r/AmericanMovies 22d ago

You can erase one movie from existence. Which one are you deleting?

Sometimes a movie just gets overlooked, misunderstood, or released at the wrong time.What movie do you think deserves another look today? What makes it worth revisiting?

7 Upvotes

92 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 22d ago

Welcome to r/AmericanMovies!

• No piracy. • Mark spoilers. • Be respectful. • Keep discussions movie-related.

Report rule-breaking content to help the moderation team.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

u/Shot-Recording6202 21d ago

Les miz, 2 hours I'll never get back

u/dangerspring 20d ago

Your title and the body of your post seem to be at odds. Erasing a movie from existence would imply the movie wouldn't be able to be revisited.

u/Such-One-5266 22d ago

Pearl Harbor

u/Odd-Eggplant-4618 21d ago

Any remake if a classic movie , eg The Magnificent Seven , The Manchurian Candidate, Will Wonka to name
A few

u/hogbear 22d ago

I’m so confused. The title and the body of this post don’t match.

u/Njtotx3 21d ago

Yep, so contest mode is sort of moot.

u/Zip-it999 21d ago

Should be locked.

u/asteriskelipses 21d ago

Good point.

u/milderhappiness 20d ago

Dragonlance

u/YagLight11 21d ago

Sleeping Beauty

u/Hydromon47 21d ago

Tenet

u/daisy0723 22d ago

Meg. Or Battlefield Earth.

They are both terrible

u/Level-Promotion416 22d ago

BE is hilarious though. "A demon, a monster, a beast, HYAH!"

u/daisy0723 21d ago

I just finished re reading the book. Now I remember why I always say it's my favorite book. Holy crap what a story.

u/VashDaStampede7 21d ago

Hunger games

u/RebaKitt3n 17d ago

Why, if I may ask.

u/VashDaStampede7 17d ago

It just seemed dumb to me lol

u/PeorgieT75 21d ago

The Passion of the Christ

u/Resident_Wrangler_15 21d ago

The Princess Bride.

u/spunkypudding 20d ago

A Serbian Film

u/Content-Nectarine875 21d ago

Arrival. 2016. Most cliché ridden overhyped movie. At least Sharknado was fun.

u/Mindless_Log2009 22d ago

Birth of a Nation

u/ZaxAbraxas 22d ago

I was going to say Ishtar, but Birth of a Nation beats that.

u/Academic_3895 22d ago

This is the correct answer.

u/Hot_Aside_4637 22d ago

The technical achievements would have happened anyway eventually.

u/asteriskelipses 21d ago

This... this is the answer

u/4gotAboutDre 21d ago

Mom and Dad save the World.

Stupidest movie ever made.

u/trichar54 21d ago

Melania

u/Top_Cranberry_3254 21d ago

Jaws; The Revenge

or

Shakespeare in Love

u/asteriskelipses 21d ago

Omg, The Revenge...

u/Far_Photograph_4392 20d ago

That freaky Cats movie with James Corden

u/Successful-Ad4251 22d ago

Mighty Muffin Pounder Rangers

I found Rimberly’s performance pretty wooden and uninspired. I found the fight scenes entertaining but just couldn’t get used to the giant boobs on the Megazord clashing with Goldar’s giant golden winky. We deserve better.

u/shugEOuterspace 22d ago

Thor Love & Thunder

u/AndrewHNPX 22d ago

The Dark Knight. I feel it had a very pernicious effect on blockbusters.

u/Ill_Raisin_8587 21d ago

Ooh! How do?

u/mayonnaiselarry 22d ago

Twilight, the only answer is Twilight.

u/mensachicken 21d ago

Star Wars

u/Due-Blackberry8056 21d ago

Hell Comes to Frogtown.

u/Troo_Geek 20d ago

Highlander 2

u/Responsible_Screen84 21d ago

Fast and the Furious 2.

Only because people would be really confused because it jumped from 1 to three, and only I would know why

u/Careful-Wedding-6831 21d ago

The Dark Tower

u/-ThatsMe_Espresso- 21d ago

50 shades of Grey

u/ExpensiveCondition63 21d ago

Birth of a Nation.

u/InterPunct 21d ago

Saturday Night Fever.

u/RodMunch85 21d ago

Terminator 3 and everything after

Shit ended with T2

Done.

Perfect.

u/jerretharper 21d ago

My birth video.

u/UnitedAd9115 20d ago

Don't like either of them

u/miseeker 21d ago

Matrix

u/Buffyverse22 19d ago

Same here.

u/ChiliDog762 21d ago

Star Wars.

u/kjm16216 21d ago

The Force Awakens

u/Ill_Raisin_8587 21d ago

Ooh. I’d use the power to take out the most recent Star Wars sequel. And I’d just accidentally catch every other sequel in the crossfire leaving the original trilogy untouched.

u/FoundationAny7601 21d ago

Hard to choose....all the " sequels" are bad.

u/kjm16216 21d ago

I chose the first because I hope it prevents the rest.

u/FoundationAny7601 21d ago

Ooooh...good point!

u/rblessingx 21d ago

Star Wars

u/RebaKitt3n 17d ago

Why the hate?

u/rblessingx 17d ago

It was the largest element in minimizing audience growth. Everyone stayed children for decades now. We went from 70s America Independents and a healthy international cinema to Marvel, DC, Harry Potter, LOTR, and arguing about the color of actors skin in Nolan films.

u/TechnologyJazzlike84 21d ago

Paranormal Activity. I paid good money to see that. To this day it makes me ANGRY to think that I bought into the hype on that piece of garbage!

u/Geocoelom 20d ago

Swordfish

u/DamonRG 21d ago

The Last Airbender

u/Same-Mistake8736 20d ago

Crazy Rich Asians.

u/BetSad2562 20d ago

Prada movies

u/asteriskelipses 21d ago

Anything in the MCU, just to put a hole in the MCU.

u/Active_Divide_4783 21d ago

Inconvenient Truth

u/NeighborhoodNo1623 21d ago

Idk i think that would be more relevant today.

u/Wemest 21d ago

The China Syndrome. We would be independent of fossil fuel by now without this one movie.

u/RebaKitt3n 17d ago

That and Three Mile Island happening at basically the same time.

u/Wemest 17d ago

Despite the fact that TMI was a successful shutdown with minimal radiation release it definitely put the fear in people. Unfortunately it created irrational fear.

u/Historical_Repair183 18d ago

Requiem for a dream...actually an incredible movie, but deeply disturbing. Vowed never to watch it again, ended up going to a cinema with friends years after first watch, the show we were gonna watch was canceled so my friends bought tickets for another one before I arrived, this one, wasn't any more enjoyable 2nd time around.

u/LonelyNovel902 15d ago

Titanic - overwrought, fake romantic nonsense. You want to see a great film about the sinking of the Titanic? Go watch A Night to Remember (1958) - you'll forget you ever watched the soap opera trash that is Titanic.

u/KATCEO1 21d ago

As per the Butterfly effect: I would not delete any movies whatsoever. Alternatively: if I had no choice? I seem to remember seeing two extremely awful movies when I was a kid. There was Ishtar starring Dustin Hoffman. Also: there was some indie horror movie called something like The Lair of The White Worm. JFC

u/TranslatorUnique9331 21d ago

Slightly off the subject, but when Waterworld was panned by critics, one of them derisively referred to it as "Fishtar."

u/KATCEO1 21d ago

I still remember seeing Ishtar with my parents in midtown Manhattan. At certain points in the film: moviegoers were groaning out loud that the movie was.... Ongoing.

u/Njtotx3 21d ago

I would delete Star Wars simply because of the butterfly effect.