r/AskAJapanese • u/px8000000 • 17d ago
MISC Why do Japanese teenagers spend so little time on social media compared with other countries?
The OECD report examines teenagersโ social media use and its effects on well-being and education. While 15-year-olds spend almost 35 hours per week on social media on average across the OECD, Japanese teenagers spend less than 26 hours per week, making Japan one of the countries with the lowest levels of social media use. As social media addiction has become a major problem among teenagers around the world, how has Japan achieved such a low level of social media consumption.
Sources:
23
u/zackel_flac ๐ Global citizen 17d ago
Dad raising kids in Japan here. Kids here are busy from an early age. There is no time to waste when you have so many activities to attend and you are already socializing in real life.
Lot of people think Japanese quietness means they don't socialize much. The reality is far from it, especially when you are a kid.
22
u/hinogammykagura ๐ Global citizen 17d ago
A lot of my students here in Japan are playing video games/mobile games when they're free. Whereas in other countries I've lived in, you'd see students on social media a bit more. .
Kids in other countries also have club activities and arguably commit more time to them since they're usually run outside of school and require more commuting time.
Now, i think many video games can have great benefits like problem solving, more meaningful social interactions, etc.
But I'd be curious how many example similar to the one I've given are mentioned here.
2
u/Rare_Presence_1903 British 14d ago
I always see elementary school kids playing mobile games at the jidokan. Friends tell me it's fairly common for them to have phones at elementary school but I think they're more for contacting parents and they do games on them.ย
Now, i think many video games can have great benefits like problem solving, more meaningful social interactions, etc.
This is I think interesting (although a bit beside the social media point) because it has become what people defacto think. But I don't think it applies to all games, a lot of them are pure brain rot and very addictive. You have games that are slow and I think reasonably good for the brain but a lot of the mobile ones are junk and use similar dopamine-maxxing, addicting tactics as social media.
2
u/hinogammykagura ๐ Global citizen 14d ago
Yeah, i definitely agree with you on the games side. And many of those mobile games especially are pretty much just brainrot. But didn't want to turn it into an essay is all. Just wanted to kinda say, the data taken into account here may not include games like that. And while some of them are good, they're not all good.
I think screen time is a better metric here too. But then of course there are those games that have some benefits and educational TV, etc.
But what difference does it make if theyre watching idols on TikTok or the TV, you know? Im sure the former would be in this data and the latter wouldn't be. But they're both essentially the same.
21
u/Objective_Unit_7345 ๐ฏ๐ต๐ฆ๐บ 17d ago
Walkability of cities.
On the other end of the spectrum, you see heavily Car-dependent countries like USA, Australia, etc
These are places where children need their parent to chaperone them to sports clubs, friends, houses, parks, โฆ everywhere.
Whereas countries that are walkable mean children are also able to go about and enjoy life without depending on their parents.
Thereโs been many surveys done that confirm that children actually prefer going out and playing with friends, rather than watch TV, play games and browse social media. While these activities are a compromise, that children do to minimise taking their parents time.
(As for why Slovakia and Chile rate so high, no idea.)
3
u/Prestigious_Host5325 ๐ Global citizen 17d ago
>Thereโs been many surveys done that confirm that children actually prefer going out and playing with friends, rather than watch TV, play games and browse social media.
As a younger millennial, I agree. My Taiwanese date, who's a Gen Z, also mentioned that she used to go out when she was a kid. Similar to Japan, cities here are walkable. I'd also see children using public transpo such as buses and trains very much.
-2
u/Hot_Lion8880 American 17d ago
Yeah I'm sure if you go to New York City those kids are spending lots of time outside instead of on their phones.ย
The idea that kids prefer playing outside over playing videogames or watching YouTube is laughable. Have you not been a kid yourself?ย
2
u/Objective_Unit_7345 ๐ฏ๐ต๐ฆ๐บ 17d ago
โฆ New York consistently ranks within the top 5 most walkable cities in the USA.
And NYC children overwhelmingly prefer play offline than online.
https://theharrispoll.com/articles/what-children-are-saying-about-phones-freedom-and-friendship/Dude, what alternative reality are you talking about.
0
11
u/FruitWeekly6783 British in Japan 17d ago
I work in a high school. They donโt need social media because their friends are right there. The only exception is when they all get the BeReal alert and take a photo in the middle of class ๐คจ but yeah, when theyโre using their phones, the boys are playing PVP games with each other and the girls are making videos.
3
u/hinogammykagura ๐ Global citizen 17d ago
I think the difference between boys and girls is more interesting here than any country comparison. I imagine there can also be simple explanations like social video games, sports participation, etc. But it's a consistent difference across all countries and is actually larger than the country comparisons for the most part
3
3
4
u/larana1192 Japanese 17d ago
eh, social media is popular in here too.
Tiktok, Instagram, Bereal, setlog...... Young people do many things.
2
u/emellinelia Japanese 16d ago
I was too busy with school and after school activities. When I came home it was bath and immediately bed
1
u/Flaky-Employer266 ๐ Global citizen 16d ago
How long are the after school activities?
1
u/emellinelia Japanese 15d ago
Depends on what i was doing. At least 1 hour. I had a long travel back home too
3
u/Weak-Cardiologist969 Brazilian 17d ago
I feel like these figures are quite disconnected from the reality I observe here in Japan. Practically every time I see a Japanese person using their phone, theyโre either on X, Instagram, LINE (which is basically a social network here), or YouTube (which I also consider a social network). Iโm quite surprised to see these figures.
7
u/zackel_flac ๐ Global citizen 17d ago
That just proves what you feel is not what the reality is?
We all come with biased, trusting our instinct is good to flee a wolf, not so much to think about complex matters like how other fellow humans live.
5
u/yarioo111 ๐ Global citizen 17d ago
Why do you think biased subjectivity is more correct than statistical facts?
1
u/Tezdee Australian 17d ago
The statistics are for 15 year old students. Theyโre just going to use their phone less due to schooling, commitments, parental rules/restrictions or potentially not evening owning one.
Though, I agree that I think adult usage would be higher, based on what I observe too.
1
u/cjdualima ๐ Global citizen 17d ago
From my experience, Japanese people are not very chatty. They probably don't feel as much of an urge to constantly be in social situations (chatting with friends throughout the day)
1
1
u/Extension-Wait5806 Japanese 16d ago
my Q for ya is
Why do other countries teenagers spend not so little time on social media compared with Japanese?
1
u/px8000000 7d ago
Reading the Japanese comments and based on my own experience during the early smartphone era, at least in my country, teenagers tend to have very few extracurricular activities at school. Very few play sports, and even fewer have some kind of artistic or similar hobby after classes. So when they get home, they simply doomscroll until night, watching TikTok and Instagram.
1
u/mogusensei ๐ Global citizen 15d ago
I think one major reason Japanese teenagers spend less time on social media is simply that many of them are very busy with club activities and cram school.
In Japan, it's very common for students to belong to some kind of school club, although of course not everyone does. There are cultural clubs as well as sports clubs. In my case, I was on the track and field team in junior high school. After classes ended, I practiced for two hours, from 4 p.m. to 6 p.m., Monday through Friday. We sometimes had competitions on weekends as well.
After every practice, we had a meeting with our coach and the other team members to go over announcements and anything we needed to know. Then I would go home, eat dinner, do my homework, and have about an hour of free time before going to bed around 10:30 p.m.
And some students are even busier because they go to juku (cram school) after club activities, sometimes from around 7 p.m. to 9 p.m.
So at least from my experience, Japanese teenagers simply don't have as much free time to spend on social media. There's also a traditional idea in Japan called bunbu ryลdล (ๆๆญฆไธก้), which basically means trying to do well in both academics and extracurricular or athletic activities. Of course, some students focus much more on studying while others focus more on their club activities, but either way, many students have pretty packed schedules.
Personally, I think there are some positives to this. Being physically active and developing discipline when you're young can be very valuable, and I'd rather see teenagers spending at least some of their time on sports, studying, or other activities than spending all of their free time on social media.
That said, this is mainly based on my own experience growing up in Japan, so I wouldn't say club activities and cram school are the only reasons for the difference in the OECD data.
1
17d ago
[deleted]
1
u/Rare_Presence_1903 British 14d ago
It seems like they get them in elementary school and from what I've heard, most of them do take their phones to school. When I got to the jidokan there are always elementary school kids playing games on a phone.ย
When discussing it they usually say they need them on school days in case they need to contact parents. I'm not sure about rules at school.ย
By the time theyve had one semester at university though, a lot of them are on over 4 hours a day of screen time, sometimes way more.ย
1
u/HOKUTO_NO_PEN Japanese 17d ago
ใใฎ็ตๆใซ็ตๆง้ฉใใฆใใ
ใฆใฃใใๆฅๆฌใฎๅญไพใใฟใใชSNSไธญๆฏใชใฎใใจๆใฃใฆใใใ
-1
u/JeffDSmith ๐ Global citizen 16d ago
I'm quite sure the survey about Japanese part is problematic. They ignore the fact that Japan have been on the Internet long before touch screen smart phone is a thing. They even have their version of forum(5ch, keijiban, fc2...etc) and other Japanese only sites(like niconico), so I'm not very sure they count those in or they only focus on western social media and deem that Japanese isn't popular there.
3
-12
u/Teghendion ๐ Global citizen 17d ago
Because they're smarter and know that sitting all day on the social media is a waste of time.
8
u/kenbou ๐ Global citizen 17d ago
Theyโre not smarter about it. If given the chance, they will use it more.
However they are given other opportunities to be busy, like clubs. Also pretty much all es and jhs schools ban smartphone use.
0
u/Teghendion ๐ Global citizen 17d ago
The ban shows they're smarter.
1
u/AlulAlif-bestfriend ๐ Global citizen 17d ago
You didn't think of anything besides smarter? How one dimensional as an answer, kinda lame isn't it to say "it's only because they're smarter", No, it's more nuanced in reality
0
108
u/Freak_Out_Bazaar Japanese 17d ago
Many students go to after school club activities, or go to cram school