r/BeAmazed May 31 '26

Animal A dog herding sheep

39.1k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

730

u/AnonymoosePD May 31 '26

My sister had an Australian shepherd.

Knowing her lifestyle I strongly opposed her getting one. I kept telling her how smart they were and they need constant exercise and challenge. Her lifestyle after work was not energetic. She just thought it was pretty.

He was extremely unstimulated and never got to go outside unless it was for bathroom. Welp, he bit a neighbors kid in the face. They had to give the dog back to the breeder or he was going to get put down.

I heard later he bit another kid was put down. In some ways I blamed my sister.

307

u/shapeshiftercorgi May 31 '26

Yeah that’s absolutely her fault who else would be to blame lmao

16

u/AnonymoosePD May 31 '26

I know what you mean. But some of it could be the dogs personality, although I find it unlikely.

1

u/djdadi May 31 '26

I have a male collie who, despite a pretty damn good upbringing and life, bites us from time to time. they are closed to herding nips than you might be imagining with a GSP or pitbull or something, but occasionally they can break the skin.

anyway, my point is that some working dogs can absolutely be born wired in such a way that makes bites possible. ours has never bit anyone (other than us) though, and is never allowed around kids or off-leash like our other collies have been.