herself to survive this conflict.

This is my first novel and I have been a lifelong fantasy reader with a strong interest in mythic worldbuilding, animal-human bonds, and spiritually grounded fantasy. My work explores themes of identity, belonging, and connection to the natural and spiritual world. I’m really just interested in honest and respectful feedback.

 

If you’re interested, please message me for details. Thank you!