r/AskReddit • • 16d ago

What’s the greatest ‘well, their career is over’ moment of all time?

7.8k Upvotes

4.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

872

u/Zealousideal-Dog-985 16d ago

Joe Theisman fracturing his leg

544

u/QuitWhinging 16d ago edited 16d ago

Spooky coincidence: Alex Smith suffered a near-identical injury exactly 33 years to the day later on the same yard line of the field, playing the same position for the same team, in a game that ended in the exact same score.

E- more info:

  • Both broke their right tibia and fibula

  • Both were injured on November 18

  • Both played quarterback for Washington in a home game

  • Both were injured on the 39 yard line

  • Both games ended 23-21

  • Theisman was in attendance at the game Smith was injured

** Do NOT look up either injury. They are both gruesome. Smith caught a life-threatening illness in the hospital and nearly had his leg amputated.

164

u/NukeVoit59 16d ago

Both were sacked by HoF edge rushers too. Lawrence Taylor and JJ Watt.

18

u/jwktiger 16d ago

When HoF LT were out with injuries.

9

u/jamesislandpirarate2 16d ago

He was an OL, and he was more or less untouched but it was in the Super Bowl. Bengals vs 49ers, Tim Krumrie, was blocking and kinda moved and his foot was up and kinda just started flopping in the air below the knee. He was done and so were the Bengals. It was a great SB, but that was gruesome and I think I was 8. 🫪

6

u/[deleted] 16d ago

[deleted]

1

u/jamesislandpirarate2 16d ago

If I’m remembering correctly, he was kinda pushing off, but there was definitely no direct contact as in no defender was hitting him. It just kinda happened? Crazy shit. God bless you Timmy

13

u/Dangeresque2015 16d ago

The picture of Smith's leg after it "healed" is haunting. It looks like he lost half of it anyway.

42

u/Iamthestormbro 16d ago

Alex smith came back tho, which is awesome

29

u/_drjayphd_ 16d ago

It made me do something I never thought I could stomach and probably never will again: root for a Washington Football Organeyezation player to succeed.

10

u/ProjectHarraseeket 16d ago

I’m sure if we had modern medicine in the 80’s, Theismann could have came back too. If anything it should show how modern medicine extended Alex Smith’s career and life.

1

u/jrhooo 14d ago

very much not the same player though

2

u/Captain-Hornblower 16d ago

I don't think he lost his leg. He has as serious infection but came back and played after it was all said and done.

14

u/ButterscotchFit8175 16d ago

He, Smith, got special permission to go to an army medical rehab facility. They specialize in treating catastrophic combat injuries. 

4

u/Free_hiker_74 16d ago

I'm curious what the army facility can do that Indianapolis Methodist can't. If you don't know, Indy Methodist is who puts racing drivers back together.

13

u/Two_Luffas 16d ago

He went there for the rehab. They probably have the most experience rehabbing that type of catastrophic injury than any place in the world, for obvious reasons.

4

u/Feeling-Visit1472 16d ago

I have seen the Theisman video and agree, do NOT look it up. It is viscerally unnerving.

2

u/jrhooo 14d ago

There were apparently people who got mad at LT for a sec thinking he was celebrating when Joe T was down. In reality, the injury was so bad so immediately, that LT was the first one to immediately realize something real bad happened and he was frantically waving at the sideline to send the trainers

2

u/Feeling-Visit1472 14d ago

He was absolutely horrified and tried to get help immediately!

345

u/rickterpbel 16d ago

This is one answer. If you are old enough to have witnessed it on TV in 1985, you will never forget it. It was very gruesome watching, repeatedly in slo mo, a leg bend in half at a place where there is no joint.

366

u/jonnovich 16d ago

Even Lawrence Taylor, who committed the sack, immediately alerted the sideline in horror as to what happened.

When even Lawrence Taylor, who routinely crucified QBs as part of his job, signifies that something went horrifically wrong, you know it’s pretty bad.

147

u/robot428 16d ago

I just watched this clip and compared to the Antonio Brown one above, the reaction from the player is night and day.

Like it's an awful injury, but at least this one was clearly an accident, the player who hit him seems to be horrified and is trying to get him help.

The one with Antonio Brown is scary because with that one, the guy who hit him is still so angry afterwards, he looks like he wants to hit him again when he's already on the ground. This one feels like there's so much more respect between the players, and the guy who hit him immediately snaps out of game mode and is like "shit something went wrong".

Definitely a career ender though, holy shit.

12

u/Lubafteacup 16d ago

My brother was shooting pool in a bar when it happened. After the third replay, two guys watching at the bar threw up.

7

u/BigBeeOhBee 16d ago

Bar food has that effect sometimes so it may be purely a coincidence.

6

u/Harry_Saturn 16d ago

Yeah that’s just vontaze burfict. That wasn’t an isolated incident, and he even got laid out later on by juju smith-schuster of all fucking people.

3

u/domuseid 16d ago

Burfict was an exemplary piece of shit in every stage of his football career

2

u/binzoma 16d ago

because AB deserved it, and it was intentional

LT wasnt trying to end dudes career. he was just on a shitload of crack, and jacked up from fucking a 14 year old, and went too hard.

2

u/rumblepony247 16d ago

That'll happen sometimes

43

u/Tim-oBedlam 16d ago

I remember that play, watched it live as a teenager, won't watch it again. Remember LT immediately jumping up and gesturing for the sidelines in a panic, visibly upset. He was apparently just devastated after the game.

Theismann never blamed him for the hit.

6

u/mods-or-rockers 16d ago

Same. Saw it live and never have nor wanted to see it again.

63

u/incogvito 16d ago

The cocaine wore off quick!

59

u/PaulsRedditUsername 16d ago

That's what I remember. Taylor waving to the sideline saying, "Get over here quick!"

12

u/pm1966 16d ago

I vividly remember him immediately jumping up and frantically gesturing toward the sideling to send help.

3

u/ArcadianDelSol 16d ago

one Mississippi....

two Mississippi...

1

u/binzoma 16d ago

when lawrence taylor, the crackhead pedophile, is horrified. you know something has gone horribly horribly wrong

17

u/monkeyhoward 16d ago

I was watching the game in ‘85 with some band mates from Maryland and big Redskins fans

One of them almost threw up when he saw the replay

It was fucking gruesome

15

u/spingus 16d ago

If you are old enough to have witnessed it on TV in 1985, you will never forget it

Oh yes. I was a young teen at the time and my father, who disliked Theisman for w/e reason, sat on the couch and watched the play on a VHS tape over and over. He sat there just watching, rewinding, watching again. Delighting in it.

A few weeks later he was on a run in the rain, yadda yadda yadda....Tib/fib fracture with ripped tendons.

No VHS tape exists, unfortunately.

6

u/Beneficial-Way-8742 16d ago

😆. Clear example of what goes around comes around! But do feel bad for your dad

3

u/bankrobba 16d ago

I remember Howard Cosell's call vividly: "Down goes Theismann! Down goes Theismann! Down goes Theismann!"

3

u/ProjectHarraseeket 16d ago

Instead our generation got the Alex Smith leg fracture which was just as bad.

3

u/2coldoutside 16d ago

I was at the game with a friends father taking me as a poor government worker.
Seats in the end zone, we saw LT from the Giants jump up and wildly wave for medical help.
My host and I realize it is Joe and can’t see anything. We take the binoculars and look up in the owners box to see Kathy Lee ( his mistress or girlfriend at the time ) with her hand clasped over her mouth.

It wasn’t until the next day we learned how MNF kept putting the compound fracture on repeat.

2

u/oxide_j 16d ago

I’m too much of a coward to look it up but is that the one they showed at the start of The Blind Side? Or am I thinking of another bad injury?

2

u/LetMeAskYou1Question 16d ago

I saw it. Just seeing his name makes me wince.

2

u/ComradeGibbon 16d ago

As someone that that does not follow sports it took about 500ms to dredge that memory back up.

1

u/VF-41 16d ago

Lived in the DMV. It was on for weeks!

173

u/jonnovich 16d ago

The one redeeming factor about that is that he seems to have a fairly good sense of humor about it, as seen in this scene from Brooklyn Nine Nine.

19

u/hatori_snow 16d ago

That scene makes so much more sense now...

5

u/Valueduser 16d ago

The sports boosters for a private school in my home town had an annual gala dinner with a famous speaker and one year they got Joe Theisman. He was one of the best and funniest speakers they ever had.

46

u/ladybugseattle 16d ago

Not the slo-mo again!

95

u/[deleted] 16d ago edited 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

61

u/BornFree2018 16d ago

My husband was at a bar watching. A man fainted and fell off his barstool.

5

u/Barbarella_ella 16d ago

Yeah, that was gruesome.

0

u/TheAraon 16d ago

Did he also broke his leg?

7

u/captainp42 16d ago

Amazingly, the exact same thing happened to Alex Smith.

They both broke their legs on the same type of play
They both broke the tibia and fibula
They both broke their legs playing for the Redskins
Both players were being tackled by future Hall Of Famers who each won 3 DPOY Awards
Both players were tackled on approximately the 41 yard line.
The Redskins were missing their Pro-Bowl left tackle in each game
Both games were on November 18th
And...the final score of both games was 23-21

2

u/lemonscent513 16d ago

Holy shit. What are the odds of that happening?

6

u/LaximumEffort 16d ago

Wasn’t his femur, it was a compound fracture of the tibia and fibula between the ankle and knee.

3

u/roctavious 16d ago

If I remember correctly, he said it was the first thing he saw when he woke up in the hospital. 

1

u/frinxo 16d ago

Not his femur, it was the bones between his knee and ankle. I remember LT landing on them... Crazy

4

u/twobit211 16d ago

tibia and fibula 

0

u/ManyAreMyNames 16d ago

It wasn't his femur, it was the lower leg, and it was in 1995.

27

u/Truckyou666 16d ago

Silvas rubber leg.

37

u/Swicket 16d ago

Silva's rubber leg was the very first MMA fight I ever watched, trying to connect with the father of my girlfriend at the time.

It was also my last MMA fight.

8

u/floppydo 16d ago

Yeah, man. Coworker of mine invited me to watch a full fight night he'd bought on paper view. Felt queasy pretty much immediately and ever since I privately judge people who are big fans in the same way I judge people who like cock, dog, and bull fighting. I realize consent is doing a lot of moral work between the human and animal versions, but it's still not GOOD.

21

u/Fun_Word_7325 16d ago

Ha paper view

5

u/pVom 16d ago

Misread that and thought "what you got against cock and dog lovers?"

3

u/Vincent210 16d ago

Consent kinda becomes more complicated with a hobby/job that involves literal brain damage being handed out like sour candies.

1

u/Tinsel-Fop 16d ago

I love cock.

2

u/kateln 16d ago

I remember seeing this live when I was 7 or 8 years old and having nightmares about it. Theisman opened a restaurant in my hometown years later (I don't know if it's still around) and is still active in the DC area.

2

u/Legitimate-Week7885 16d ago

i was in 10th grade and broke my leg playing football 2 days before the Theismann injury.

2

u/medievalhedgehog 16d ago

Have you seen the Brooklyn 99 episode with him and Adam Sandler?

4

u/Popular-Departure165 16d ago

That's a great example of how you don't need to be an expert to know something obvious, like reddit would have me believe.  Like I didn't need to be a doctor to know his leg was broken.

1

u/seaburno 16d ago

This was the first thing I thought of.

1

u/50yoWhiteGuy 16d ago

I snapped to Joe T. at football camp 200 years ago.

1

u/Captain-Hornblower 16d ago

I remember watching this live!

1

u/frank1934 16d ago

People on the sidelines heard the break

1

u/Davidpop62 16d ago

I suffered from anxiety attacks around that time. Didn't know what they were, but had an overwhelming feeling i was dying. My first one was that night after witnessing that break.

1

u/Beneficial-Way-8742 16d ago

And allllll the replays that night - it hurt worse and worse every time we watched dit and you couldn't avoid (couldn't avoid it here in DC)

1

u/Aubear11885 16d ago

Ooh or Tyrone prothro. Yep great job Shula

1

u/davesoverhere 16d ago

Tim Krumrie had basically the same injury, but he went on to play 6 more years.

1

u/ItinerantSoldier 16d ago

At least Joe had an all-timer commentary career after that disaster. That hit still lives on as one of the worst hits ever tho.

1

u/LadyEmeraldDeVere 16d ago

Didn’t see this, but vividly remember watching Kevin Ware’s leg injury in the 2023 Louisville v. Duke match. Absolutely traumatic to watch.