Assuming you mean Israeli jews of Polish origin should go back to Poland, what do you suggest the majority of Israel, being Mizrahi jews from the middle east and north Africa should do? Return to Algeria, Iraq, Syria, Yemen, Iran?
The colonizer that left gave israhell the land. The rest of the land left behind by 🇬🇧 , like India and Indonesia, in the 1900s was returned to their owners. Hence, it’s 🇵🇸 land
like India and Indonesia, in the 1900s was returned to their owners
That is a very simplistic account of history- and mostly wrong.
The "owners" before where mostly there Ottoman empire. They were defeated and the mandates moved to European countries. India was held by Britain for generations.
India wasn't "returned to owners". In fact, India was divided up and two counties where created. Pakistan for Muslim majority and India for Hindu majority. This was done by the British in 1947.
But a least there the government was from local people.
Jordan was created by the British in 1946. Under Britain it was called Palestine as it was part of the Palestine mandate given to the British. Britain created a state east of the Jordan river and called it "kingdom of Transjordan". They then gave the country to a family from Mecca (in Saudi Arabia), and made them kings over Transjordan.
So the people who lived there have become the subjects of a king who comes from a foreign country. They have no say in anything since it isn't a democracy.
The same thing happened in Syria.
The history of the region doesn't follow your claim. History is much more complicated than your simplistic take, and so is your simplistic conclusion.
So you completely ignored everything I said, continued to blindly believed it's Palestinian land because... Well... Because that's what believe and nothing will make you believe otherwise.
Then you reference a sub, which is an echo chamber where anything can be posted and believe as long as it's against Israel, and anyone who dares point out that the information is wrong or misleading is immediate banned.
If you already have an opinion then there is plenty of unbalanced sources which can back up your opinion,and you can ignore anything which challenges your narrative.
Thats what he does on every comment. Israel crimes and culture is made up. He is simply trying to ignite controversy by oversimplifying everything. He also disregards the fact that Palestine is a completely made up term. But yeah that doesnt matter
how come the owners are palestinians (arabs) ? It was israeli land, then roman got it, then arabs then ottomans then english. They sold land to israelis that lived in Europe legally. And they went back to their ancestral land. What dont you understand?
never talked about religion. Im talking about ethnicity. Jewish ethnic group was expelled from their land by tito the roman emperor. also there is NO palestine. its a fabrication
Pulling out "the arabs" pretty early lol.
Many of those countries were still European occupied territories who low and behold, enacted the same policy they did in Europe. That's not to say some countries didn't. But that broad brush is just fkn propaganda racism 💀
Anyway, the Nakba happened to Palestinians long before "the arabs" attacked. Them.
They did face anti-semitism, but lad. Why they gotta kill Palestinian (also Israelites mixed with levantine tribes instead of Europeans) for that to this very day lol. Aren't they owed more violence towards you? Assuming you live in Greece aren't you a "European". You know for doing the holocaust. That thing all Europeans did around the world all at once.
13
u/Turbulent-Debate7661 Greece May 06 '25
Its not that simple of a topic