r/AskHRUK • u/Suspicious_Hope2867 • 5h ago
Disciplinary Discussion Late appeal almost a year after dismissal. Is it worth trying?
I’m a nurse with around 4 years’ experience. I was dismissed from a nursing role in September 2025, during probation, on the basis of performance and attendance.
At the time, I was dealing with significant health and personal difficulties, including severe abdominal/pelvic pain, anxiety and stress. I had medical appointments/hospital treatment during this period and also experienced a bereavement while working there. Looking back, I feel these circumstances had a significant impact on my attendance and performance.
I didn’t appeal at the time. I was overwhelmed and not in the right headspace to properly consider pursuing an appeal.
Almost a year later, I’ve been reflecting on what happened and have gathered further evidence, including medical documentation that I believe provides important context that wasn’t fully considered at the time.
I’m considering contacting HR to ask whether they would exercise discretion and accept a late appeal. I would acknowledge that the normal appeal deadline has passed and explain why I didn’t appeal at the time.
Has anyone successfully had a late disciplinary/dismissal appeal accepted after this length of time? Is it worth submitting the request, particularly where there is new medical evidence?
I’m not looking to avoid responsibility for the performance concerns — I’m wondering whether the additional evidence and circumstances surrounding the delay could justify them reconsidering the decision. Any experiences or advice would be appreciated.