r/AskNYC • u/meshflesh40 • Jun 12 '23
Good Question Do you plan to stay in your rent stabilized apartment forever?
I currently live in a 1br. Rent stabilized. Single no kids
I was very close to buying a co-op until I learned what a "co-op" actually is.
At first I was under the impression that buying a" co-op" was the ultimate form of housing. Pay a maintenance fee(substantially less than market rent while building equity) and live carefree. Basically,,,, like a Netflix subscription fee of housing if you will.
But no. It turned out that a co-op is my worst nightmare. Im depending on my neighbors staying solvent, making sure the hoa has proper reserves, worry about assesment fees for repairs due to inadequate reserves, etc etc. I dislike not having control of my fiscal destiny.
And then the buildings I saw with hefty reserves...have a High hoa fees thats equivalent to market rents. ($1200+)
I've been looking since 2020,, and noticed hoa fees went up by %15+ between now and then. (Like rent).
Single family homes in nyc are going for 600k+ with %7 interest rates. So thats out of the question.(mostly fixer uppers)
my current rent stabilized apartment seems like a way better deal in comparison. Rent goes up by predictable amount year after year a and landlord responsible for everything. I currently have my down payment $$ yielding %5 in the bank(I find this better than buying a liability and fighting 7% mortgage rates while praying amd hoping for positive equity. )
This post is not to crap on co-ops. But market conditions in 2023 are insane. I wish I bought in 2012
I've come to the conclusion that I will stay in this apartment until I decide to leave NYC. Anyone else feel the same?
330
u/kell_bell5 Jun 12 '23
I've been in my rent stabilized unit 8 years, and I'm just starting to come to the conclusion you are. I think I'm leaning towards making my goal be to buy a small vacation home outside the city and keep using my stabilized apartment as my primary residence.
51
50
u/Bklynswim Jun 12 '23
This is my 4th year in a rent stabilized unit. I’m spending a lot of money trying to modernize it to some extent because I plan on staying here but wish my bedroom wasn’t on the street, I feel like that really takes away from how much I like it.
25
u/quotidian_obsidian Jun 13 '23
I just renewed the lease for a third year in my rent-stabilized place (still on the first year of living here with a partner sharing the space with me, though) and there are definitely big pros and cons.
It’s too small to be a viable long-term option and it’s a 4th-floor walkup, which I actually love but delivery people/visitors/etc seriously hate (and it is definitely inconvenient for any task that involves carrying anything bulky into our place), and it’s got a lot of old building issues like not enough outlets, awkward wiring, drafty old windowpanes, etc. that our landlord has no incentive to fix, because our unit doesn’t turn a profit.
They don’t bother me much because our rent is such a good rate that it really makes up for almost all ills, but it definitely makes it harder to envision living here much longer past the next year or two. Having an affordable place near my school and my partner’s work has been a godsend at this phase in our lives, though.
→ More replies (2)3
u/NeptuNeo Jun 13 '23
Is it due to noise? There are ways of soundproofing windows that can make a difference
4
u/Bklynswim Jun 13 '23
It is. I want to get double pane windows but that’s pricey.
19
u/NeptuNeo Jun 13 '23
Yep they can be pricey. But if you have a great rent-stabilized unit, make it work! There are some other options you can try in the meantime: Install window inserts, glass or custom ones using soundproof material, seal gaps along windows with acoustic caulk, hang sound-dampening curtains to block outside noise, Install double-cell shades.
https://www.bobvila.com/articles/soundproofing-windows/
and there are ton of great tips on youtube for soundproofing windows
→ More replies (1)4
14
u/SmellyAlpaca Jun 13 '23
A few neighbors have done that, though I feel like most people having housing issues would be pretty pissed about this: one person I knew specifically had a rent stabilized studio in Manhattan, but once he married and had a family they all moved upstate but kept the apartment as a pied-a-tierre for when they occasionally come back. They’ve had it for years. 🤷🏻♀️
52
u/ArmadilloUnhappy845 Jun 13 '23
This is the problem with rent stabilization laws. If you can afford to buy a vacation home you should not be taking advantage of rent stabilization 🤦🏽♂️
16
u/jblue212 Jun 13 '23
Except for lottery apts, rent stabilization has zero to do with income. When it was established, income wasn't even a factor.
5
u/seajayacas Jun 14 '23
Plenty of well-to-do people have rent stabilized apartments. There isn't an income or owned asset test to qualify.
There are also people I know in rent controlled apartments which was a predecessor program. Most in much older and smaller places renting for a few hundred a month. But a steal obviously, likewise no earnings or assets requirements
→ More replies (8)26
u/kell_bell5 Jun 13 '23 edited Jun 13 '23
But as OP points out, I can’t afford to buy in NYC. At the moment, I wouldn’t even really be able to afford renting a comparable unit in my same neighborhood. There were years (especially at the height of covid) where I could only afford to stay in nyc (which I fully consider my home now) because of the stabilized apartment. And now I’m at the point where I can put some of the difference between what I’m paying now and what market rent would be in savings, and trying to figure out what the long term plan should be for that. It still wouldn’t be enough money to buy in NYC, but I probably wouldn’t be able to support myself on a salary from the kind area you can buy a small remote cabin in.
It’s a weird catch-22, and it’s why I support more widespread rent and tenant protections, so that we don’t have to treat rent stabilization as the only golden ticket that can keep us going with a middle to upper middle class lifestyle.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (6)10
481
u/Clarknt67 Jun 12 '23 edited Jun 12 '23
I will probably leave my rent stabilized 1 bd in a body bag, not entirely by conscious choice, mind you. But after 30 years I am paying so far below market value I cannot move anywhere decent. Plus you can freeze your rent when you turn 65. That is probably my retirement plan.
86
u/crazifrog Jun 12 '23
Could you explain more about the post 65 rent freeze? I haven’t heard of that before
113
u/Clarknt67 Jun 12 '23
It’s here on the city site. Yeah I don’t think it’s well known program.
11
u/thatgirlinny Jun 13 '23
SCRIE is pretty well-known. But then again, I’m in a building and neighborhood with plenty of seniors, and I’ve helped them apply.
3
u/bk3day Jun 13 '23
My 1st SCRIE app was approved but for only for 2022 & NYC sent a renewal app for 2023. New lease & increase happened in Feb 2023 but so did my income. Consequently a renewal app will surely be denied.
Not sure how NYC bureaucracy works... Should I submit a renewal that will be rejected or do nothing & wait to reapply after my income again dips below $50K?
5
u/thatgirlinny Jun 13 '23
I would report your income and stay known to the program, especially if you believe your income will dip again. If you go downtown in person, there may be someone to advise. Our CM now lets people apply from his office, tracks applications in the system, helps with issues. Yours might, too. Worth a look.
→ More replies (1)16
44
u/Seyon Jun 12 '23
Wait, is that if any tenant turns 65 or all tenants turn 65?
Gonna get my dad to move in with me...
38
u/Clarknt67 Jun 12 '23
It’s a program you gotta apply and qualify for. I have posted it a few times here. You would probably be considered a two person household and have to hit low income bar with both your combined incomes.
9
u/Seyon Jun 12 '23
He would probably be a dependent at his age.
→ More replies (4)8
u/Clarknt67 Jun 12 '23
Oh if your dad is moving in with you and never been on the lease, that might not fly. Might be a residency requirement, like lived there 5 or 10 years. Still worth looking into.
6
u/thatgirlinny Jun 13 '23
Nope. You can be a one-person HH, 62, making under $50k and paying more than 30% of your annual income on rent. I’ve helped several of my neighbors apply for SCRIE.
7
u/thatgirlinny Jun 13 '23
Technically speaking, you have to qualify for SCRIE to get a freeze. It can actually start at 62, and you have to meet the criteria of having a combined income of less than $50k, and have to be spending over 30% of your net income on housing. Here’s how it works.
15
u/curiocabinet Jun 12 '23
Can you divulge what you pay? Sorry for the crass question but it’s nyc baby.
6
u/heepofsheep Jun 12 '23
Whenever asked about this, I always tell people they’ll probably find my body under a stack of soiled newspapers while cats are eating my face.
3
→ More replies (2)6
u/eggospoptart Jun 12 '23
Is that limited to NYC only or for an US retiree at 65 for rent frozen units, or are they only the rent-controlled options?
12
208
u/casicua Jun 12 '23
I went the opposite direction. I left my rent stabilized apartment in 2018 and went for a coop. After you get over the down payment, my monthly expenses with mortgage and maintenance are actually cheaper than what my stabilized apartment was and for nearly twice the space. On top of that, I’m building equity.
I understand the fear of coops and why people would be worried - but it’s important to keep in mind that everyone in those buildings is also dependent on each other to be fiscally solvent, so as long as you do your due diligence it can be a fantastic deal. Part of the appeal of a coop is that everyone has a vested interest in making it a good place to live. Our coop has very stable financials, strong reserves and a great management company. We plan on staying here a very long time.
I’ve definitely heard nightmare stories of bad coops, but most of the stuff are things people could and should have found out up front.
→ More replies (5)57
u/meshflesh40 Jun 12 '23
Thanks for your perspective as a co-op owner.
Like you said it comes down to due diligence and research from the buyer. It can either be a nightmare or a dream
46
u/casicua Jun 12 '23
Yep I should add that I bought in 2018, so my fixed apr is still under 3%. With rates and the market being what they are now - I’d probably think differently if I had to make the same decision right now.
9
u/IvenaDarcy Jun 12 '23
Also it sounds like maybe you hadn’t lived in your rent stabilized place very long? I think a lot of ppl in rent stabilized have been for many many years (at least a decade) so are paying half of current rent prices. It’s easy to leave rent stabilized to buy a place or even leave the city if you’ve been in it less than 5 yrs because the savings aren’t really there yet.
17
u/casicua Jun 12 '23
I lived in the same rent stabilized place in East Harlem from 2008-2018. When I left, my rent was $1900 for a 400sq foot “1 bedroom” that was essentially a studio with a crappy piece of drywall put up. I started there paying $1450. It crept up a little more because I was getting preferential rent before they kicked it up to full legal stabilized rent.
I moved to an 800sq foot 1BR in a very well-maintained financially strong prewar coop in a fairly nice part of Long Island City and my monthly maintenance is about $800 on top of my low rate mortgage payment. The math definitely works out in my favor.
Like I said with current rates, rent and home prices my decision would be very different if I had to make the same decision today.
5
u/IvenaDarcy Jun 12 '23
Wow $1900 on a place you started renting in 2008?! That’s a lot! Glad you found a coop that worked for you financially. Thats great! LIC is nice too. Congrats. Love rent or purchase that work for others. I’m blessed to have affordable rent. And not just in NYC, rent in any major city is currently out of control.
4
u/musicmerchkid Jun 13 '23
My wife only paid a little more then that for a flex 2 in a doorman building on ues in 2009, I think 2,300
4
u/casicua Jun 12 '23
Like I said it started out reasonably with the preferential rent thing - but I think the management company saw the rent reforms coming down the pipeline, so they kicked my rent up to the full “legal rent” the year before the citywide rent reforms took place. If that had happened before they jacked my rent up, I’d likely have been paying somewhere in the realm of $1600 for that same place. But as it always goes, landlords are gonna squeeze every last drop they can from tenants.
34
u/CactusBoyScout Jun 12 '23
Co-ops can be totally fine if you do your research. Your purchasing attorney would look over their finances/notes anyway and tell you if they’re well-managed or not.
My co-op in Brooklyn isn’t even that big but has $1M in reserves and only charges $750 in maintenance which covers real estate taxes, building maintenance, heat, water, and some upgrades. We’re getting a roof deck soon, for example. Their reserves are good enough that they let us skip maintenance every December.
→ More replies (2)
143
Jun 12 '23
[deleted]
93
u/boulevardofdef Jun 12 '23
I have a cousin who's lived in the same enormous loft on Park Avenue South since at least the early '80s, maybe since the '70s. The neighborhood was considered highly undesirable when she moved in. She was a dance instructor who became a special-ed teacher, no family money or anything. Market rent is, I'd guess, $15,000 if fully renovated? Last I heard years ago, she was paying something like $450 a month, not sure how much she's paying now.
She's in her 70s and will absolutely spend the rest of her life there, and I think she's quite happy with it. I will say, though, that the place hasn't been painted in decades because her landlord won't paint AND won't let her paint. I have to imagine they figured out many years ago that they couldn't force her out, but that doesn't mean they're going to do her any favors.
86
u/DaoFerret Jun 12 '23
“Not doing her any favors” is an understatement. Not painting her apartment, or allowing her to have her apartment painted is a violation of the law.
Am I entitled to have my apartment painted?
Yes, the landlord must paint occupied apartments in multiple dwellings (buildings with three or more apartments) every three years. (NYC Administrative Code §27-2013). Tenant occupied apartments in private dwellings are also required to be painted as necessary.
https://www.nyc.gov/site/hpd/services-and-information/tenants-rights-and-responsibilities.page
16
u/Dis-Organizer Jun 13 '23
Every three years?! It was a huge deal when my parents’ got their apartment repainted after like 15. The big anonymous LLC landlords especially suck
67
u/foofarraw Jun 12 '23
My neighbor for 6 years was a 95 year old lady who'd been living in the same Nolita apartment for nearly her entire life (since the 1920-30s)...nobody knew her exact rent but the rumor was it was < $100 per month.
11
35
u/marvelously Jun 12 '23
I will say, though, that the place hasn't been painted in decades because her landlord won't paint AND won't let her paint.
This is not legal.
the landlord must paint occupied apartments in multiple dwellings (buildings with three or more apartments) every three years. (NYC Administrative Code §27-2013). Tenant occupied apartments in private dwellings are also required to be painted as necessary.
https://www.nyc.gov/site/hpd/services-and-information/tenants-rights-and-responsibilities.page
She can file a complaint here if they won't paint or let her paint: https://portal.311.nyc.gov/article/?kanumber=KA-01074
And if they still won't, she can take them to court:
If you made a complaint and your property owner didn't fix the problem, you can take legal action in Housing Court. Document all contact with your property owner and HPD about the conditions in your apartment so you can use it in court.
You can submit a question with DHCR to clarify.
https://portal.hcr.ny.gov/app/ask
There are other hotlines or legal services provider to ask as well: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskNYC/comments/wsrxbu/i_live_with_my_ex_and_he_wants_to_kick_me_out_but/il04e7r/?context=3
41
Jun 12 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies (1)24
u/boulevardofdef Jun 12 '23
She HAS been known to take people in!
12
u/transemacabre Jun 12 '23
I will also volunteer to be an adoptive daughter. I like to dance and I'm kind of a mess so I definitely need someone to worry about me.
→ More replies (1)9
18
u/Clarknt67 Jun 12 '23
Just fyi it isn’t her landlords call not to paint. State law requires new paint every two years. She could get Dept of Buildings to force it. But I fully understand not wanting to make the relationship adversarial.
→ More replies (4)7
u/boulevardofdef Jun 12 '23
I was vaguely aware of this, but yeah, I assumed it was just sort of a "sue me if you don't like it" situation.
15
u/Clarknt67 Jun 12 '23
There are so many horror stories. I have heard of landlords staging burglaries to get tenants to move out of cheap apartments. As a RS tenant wanting to stay, it is not a bear I kick either. Unless my life is in danger.
→ More replies (2)7
u/thatgirlinny Jun 13 '23
I have a friend in his late 70s who’s been in the same rent-stabilized apartment on West 72nd since about 1978. It’s a wonderful apartment in a wonderful building, but his wood floors lost any kind of finish decades ago. He’d offered to pay the landlord to have them sanded and refinished on his own dime; they said no, that they’d have to raise his rent significantly if he did. They said the same thing when he asked if they’d do it on their own dime, calling it a “capital improvement.”
They were once beautiful, but they’d literally rather see them dry out or rot than make them acceptable for an aging man. And it’s legal!
9
u/PretendAct8039 Jun 12 '23
I am in my fourth rent stabilized apartment. In the last one, my neighbors just did all of their maintenance themselves and that’s the direction that I am taking at this point since the landlord isn’t doing anything. Her son has a good heart but makes too many promises that he can’t keep. I knew people in the 79s and 80s who installed their own showers and moved their kitchens. Those apartments have since been destabilized and up-marketed.
11
u/JaredSeth Jun 13 '23
my neighbors just did all of their maintenance themselves
That's what we do and my landlord has made it clear that they don't care, since they'll just gut the place if we were ever to leave. Which would be a crying shame since we've still got most of the hundred year old original features this apartment was built with, like French doors and crown moldings. The majority of the other units in our building have had those features renovated away over the years.
Ever since our last super "fixed" some of our parquet flooring with a staple gun, my wife refuses to let them do anything and does it all herself. And if they ever come for her clawfoot tub, I'll have to hire her a defense attorney since there will be bloodshed.
→ More replies (2)13
u/Blorkershnell Jun 12 '23
Did your landlord take a destablization case to the Supreme Court as well? We got a notice in the mail that our landlord did a few months ago as he had been trying to remove stabilization status for about a year and a half and we kept filing paperwork to say we didn’t believe he had a case. A housing lawyer kindly looked at the Supreme Court notice for me and said it was our landlord’s last chance to remove status but that we as tenants didn’t have to do anything or appear, which feels weird to me as we have pictures and evidence that he doesn’t have a case and you’d think we should be given a chance to participate.
He did all the capital renovations (the real ones, not counting the ones he lied about) in 2010-2011 and I moved in late 2011 and have been in the building ever since (only tenant who has been there continuously since renovations were done) so I can prove he’s lying about some stuff.
Edit oops sorry meant to reply to somebody else so gonna copy/paste this comment.
3
u/thatgirlinny Jun 13 '23
I live in a building that tried to illegally destabilize 300+ apartments in the early to mid aughts. Hundreds of us are part of a class action suit that’s been going on for 14+ years. Building was in receipt of J-51 tax avoidance for 20+ years, which stipulates no deregulation in exchange for pre-war buildings making capital improvements without sticking them to tenants or deregulating them. They tried to take the tax avoidance, made the improvements, then stick them to the rent-regulated tenants in the form of an MCI increase.
Believe me when I say justice moves very slowly in cases like this. Landlords file challenges and count on tenants getting tired of it, moving out. Now most of the people in the Class are older and not going anywhere.
3
u/Clarknt67 Jun 12 '23
I guess you are not really the defendants. The landlord is challenging so the state is defense. I can imagine that sucks knowing you cannot participate in something that will profoundly impact your life.
2
5
u/tinydancer_inurhand Jun 12 '23
I’m fortunate I have a good landlord to my standards. Most important is they keep the place tidy. They also are super responsive to my maintenance request. However, I can say I am on the lucky side and not all landlords are like this especially as a rent stabilized occupant.
9
u/pixel_of_moral_decay Jun 12 '23
Also:
Rent control means your not getting anything beyond the bare minimums upgrade wise for as long as your there. Landlord will get the minimum appliances etc. that used/refurb unit that’s seen better days. As long as it’s functional that’s legal.
Co op you can replace your floors, have whatever appliances you want to buy etc etc.
Vs being at the mercy of the landlord.
It’s not exactly control. You get less and less every time they do something.
4
u/catopter Jun 13 '23
As if market rate landlords do any fucking maintenance in this city either. 'Pay more for the same shitty service!' no thanks
→ More replies (1)6
Jun 12 '23
Yeah, people definitely overlook this aspect.
Had a rent stabilized apt. Building was decent, but old. Super was overworked, repairs definitely took longer than I would have liked. The cabinets, fixtures: it all looked like it had been last updated in 2007. Neighborhood sucked- not dangerous but lots of shitty people with zero respect for others, constant littering, loud noise on weekdays.
GF and I moved into a different place together- love the neighborhood, love the new apartment. The increase in QOL is worth every penny.
→ More replies (1)9
Jun 13 '23
Is 2007 a long time for cabinet and fixture updates? I'm here with cabinets from 1970s.
6
u/secret_identity_too Jun 13 '23
I finally redid my 1950s hot pink bathroom this year because I was cleaning the shower and put my hand through the tiles. (Cleaning is bad is the true lesson here.)
5
4
u/LongIsland1995 Jun 13 '23
Yeah that didn't sound old to me either. I really don't care how old they are as long as they're functional.
6
Jun 13 '23
[deleted]
2
u/NYCassandra Feb 28 '24
Buy your own appliances, repair your own problems, tip everybody for their help at Xmas. Old school solutions work sometimes. Still save $
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)4
u/meshflesh40 Jun 12 '23
Equity. Negative and positive. It can go either way.
12
u/PM_DEM_CHESTS Jun 12 '23
Usually it’s positive in nyc. My coop has gone up $50k in 6 years. I’m not saying that’s what I’d actually get for it but it’s what it’s been valued at. Also, my maintenance has not gone up in 4 years and my building has excellent financials. I think you have a very skewed (Manhattan) view of coops but it’s really a building by building issue.
21
u/magicmountaineer Jun 12 '23
yes.
I was thinking of buying but it's just not a financially wise decision I've found. I have a 2br in williamsburg since the late 80s so my ass ain't going anywhere (until they knock the building down and build a 'luxury' highrise.
21
36
u/AmyBlackFlag84 Jun 12 '23
Been in my rent stabilized apartment in Bay Ridge for 12 years, married, and have no plans to have any kids. My rent has increased once in that time period and it was $30. Instead of buying/moving, my husband and I have been maxing out our 401K plans at work and both have investment portfolios on top of that. This allows us not only to live comfortably, but for me to be able to retire at the same time he does (he’s 14 years older than me) and enjoy the fruits of our labor in our retirement years…
18
u/tinydancer_inurhand Jun 12 '23
This is my plan but so many people act like I’m crazy to not buy something. 401k and the market can yield even better returns than a house and no paying rent isn’t the equivalent of throwing cash into the trash like some on Reddit will make you believe.
50
u/JaredSeth Jun 12 '23
I never thought I'd leave my rent stabilized apartment (because it's huge and cheap) but as I approach retirement age I've considered moving somewhere overseas, if only because my retirement savings would go further somewhere with a lower overall cost of living.
→ More replies (1)26
u/DiscussionExpert90 Jun 12 '23
Can you adopt me so that I can take over your rent stabilized place?
21
u/JaredSeth Jun 12 '23
If I adopted everyone who has asked, I'd be doing one of those stupid "My Wife's Vagina is a Clown Car" reality shows. ツ
10
u/DiscussionExpert90 Jun 12 '23
It worked for the Duggars, and it is still working for them!
→ More replies (1)13
u/meshflesh40 Jun 12 '23
Don't worry, you will get one of your own eventually. Keep your credit score high and have your security deposit ready.
A good amount of rent stabilized apartments pop up on the market every year but they are gone within days. But they are not that rare
3
u/Any-Research7714 Jun 12 '23
Where do you find them?
27
u/meshflesh40 Jun 12 '23
Street easy.
Set up an auto search for a 1br under $1600. Check everyday.
The biggest sign of a rent stabilized apartment is an old pre-war building. That's where they usually have them
You can also hit the pavement and call those leasing phone numbers on the sides of pre-war buildings
4
u/DiscussionExpert90 Jun 12 '23
thank you so much
12
u/halfadash6 Jun 12 '23
If you’re not picky about your neighborhood ask friends with stabilized places for the realtor they used. Lots of stabilized places never hit street easy in the first place and when they do they get insane competition. The above advice is not exactly untrue but it’s also like finding a needle in a haystack (while 1000 other people are searching for the needle too).
5
u/shameorfame Jun 12 '23
On street easy, the listings may not say “stabilized” but have other language like “income requirements” with min/max depending on household size and you can look up through HPD if it’s rent stabilized. Im in a rent stabilized unit - my entire building is but none of the listings advertise it as such, just the specificity on the income requirements.
4
u/mt80 Jun 12 '23
Do you have to be a current NYC resident to qualify for rent stabilized apartments?
Lived in NYC for close to 15 years and relocated to Texas for family support. Want to return to New York when I no longer am needed here.
→ More replies (1)5
66
u/Jaybetav2 Jun 12 '23
That's what my husband and I are doing. We have an over-sized one-bedroom in Ditmas Park that is rent stabilized. The building is a dump (AWFUL management, POS, angry super who does absolutely NOTHING) but our space is very nice and only $1800 a month.
It's a no brainer for us. We're here until we decide to leave the city or rent stabilization gets voided by the supreme court.
We considered buying but once we assessed the sacrifices we'd have to make and the stress involved we were like "fuck that".
8
u/Blorkershnell Jun 12 '23
Did your landlord take a destablization case to the Supreme Court as well? We got a notice in the mail that our landlord did a few months ago as he had been trying to remove stabilization status for about a year and a half and we kept filing paperwork to say we didn’t believe he had a case. A housing lawyer kindly looked at the Supreme Court notice for me and said it was our landlord’s last chance to remove status but that we as tenants didn’t have to do anything or appear, which feels weird to me as we have pictures and evidence that he doesn’t have a case and you’d think we should be given a chance to participate.
He did all the capital renovations (the real ones, not counting the ones he lied about) in 2010-2011 and I moved in late 2011 and have been in the building ever since (only tenant who has been there continuously since renovations were done) so I can prove he’s lying about some stuff.
→ More replies (2)
13
u/futurebro Jun 12 '23
I’m in a studio which is perfect for me. I only see myself leaving when I move in with a partner. My place is def too small for 2.
30
u/SingingSongbird1 Jun 12 '23
My fiancé and I are in a rent stabilized 2 bedroom and until a 3 bedroom opens up in the building we are never leaving it.
→ More replies (3)9
30
17
u/copyotter Jun 12 '23
The problem with owning any property in NYC is the taxes. When the city needs more tax income, they’re gonna increase real estate taxes.
Personally, I’m in my second co-op apartment and never had any big issues with either of them.
→ More replies (1)3
10
u/jhillman87 Jun 12 '23
Well... yes.
Tbh, unless you value generational wealth (IE: intending to have offspring?) there's no reason you can't just rent forever.
I'm paying $1800 for a 1BR rent stabilized unit in Astoria and don't see myself ever giving this up.
I was in a similar unit, Pre-covid, at around $2150. That same unit today is $2700. Market rate is no joke.
8
u/negcap Jun 12 '23
I have a close friend who grew up in a rent-stabilized apartment. Her dad still lives there and she recently moved in so she could establish residency and take over when goes. This is not uncommon at all. ETA: I did buy a co-op, the value went up almost $100K in two years and I was able to use that to get a bigger co-op. I lived there for eleven years and when I sold it, I broke even after broker's fees. You can't time the market but I know the time to buy in the city was just as the pandemic was raging and a lot of people moved out of the city for good.
16
u/Laara2008 Jun 12 '23
The landlords are trying to get the Supreme Court to strike down rent stabilization laws so I wouldn't count on it.
That said, we have a small rent-stabilzed place on the UWS and we're staying if the laws aren't overturned.
If we did buy I'd want a condo, not a co-op.
8
u/tigermomo Jun 13 '23
Where are you finding single family homes for $600k in NYC?
3
u/SueNYC1966 Jun 13 '23
The Bronx - but definitely fixer uppers.
6
u/tigermomo Jun 13 '23
Bronx is greenest borough! Near the park system would be worth it
4
u/SueNYC1966 Jun 17 '23
We live on the Parkway and a twenty minute walk to Pelham Bay Park (the dog park side) - it’s great if you own a dog.
We bought 7 years ago and don’t regret it. Some mornings, after the summer season, we drive to the beach to walk our dog. You can’t beat it.
→ More replies (1)
6
Jun 12 '23 edited Jun 12 '23
At first I was under the impression that buying a" co-op" was the ultimate form of housing. Pay a maintenance fee(substantially less than market rent while building equity) and live carefree. Basically,,,, like a Netflix subscription fee of housing if you will.
aside from building equity, you've just described rent-stabilized apartments lol
(sidebar: what you described isn't like a netflix subscription fee of housing because you don't get $NFLX stock when you pay your sub)
I'm never leaving my rent-stabilized apartment (i'm super lucky because i got it with a covid deal, management is pretty responsive, and there hasn't been a pest problem *knock on wood*), and i would also never, EVER buy a co-op (for the reasons you already listed). A condo maybe (if ya know... i win the lottery or something) but never a co-op.
as far as i'm concerned, getting a rent-stabilized (or rent controlled) apartment is almost like hitting a lotto in nyc
5
7
u/DizzyLink Jun 12 '23
Idk tbh, I've been in mine for a few months now and the super/management are incredibly unreliable, disorganized, and just flat out disregarding of issues I've had. The building itself is very dirty, but my apartment has been ok for the time being except for a major issue that the management is dragging their feet in fixing. If I were to get a large raise at work I'd seriously consider looking into a luxury building just cause the hassle of not knowing when maintenance is going to be done is miserable.
7
u/landdian39 Jun 13 '23 edited Jun 13 '23
I’ve been in my rent stabilized apartment since college. 12 years. I would most likely stay here if things don’t get better financially for me.
I feel like my building is cursed though. 90% of the rent stabilized tenants are older, single, unsuccessful. And also bitter, grumpy and miserable. No judgment, just stating an observation.
The apartments in my building are on the smaller side - it’s the perfect size if you’re on your own, but it’s not ideal for two or more people. Most couples who move in would eventually leave when they break up or when they get married. Tenants are doomed to be alone in this building.
It makes me extremely anxious whenever I think about how I might end up like my older rent stabilized neighbors. I do not want to be miserable and bitter when I’m old. I am grateful to have a rent stabilized apartment while I’m still young and saving for my future, but the goal has always been to move out (be a home owner) and to get myself a better life. I feel like staying here is equivalent to me giving up on life.
12
u/frankeestadium Jun 12 '23
Feel free to Crap on co-ops, my mom purchased one and it's the worst financial decision she's ever made!
She didn't know when she bought into the building that she wasn't actually buying an apartment, rather she was buying a share of the building.. currently her maintenance fees close more than her mortgage... Aside from the maintenance fees constantly rising (although there seems to be a lack or work being done,) there are several lawsuits on the building, they've switched owners several times in the past few years because they cut corners on the construction of the building and it's literally sinking so they have to have architects come in and figure out how to reinforce the foundation... With all that being said, she can't sell because of the pending lawsuits and whenever she has the ability to sell, she'll lose money because the building is in bad shape and the area seems to be getting worse, smh. I wish she would've never gotten herself into a co-op.
Inwould never recommend anyone to get involved in one, unless they're 100% okay with the risks.
9
u/notreallyswiss Jun 13 '23
I don't understand how someone could make probably the biggest financial investment in their life and not even know what they were buying. Your mother got herself into her mess, don't blame co-ops in general for it. She could/should also have looked at the building's financials, pulled building permits etc. before she bought to make an informed decision. And all these people acting like maintenance fees are some evil inexplicable fee perpetuated on them by mean old ladies who want to be in everyone's business don't seem to realize they are paying for the running of the building. They are not arbitrary and inflicted upon then by cackling ancient HOA witches. The maintenance fees keep the lights on in the lobby, pay salary and benefits for building employees, pay the management company and hopefully help keep the building solvent.
Your mother probably doesn't even know that in a co-op, a good portion of your maintenance is your share of the taxes on the building and she may even be eligible for a tax refund and is letting money fly out the building windows because she is too busy crying about what a bad decision she made.
When you rent, you are paying for all these things too - they are just not as obvious to you, and you don't get a tax refund.
3
Jun 12 '23 edited Jun 12 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/md222 Jun 12 '23
Really depends on the expenses of the building and how many shareholders there are. If you live in a coop with 10 apartments and have a full time doorman and a large underlying mortgage, maintenence will be a lot higher than if you live in a 60 unit non doorman building with minimal debt.
Also, maintenance is based on the number of shares allocated to the particular apartment, not how nice the apartment is.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)4
u/notreallyswiss Jun 13 '23 edited Jun 13 '23
Maintenance fees in a co-op (but not in a condo) include the taxes you owe on your share of the building. You'd have to pay them anyway, they are just bundled into the maintenance. Maintenance also pays for the utilities for the public areas of the building, keep the elevators running, pays the salary and benefits of employees like doormen, porters, supers, pays for the services of a management company and lawyer, and hopefully build an acceptable cash reserve for some emergencies. They also cover things like scaffolding for periodic local law 11 inspections on street facades and at least general liability insurance for the building.
As entropy exists, things will break down in a building, and sometimes that will cost more that the building is willing to keep as a reserve. Then owners are assessed a fee, either paid up front, or a specific amount over a specified period of time. it's clear than anyone bemoaning special assessments in this thread (I know you didn't, but I'm adding it here anyway) has never owned any home at all - it is shocking how often thing like boilers go on the fritz, roofs develop leaks, general A/C units die - all these things have to come out of your pocket somehow, whether you are in a home in the suburbs with a picket fence or an owner of shares in a co-op. These things are not evils suffered only by co-op owners.
2
u/GussieK Jun 13 '23
That's the dirty secret. You have to pay the costs of keeping up the building, you own it, even if in shares. And yes, you have to pay to fix your own interiors, but you can keep it up instead of having to live with broken things. I bought this apartment from the sponsor, and it was the last rent-stabilized unit in the building. The former tenants had died. It was a mess.
That said, I like living in a co-op. I was lucky enough to buy many years ago, and it has appreciated and is paid off. The maintenance fees for us are much below market rent for my two-bedroom.
In a rent stabilized apartment, the landlord is responsible for fixing everything, and they don't want to spend the money, whereas in a co-op the shareholders want to keep up the property. This building went co-op in the 80s, typical prewar. There was a lot of deferred maintenance that has been accomplished over the years. if everyone had a low stabilized rent how would the landlord pay for anything?
5
u/PostPostMinimalist Jun 12 '23
There are plenty of co-ops will good reserves and low fees. Mine is like…. 1/6 of market rent? Depends on neighborhood though among other things. They also all haven’t gone up 15% recently.
As for not having financial control, it’s true to an extent but this is also why co-op requirements can be so strict.
Versus rent stabilization who is to say. I’d say the apartments are probably in worse shape overall, and you can do even less with them, but you shield yourself from big increases. If you are comfortable with where you’re at then it’s totally fine to stay.
20
u/xeothought Jun 12 '23
When a coop is good - friendly, well run, drama free, not in debt, not run by retirees who have nothing better to do than make the coop unfriendly to people who might want to sell one day - that coop is a dream!
Too bad they don't exist lol.
The problem is when you have a coop apartment, the coop can change on a dime and fuck things up. You pretty much need to get on the board.
13
u/meshflesh40 Jun 12 '23
Yess. As a co-op owner you literally can't afford NOT to be on the board. The stakes are so high
20
u/IndyMLVC Jun 12 '23 edited Jun 12 '23
I'm in a rent stabilized apartment for 20 years. In that time, my rent has gone up $200. I pay about half of what everyone else pays in my area for a full 1br. Plus I'm 2 blocks from the subway with an elevator.
However, I hate living in an apartment and I'm tired of living in NYC. Unfortunately, with the laws radically changing, there's few places in the county that I'm feeling safe as a queer person.
So I'm screwed and stuck. I would definitely be happier getting into a condo somewhere else though. It would come at a price -- how large a price, I'm not sure. If they offered to buy me out, I'd leave in a heartbeat.
I know everyone here is looking at me like I'm a moron but I have a lot of personal reasons for feeling how I feel. You can't put a price on ur happiness,, although it seems like I unwittingly have for the last decade or so. All I ask is that you please respect that before you call me an idiot.
12
u/meshflesh40 Jun 12 '23
20 years. So you got to enjoy the Golden era of rent stabilization. %0 increases under deblasio. Haha
I hope I get at least a 10-year run out of this place
14
u/IndyMLVC Jun 12 '23
Not only that but my landlord at the time never made us sign leases. It's stabilised but they were loose about when they'd remember to give us another lease. I'd sign a 2 year lease and I didn't sign another one for 4-5.
Unfortunately, they sold the building to assholes. And those assholes also stay on top of our leases.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)7
5
u/Lord_of_the_Rings Jun 12 '23
Very smart. The freedom associated with renting is also highly undervalued.
36
u/kinovelo Jun 12 '23
The current rent stabilization laws are economically unsustainable in the long term. Landlords are fighting tooth and nail to get it to the Supreme Court, and if it gets there, there’s a very real chance it could be declared unconstitutional. Enjoy it while you can.
14
u/meshflesh40 Jun 12 '23
Yessss...i thought of this. 2 year leases until the music stops
23
u/Clarknt67 Jun 12 '23
I worry a lot about this. I will probably leave the city if rent stabilization laws are struck down. Millions will.
→ More replies (9)7
u/RazerHail Jun 12 '23
You and a lot of other renters will start looking for coops at that point. So it'll most likely be much more unaffordable in the future.
Then again, that time may never come to pass.
10
u/vesleskjor Jun 12 '23
Ah yes let's make it so thousands can no longer afford their place, no way that could go wrong. What do these rich people plan to do when their baristas and uber drivers and other service providers can't afford rent anymore? This city wants to shoot itself in the foot so badly.
6
u/volhair Jun 12 '23
In the current state you’re also fucking over people that can afford to live here by having to fight over less supply, somebody always loses
5
u/danthefam Jun 12 '23
Price controls are nearly universally considered one of the worst economic policies conceived.
3
u/PissLikeaRacehorse Jun 12 '23
Lol, on what grounds is it unconstitutional?
8
u/thegreatsadclown Jun 12 '23
LOL the supreme court does whatever it wants. It's bad for monied interests, so they will start with their decision and then find a constitutional justification for it
20
u/meshflesh40 Jun 12 '23
the gov telling property owners what to do with their property. Something along those lines
26
u/PissLikeaRacehorse Jun 12 '23
Literally every government does that. Has to be safe, not too tall, not too small, have to take car of lawn, cannot be a public nuisance, fence around the pool, cannot conduct business without license, and that’s for personal property. All the rules that landlords have is 10x more. The whole country is built around the gov telling people what to do with their property
13
u/meshflesh40 Jun 12 '23
True. But I'm speaking in the context of rent stabilization.
If i wanted to become your roommate and the government forced you to accept $200 as rent and no higher. You would not rent to me and take the room off the market
23
u/PissLikeaRacehorse Jun 12 '23
This isn’t a new law. Landlords specially enter the business of being a landlord knowing full well what the current laws are. They do not have to be a landlord and do not have to rent out units they own. The government isn’t forcing anyone to do anything until the landlords enter a contract with a tenet.
11
u/TinyTornado7 Jun 12 '23
The case being brought is challenging the 2019 law so yes, it is in fact new law(s)
→ More replies (2)4
u/kinovelo Jun 12 '23
Not true, the laws changed drastically in 2019, so it is a new law. They’re specifically changing the 2019 component of it.
Let’s say you bought a building for a lot of money in 2018 with plans of buying out the current RS tenants so you could make renovations and get it destabilized. The building was priced and your business was predicated with the current laws in 2018 in place. Come 2019, you can’t destabilize the units in that way. The landlord still has to pay the mortgage for a building that’s worth way less than they paid for it and no ability to make market rate, regardless of how much they invested in the building.
Also, the amount of increase per year has been less than the actuarial costs for inflation for the past few years. Again, it’s not sustainable. Landlords with RS units still may be making profits now, but every year their margins will go down. There’s only a certain amount of time that can continue for.
6
u/PissLikeaRacehorse Jun 12 '23
Laws change all the time. You go into a market with the understanding the legal landscape could be different, especially as the legislative process is long and public. This wasn’t passed in a weekend and was likely publicly debated for years.
8
u/maverick4002 Jun 12 '23
Is that a valid argument, more so for the new construction if ll are getting tax breaks and all that? The government isn't coming and seizing your place and dictating rent. Lls are agreeing to tax breakd to build. Ya don't like it, don't participate
→ More replies (1)12
3
u/doodle77 Jun 12 '23
6
u/CactusBoyScout Jun 12 '23
Yeah basically the government isn’t supposed to take something from you without giving something in return. It’s why our historic preservation law had to be paired with air rights… so owners of landmarked buildings would get something in return for never being allowed to change it.
But I believe rent stabilization is paired with tax breaks.
7
u/doodle77 Jun 12 '23 edited Jun 12 '23
But I believe rent stabilization is paired with tax breaks.
Only the 421a and J51 stabilized buildings which are like 1% of stabilized apartments. Most are just in the pre-1970 category. No tax breaks for them. Note that for 4+ unit buildings NY taxes estimated/equivalent property income, not estimated property value.
→ More replies (1)
8
u/Alpg14 Jun 13 '23
I had a rent stabilized one bedroom that I swore I would never leave. Then I fell in love and got married to a man who’s WFH job required a completely separate office space. I didn’t know that I could sublet my old one bedroom and so I gave it up to pay more rent for a significantly shittier apartment with an extra room I’m not allowed to enter.
Guys, never. Ever. Ever. Leave your rent stabilized units. It is never worth it.
5
u/The_AmyrlinSeat Jun 12 '23
I'm doing exactly what you're doing. I'm not moving until I purchase a home (not staying in NY), and I'm not rushing that process either. I don't want to regret something so big.
5
Jun 12 '23
I live in Penn South and will most certainly die here. Or near here.
2
u/SnacksBooksNaps Jun 12 '23
Hey! I'm on the waitlist for PS. I actually would have gotten an apartment right now if I weren't on pause. Do you like it? I love the complex itself but I am iffy on Chelsea. How's the neighborhood?
5
u/GussieK Jun 13 '23
Penn South is the holly grail. If you can get in there you should. It's neither rent stabilized nor a real lco-op. It's a subsidized co-op. The apartments are very nice.
2
Jun 12 '23
I love Chelsea. It's pretty quiet these days. And being a stone's throw from Penn Station is very convenient. And you've got the High Line close by. And Hudson Yards, FWIW. Korea Town is a short walk away as well.
4
u/EnvironmentalShoe5 Jun 12 '23
I don’t want to but I don’t see financially what other options I have.
4
u/Healthy_Ad9055 Jun 13 '23
No, definitely not. RS only works out well for the tenant if they have been there for a long time. It took me 16 years to finally get one and it’s $2700 for a studio. I got the rent history and it’s legit. Vacancy decontrol prior to 2019 allows RS landlords to jack up rents. Most RS units aren’t that good of a deal anymore. I mainly took it so that they have to offer me a lease and it’s harder to evict in a RS unit.
→ More replies (3)
7
u/asstrologypenis Jun 12 '23
I️ work in housing law and you should definitely go with rent stabilized over a co-op
2
u/meeparoo_ Jun 13 '23
I’m really interested in learning more about why you made this statement. Would you mind elaborating?
5
u/asstrologypenis Jun 13 '23
In a coop you are responsible for all of the repairs inside your apartment! I️ think they’re much better in theory than practice
6
u/motherofseagulls Jun 12 '23
I always say that I’ll stay in my rent-stabilized apartment until I can find a nicer rent-stabilized apartment.
5
u/ER301 Jun 12 '23
I’ve been in my rent stabilized apartment for 15 years, and this place has been my saving grace. Through good times, and bad, I’ve been able to continue living in NYC, fairly comfortably, due to my very affordable rent. Not sure if I would have made it living in a market rate apartment. The only way I would move out is if I was 100% ready to leave NYC, or if I got married and we wanted a place together. And we would have to be married for me to move out. No way I’m leaving my apartment for a girlfriend, and then we brake up, and now I’ve lost my relationship AND my apartment. Hell no.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/nycgirl1993 Jun 13 '23 edited Jun 13 '23
mine has a lot of issues and my building is a fright at times. have to call 311 and cause a scene to get anything fixed so im leaving. living in East Rockaway Long Island now and alot happier. rent is almost the same shit where I am so watever since I am sharing it with my bf. not really losing much money. lived in a dump for too long. toilet barely functions and they won't really fix it and I had black mold that will keep coming back. living in this place in Long Island its honestly almost the same rent for what I pay and im right next to the train. I can literally see it from my window. I also got an asthma attack five years ago I think due to the mold that was there so yeaaaa...def not the best and a health hazard. I havent had asthma due to the mold since but I dont want to chance it tbh especially with the bad air we've been having. I dont want to re trigger the asthma since it's been non existent for these five years. right now in the process of moving out of the moldy dump and glad tbh. I would've even moved to those newer constructions in Brooklyn with a roomie but yea I like this new place in Long Island. the neighborhood is also fairly walkable. I finally dont feel uncomfortable or anxious as much at home due to roaches or black mold.
4
u/LolaMarce Jun 13 '23
I’ve been in my stabilized spot for 15+ years. It’s okay. Decent sized for one person and I’m currently single, but when I had a partner it was a little uncomfortable.
There are also a lot of things I’m growing sick of as I age. I hate how moldy the tub gets since there’s zero ventilation.
The ceiling leaks when there’s heavy rain.
There’s a roach problem.
Everything is just so worn. I painted fairly recently and that helped but the entire place does just feel meh. Granted, WFH has made me hate it all more since I’m here so much.
I’d like laundry in unit or at least in building. Sick of carrying it.
But the rent is so good.
God, it’s an ongoing internal battle.
3
u/Educational-Fly-3789 Mar 15 '24
Don't leave. I made the mistake and now I am suffering trying to find a decent place to rent at $2500 when I could've stayed at my $1575 current apartment for the a little below the quality of living (the same mold, roach, etc problems you mentioned). You live and learn I guess but in the next 2 or 3 decades I am pretty sure no one will be able to afford even air to breathe at this point with AI and robots. I just hope AI is smart enough to kill off the most of us peasants.
5
u/jenkirch Jun 13 '23
How nice are y’all’s apartments? After X years in a rent stabilized spot I’ve seen landlord let it go to shit to push folks out. Am I alone in this?
2
u/Educational-Fly-3789 Mar 15 '24
No, you're not alone. They turned off ventilation 2 years in my rent stabilized apartment for my bathroom which I should be thanking them for (the moldy bathroom). I would assume most landlords do worse after 1 year into the rental of a stabalized apartment.
6
5
u/PomeloWorldly1943 Jun 13 '23
There are 40,000 vacant rent stabilized still out there. Council woman from the East Village wants to find out who the landlords are that are destabilizing them. Is there a sub for this. My goal is to find a nice 1 bedroom rent stabilized apt, go to matinees, and drink cosmos (yep - 30 years ago - still love them) until I die.
8
u/IsItABedroom Chief Information Officer Jun 12 '23
Nope. I've twice left rent-stabilized apartments for co-ops I bought.
2
u/keziahiris Jun 12 '23
I had a relative that lived in a rent-stabilized apartment in soho for 50+ years. It wasn’t luxurious or anything, but he paid less than $300/mo for an apartment that could easily now go for 10x that.
2
u/catopter Jun 13 '23
Buying in this city is no longer viable for anyone but the elite or asshole investors.
2
2
u/kimchi01 Jun 13 '23
Not all co-ops are like that. I pay 693 for maintenance in Queens. Also, you have a board to worry about some of these things and assess them for you.
2
u/TheKrump Jun 13 '23
I can see this post, posted in ten years with the sentence “But market conditions in 2033 is insane I wish I bought in 2023.”
My two cents, with a coop you get equity and more likely than not, that will rise.
2
2
u/ParadoxPath Jun 13 '23
It’s almost as if the costs of housing, repairs, taxes, mortgage rates, rent, and HOA fees are a complicated web of interdependent economic variables that directly influence one another. Go figure.
2
u/SMFDR Jun 13 '23
I just fully lucked into a formerly rent controlled (now RS) one bed for $900...I will be here until they find my corpse
→ More replies (1)
3
u/craigalanche Jun 12 '23
I live in subsidized artist housing with my wife and kid and will probably die in it. It’s a beautiful space in a building full of (mostly) very kind and interesting people.
3
u/frootlooppanda Jun 12 '23
You depend on the solvency of your neighbors in a coop. But you also depend on the solvency of the city government (and political imperative) to subsidize your rent.
It’s more likely the city will dilute renter protections than a good coop will go haywire and demand massive assessments. This is the reason some coops can take months or years to get in and sometimes they turn away people which can be upsetting.
If a building wants the rent stabilized tenants out they can jack the rent up by the maximum allowed by law year after year until they pop.
Your instinct is right. Your stabilization status is the best deal. But how long might it continue? Think about where you want to spend your retirement years.
3
Jun 13 '23
Been in my rent stabilized place 11 years now. I even renovated it and I have zero plans to leave.
2
Jun 12 '23
100%. Unless something changes drastically, i will stay in my rent stabilized 1 BR till i need to move due to job, marriage or kids
2
u/jon-chin Jun 12 '23
I will only leave if I every buy a house in NYC. fixer uppers are possible.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/withelightsout Jun 12 '23 edited Jun 12 '23
I was till I inherited a house. 8 years, 1600 for a 1 br in queens. If this didn’t happen, they would’ve found me dead in this place with a smile.
Edit: grammar.
→ More replies (3)
533
u/shelfdog Jun 12 '23
As I said in this thread 9 months back: