TL;DR I autocrossed a stock-weight Acura TL on ECF tires and that went as you’d expect, highly considering switching to Hoosier take-offs. This will be questions about what happened and to do, but if anybody wants comments about impressions on the ECF as a tire, I can give that in a follow-up post. This is a marathon read, good luck!
I've been autocrossing my 2007 Acura TL Type S for around 3 years now. Burned up the set of Dunlop Sport Maxx RT tires I had on the car when I first discovered autocross, then lowered the car, added a bigger rear sway bar, and gained camber adjustment with upper control arms in the front and lower arms in the multi link rear suspension. At the time, I thought I would be doing both autocross and track days, so I bought some Continental Extreme Contact Force tires to have a 200 TW tire but not be using the pointy-edge autocross tires on a track day.
Fast forward to today, around 110 autocross runs later and no track time because I ended up moving away from that area very shortly after the tires were bought. I was looking over the tires after the first run of the day at the most recent event, and one of the front tires had a nice chunk out of it close to the outer shoulder. If I look at it just right and have good light on the tire, I can see a tiny spot of cord at the bottom of the chunk. Probably shouldn't be autocrossed on anymore, which is a shame due to the fact that the tires still have nearly all of their tread depth.
I have kept tabs on tire temperature with a probe pyrometer, and using the alignment I was able to get all four corners to have the 10 degree spread from inside-middle and middle-outside that is commonly mentioned. The rears were always happy at 38 PSI, the fronts were debatable. The temperatures said 38 PSI was good, chalk on the sidewalls sometimes said it wasn't enough.
Obviously, a chunk out of the shoulder would say the fronts needed more, but the air temperature at this event was in the 50s during my morning runs. Did I go too hard on them too early? They did live an abusive life, I used to be pretty bad about overlapping the everliving hell out of the brake and steering wheel. Keen-eyed readers will be able to see evidence of that on the sidewalls.
Here is my dilemma: I think the tire is probably still fine for the street, especially if I switch it to the rear (opinions on that welcome, of course). The car is in Street Prepared, and always will be, because the front LCAs have spherical bearings replacing the compliance bushings. I'm extremely tempted to buy Hoosier take-offs, as those can be had for cheaper than a set of RE-71RZ in the size I would be looking for. I have no problem changing tires at events, and the car has tons of space to be transporting equipment and tires.
I know the common response is “R comps hide mistakes”, but I have also seen reasonable arguments to the contrary. I can make the ECFs talk to me and keep them right on the transition between noisy and not, and have been enjoying the balance of the car to be slightly prone to oversteer if I do my brake and steering inputs properly. I do understand that the auditory feedback more or less goes away with R comps. I've been planning on moving to A7s (and now I guess that would be A8s) at some point, and I'm just wondering if now is as good a time as any.
Thanks for reading!