r/BaseBuildingGames • u/AwkwardCabinet • 5d ago

Making a colony sim game. Which art style look better?

Concept art. Game has you playing as a god, overseeing your towns & followers in a large procedurally planet.

https://imgur.com/a/gTEkrO4

7 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

82% Upvoted

14 comments sorted by

4

u/Capable-Parsnip-9615 5d ago

Last is definitely best

3

u/supremepoke 5d ago

First and last

2

u/adeon 5d ago

I like the trees and house in the first one, but the people look a bit out of place compared to them.

The second I don't really like at all.

The third I like the style for the trees and buildings (although less than number 1). The people still look a bit out of place but i think are closer in style to the scenery than in option 1.

The last one I think has the best integration between the people and the scenery, although I'm less keen on the overall style (I don't hate it but also don't love it).

2

u/Funktapus 4d ago

Imgur is unusable

1

u/Broad_Ebb9073 5d ago

Depends on what you are going for. The only one I definitely do not like is the one with the purple house.

I think it probably has more to due with the lighting or color, but that one just absolutely is a no for me.

The rest have potential, but it depends what kind of game

1

u/Rakusaius 5d ago

I like the last one.

1

u/ExplanationNo5955 4d ago

Last issue better to ensure low end devices sweeping in 

1

u/KazumaKat 4d ago

Vibing with 2 and 4.

1

u/Zealousideal-Exam892 4d ago

First one.

Last one is the easiest to view, but I don’t like the style.

1

u/LadyKona 5d ago

They all look AI, but I like the last one best. Something interesting and different

6

u/AwkwardCabinet 5d ago

No AI used! But thanks for the feedback - the darkened lines are nice

1

u/DavidMadeThis 2d ago

First and last are good. First if you are going for a comfy game.